"Well, that escalated quickly."
From someone noting that Beef Ellington had a swollen foot at practice, to his being declared out pretty much 8 weeks into the season...this is how the world of media and social networks go.
In the end, if I'm looking at this objectively -- here's the facts that I see:
1. He has a swollen foot that appears to be the continuence of a nagging situation he's had for a while.
2. Important note: this "nagging situation" did not prevent him from practicing previously or playing (well) in preseason games.
3. He had an MRI and saw some foot specialists. No "dire" diagnosis came out of this.
4. Even AFTER the MRI and the foot specialist visit, he was not ruled out of Monday night's game. Therefore, whatever they saw was not serious. Honestly, I don't think there's any question about it. If he has a 50-50 chance of playing (he's listed as Questionable, not Doubtful or Probable), then it's not serious.
5. Even AFTER the MRI and the foot specialist visit, he was practicing in pads and a helmet. Some are saying we don't know what "limited" means, but some guys limited are not in pads in a helmet, meaning they are just "walking through" and some have pads and a helmet, meaning they can take contact. I don't believe this is all some elaborate ruse by the coaches to fool SD. You are not going to risk injury to your starting RB on a silly "ruse."
All that said, I'm buying at face value that he is Questionable and GTD for Monday.
What that tells me fantasy wise:
a.) if you have a starting RB as a backup, even if that starting RB is so-so, it's probably safe to play him and sit Ellington. 50-50 is still not great odds.
b.) if you don't have a starting RB as a backup and will have to reach for a guy getting limited touches, I think the risk is worth leaving Ellington in your lineup.
Me, my next best option is Bishop Sankey, who may be good down the line but he may not even play on Sunday (our waiver wire takes place Wednesday so I can't pick someone else up.) So for me, I'm rolling with Ellington, because the risk is worth it. Sankey is not likely to get me more than a few points anyway, so might as well shoot high.
Good luck everyone in your games this weekend. This was a fun thread.
I'm still pissed at Glazer for pretending to be a doctor.