Cover shows count for this thread? A local venue has "A Tribute to MTV Unplugged" coming, with cover bands of Nirvana, Pearl Jam, and Alice in Chains. Those were three amazing unplugged performances, so I figured what the heck. Going next Friday.
So I saw this Friday. I would definitely say it is worth the money if you are a fan of these unplugged shows, but it didn't totally meet my expectations. Here's my detailed review of each:
Lithium (Nirvana cover band) - This was the only band that appeared to make any attempt at actually impersonating the band. The lead singer wore a wig and a green sweater. One of the guitars had the same paint job. The drummer wore a wig to look resemble Dave Grohl. The singer actually quoted from the CD between songs. It was more for comedic effect than an actual impersonation, but it was a nice touch. I felt they did a pretty good job recreating the show (they played the whole CD straight through in order), and while I think Cobain is harder to recreating than I thought going in, the singer did a good job at least singing in his style.
Alive (Pearl Jam impersonation) - After the good show that Lithium put on I was excited for Alive, as Pearl Jam is my favorite band. It was probably impossible to meet my expectations, but they certainly missed. Instrumentally, I think they did a pretty good job, and that part was a good show. The singer however, was a total swing and miss. Don't get me wrong, the guy could sing, but he was in the wrong cover band IMO. His voice seemed to be one or two octaves too high all the time. He probably would be awesome in an REO cover band or something, as that is what he reminded me of, but he just couldn't do it for Vedder. They also were not as true to the show, and played a couple of songs off script (Elderly Woman..., one other I can't remember now). Their show was also the shortest. And they didn't finish with Rockin in the Free World, which I really was hoping for.
Mad Alice (AIC cover band) - After the disappointment that was Alive, I was considering leaving for Mad Alice. AIC is my least favorite of the three, and the one I know the material the least. I am sure glad I didn't. They blew me away. I don't know if it was that they were far superior, or lower expectations, or less familiarity of the original, I don't know, but I can see why they were saved for last. They had two guys who while didn't totally recreate their sound, they sure did a good job for a cover band. I had doubts before the show they would pull off the vocal style of the band, but they blew me away. Would definitely listen to more AIC going in next time to be sure I knew all the songs, but I would see these guys again if the price was right.