I agree with the original premise of this thread, but an additional concern that I'm noticing this year is that everyone seems to have gotten the memo that rookies are a good bet.
Traditionally, it's been a smart strategy to get a bunch of rookie lottery tickets and hope a couple pay out. Last year I took a late-round fliers on BTJ (and Adi Mitchell; can't win 'em all), and also picked up Tracy and Irving off the WW. But that strategy becomes a lot riskier when you have to draft those rookies to be in your starting lineup right away.
Jeanty was always going to be a first rounder (and I'm probably out at that ADP), but I fear it may become much harder to find value in the likes of Hampton, MacMillan, Treyveon and now probably Croskey-Merritt.
Yes the super rookie value that used to exist is gone but it doesn't mean they are overpriced- might just be finally priced correctly. It used to be that mobile QBs were a cheat code but people caught on and their ADP shot up but I don't think it ever became unreasonable, it just got them ranked where they should have been all along. Maybe
People who drafted Fields, Richardson and Trey Lance in recent years over in the corner saying, "Hi"
People who drafted Jayden Daniels, Bo Nix and Jalen Hurts say "sup". And as for FIelds, he was a QB1 in ppg in 2022 and 2023.
I get your point, but I wasn't saying that running QBs aren't good, or are never worth drafting. My point was that we went from running QBs being the hipster Konami Code to people overdrafting any QB who was a halfway decent runner, regardless of how good of a passer/real-life QB they were. Lance and Richardson were the apotheosis of that trend. Yeah, Fields put up some good numbers, but he was never a set-it-and-forget-it QB1, and that's what he was being drafted as a couple years ago.
I worry we're seeing a similar trend with rookies, where people are overinvesting in their upside. I really like a lot of the rookies coming up this year, and I want to draft a bunch of them. But I'd be lying if I said I wasn't scared as hell to be relying on them as my RB1 or WR2. Which is not to say I won't end up doing it!
I totally get that and yes some of the rookies and mobile QBs will get overdrafted and bust. But that is just generally true for all types of players. At least mobile QBs and rookies have major upside. What is the hit rate of non-rookie WRs and RBs when we get into rounds 4,5,6, etc.? You are right there is a tipping point where certain archetypes can become overvalued and other guys become values. Where it is, I don't know. Last year according to Fantasy Pros data, of the 14 players most rostered on championship teams, 5 of them were rookies. There were only 2 QBs on that list, Lamar and Jayden. So at least for last year, the data seems to point to still wanting to be aggressive with those players.
I came of age professionally during the dot-com bubble, so my antennae are always up when I see "dumb money" chasing last year's trend (housing bubble, crypto, etc). I don't think we reached the dumb money stage of drafting rookies last year. I fear we may be heading toward it this year.
But you could totally be right. Maybe my fears aren't justified (or are premature). I would love nothing better than to come away from this draft with a bench full of rookies. But I would not want to come away from my draft with, say, Hampton, Henderson and MacMillan in my starting lineup. Not because I think it's impossible for them to justify their ADP, but because I wouldn't want my season to depend on them doing so.
By the way, WR is particularly tricky because there are so many veteran WRs going in the midrounds who also scare the hell out of me (Adams, McLaurin, DK, Worthy, etc). Maybe in those cases it is smarter to take the rookies with upside? Or maybe I focus on RBs and onesies in those rounds and then take a bunch of WR fliers late? Still figuring out my draft strategy