The Saints traded a sixth-round pick for kicker Olindo Mare on Tuesday, a move that could signal the end of John Carney's days in New Orleans. Mare, who spent his first 10 seasons with the Miami Dolphins, has been one of the league's most consistent kickers, making 81 percent of his field-goal attempts and earning a Pro Bowl trip in 1999. He also is among the league's best on kickoffs. He has led the NFL in touchbacks since 1999, including a league-high 24 last season.
Neither Saints Coach Sean Payton nor General Manager Mickey Loomis was available for comment Tuesday. But Carney's agent, Jack Mills, speculated that Carney will likely be granted his release by the Saints. "John is assessing his position, but it's most likely that he will choose to be someplace else," said Mills, who also said he believes the Saints would allow Carney to leave, even if they don't plan to release him. Retirement could be a possibility.
Carney, who has been with the Saints the past six years, had the most accurate season of his 17-year career in 2006, making 25 of 27 field-goal attempts, including the playoffs. But the Saints kept two kickers on the roster for much of the season so Billy Cundiff, who has a stronger leg, could kick off. Carney attempted one field goal from 50 yards or more last season. And Payton chose Cundiff to attempt a 47-yarder at Chicago in the playoffs in a key third-quarter situation. Cundiff was short on that kick in the nasty weather at Soldier Field.
"It's all part of a process, as you know. It was a business decision," Dolphins General Manager Randy Mueller said in a conference call with the Miami media. "I think it's good for everybody. (New Orleans) was one place Olindo wanted to go and kick. They're a really good team, and you know how kickers are. They like to get indoors. Good for him. Olindo is a guy who gave his heart and soul to the Dolphins for 10 years. Sometimes change is a part of this business. We elected to take a different route. It's nothing bad about Olindo. We all like and respect him."
Mare is due $1.5 million in each of the next three seasons, with roster bonuses of $250,000 in 2008 and 2009. The Dolphins already paid his roster bonus this year, hoping they would get some value back in a trade. arney is due $770,000 this year, the final year of his contract. Carney, who turns 43 this month, ranks fourth in NFL history with 1,758 points. He went to the Pro Bowl in 1994 with the San Diego Chargers and kicked in Super Bowl XXIX, making his only field-goal attempt from 31 yards.