This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
Pretty fair trade...I think Trent is the best player in the deal, but if Stewart and Marshall perform to top 15 levels over the next 3 years, team A did very well.
That first trade for Aaron Hernandez is awful. Two late seconds for the best TE in fantasy not named gronkowski or graham. Doesn't make much sense'Dreamer said:
I think they're all close except the Hernandez deal. And even with that one, I've seen some very good players fall to the late 2nd in this year's rookie drafts, so I could see it if he is really sold on a player or two.I agree with you on which side I'd prefer in all of them except the Britt trade. I'm probably overly high on Torrey Smith, but I don't see a huge difference between him and Britt and I like Witten (assuming this is PPR) more than a 2nd round pick.
Another horrible trade for the team trading away Hernandez.'The Real Hipster Doofus said:
Interesting.I think there are too many variables to make this kind of deal two years out, but fortune favors the bold! I think both squads have question marks with their youth. It is entirely possible that Blackmon and Quick and Meachum aren't strong starters in 2013... frankly, I think it is statistically likely that 1-2 of them are not. Your squad could also have only 1-2 starting RBs come 2013... Deangelo was barely startable last year, he will be 30 in 2013, and we do not know Stewart's situation. Basically both of you have possible weaknesses, though his seem to be worse.I like the chances that your squad is better than his next year, but it isn't a given. Most importantly, though, is that a lot can change between now and 2013, so it is very risky to make this kind of deal two years out. The cost isn't crazy, though, you would lose some position in the 1st and lose a 3rd, not a huge deal.'Couch Potato said:
I'll take the McFadden side ALL day. Great deal.
Great deal for the Charles and Dez side IMO. McFadden, Charles, and Dez are all the same tier. The team that gets 2 of those 3 wins for sure.
I'd prefer his WR duo that starts, and the bench WR slightly in your favor, I realize this is probably perceived differently by you and that's certainly understandable. I'd be far more comfy with his TE group, both Davis starting and his bench has a lot more upside.'Couch Potato said:
No chance. Charles/Dez side and it's really not close for me.
Huh? Even thinking that DMC>Charles (it's splitting hairs and personal), Dez>>DJax and Fitz
I have a very high opinion of McFadden and think he has a top 3 year this year. (Go ahead and mock away) I don't see a huge difference between Dez and DJax. There was a 20 point difference between the two last year and I think that DeSean puts up much bigger numbers this year. I've got 'em about equal. Fitz is... well Fitz.
You are welcome for my reply as well. ::no love::
Dez has more upside and I think DeSean maxed out what he could do in 2009. Should be more 1000 yard seasons ahead for him, but Dez has higher potential.
This deal went down in a league I am in (dynasty ppr)... yeah, I use common name\avatar wherever I go - you posers, I know who you really are.
I had to look at the deal two or three times to really get a feel for it once it posted. To me, that is the first sign of it being a pretty fair deal. But I think the Charles\Bryant side helped his TEAM more.
Thank you for your reply!
Percy got stolen. Especially in a PPR.
I wouldnt think thats enough for Percy.'HAM said:
Very interesting. Would love to look back on this one in two years. Seems very fair.
I wouldn't take that for Percy.... but I do think there's a chance Floyd outproduces Harvin this year. With no VJax Floyd could be in for his best season.
Yeah. A very even deal today. 2 years from now....it will probably look the same IMO. Both players have a great opportunity to excel. I think Jordy is slightly under the radar due to all the other targets on that team. But he has emerged IMO as a real go to guy after Jennings. I love Torrey Smith and I own him in multiple leagues so I figured let's diversify and grab Jordy Nelson for a squad. This particular team I have rebuilt a lot this off-season. Thus far I have addedJamal CharlesVictor CruzJordy NelsonOwen DanielsWillis McGahee2.6Giving up1.2 - which would be Martin or Blackmon for me but for me is Jamal Charles instead1.8 - unknown - and Cruz was my prize for this pick and Rice2.2 - unknown - slight trade down to aquire Nelson.Sidney Rice - Traded for 1.8 and McGahee thought that was robbery.Jonathon Stewart - in the Charles deal...done waiting for him.Torrey Smith - For NelsonMy roster now after all this activity is currently (draft in June)BradyEli ManningGabbertCharlesIngramMcGaheePowellMcKnightDez BryantCruzNelsonBoldinBessJames JonesAvantMorganCookDanielsObviously RB is a weakness....but I am still rebuilding this team. Ingram was my 1st round pick last year and while it looks ugly right now.....I still feel he will be a heck of a RB and this year is the year where I find out if he will be a true starter. I anticipate a big role for him this season. If Charles is a stud and Ingram can emerge and a sleeper like Powell comes out of nowhere along with Mcgahee getting one more year as the man....this team may slip into the post season. WR core is stout. Cook could be a monster. Lot's of questions....but this will be a fun team to root for this season.
Any thoughts on this one? Too much to give up for Lynch? Got Lynch too cheap?
With moves like that I can see why he is at the bottom.
I'm flabbergasted
I expect Cutler to be a decent QB1 this year but for a bad team that's horrible.
No thoughts on these huh? Surprised.Team A Gives:LeSean McCoyTeam B Givesoug MartinMichael FloydJ.J. Watt2013 1stTeam A Gives:Matt FlynnKenny BrittTeam B Gives:Jake LockerRGIII
I mean they both look pretty even. I'd rather have Flynn/Britt, but...nothing too controversial here. At all.'Banemorth said:No thoughts on these huh? Surprised.Team A Gives:LeSean McCoyTeam B Gives
It comes down to how people rank them but I have RG3 above Britt and Locker above Flynn. I suppose if you need help at WR then trading RG3/Locker for Britt/Flynn could make sense but I wouldn't do it.I mean they both look pretty even. I'd rather have Flynn/Britt, but...nothing too controversial here. At all.'Banemorth said:No thoughts on these huh? Surprised.Team A Gives:LeSean McCoyTeam B Gives
These are two trades I had actually posted a few months ago except back then they looked like this:Team A gave up:Flynn, Matt GBP QBBritt, Kenny TEN WRTeam B gave up:Locker, Jake TEN QBYear 2012 Round 1 Draft Pick 1.04_______________________________Team A gave up:McCoy, LeSean PHI RBTeam B gave up:Watt, J.J. HOU DE;Year 2012 Round 1 Draft Pick 1.02Year 2012 Round 1 Draft Pick 1.08Year 2013 Round 1 Draft PickFor which I was told how terrible I am and how awful that would pan out. Etc. etc. Just interesting to see how things they change.It comes down to how people rank them but I have RG3 above Britt and Locker above Flynn. I suppose if you need help at WR then trading RG3/Locker for Britt/Flynn could make sense but I wouldn't do it.I mean they both look pretty even. I'd rather have Flynn/Britt, but...nothing too controversial here. At all.'Banemorth said:No thoughts on these huh? Surprised.Team A Gives:LeSean McCoyTeam B Gives
