2012 Offseason Dynasty Trades (1 Viewer)

[solorca]

I'd like some thoughts on this one. I'm team A and took over a team in a league. I have Rodgers, Forte, and Dez Bryant, but need some startable pieces to compete. I think I can still get a very good player at 1.07, and I'm not sold on Blackmon.

Team A Gave

1.02

Ryan Mallett

Team B Gave -

1.07

Peyton Hillis

Deangelo Williams

Santonio Holmes

 

[Banemorth]

I'd like some thoughts on this one. I'm team A and took over a team in a league. I have Rodgers, Forte, and Dez Bryant, but need some startable pieces to compete. I think I can still get a very good player at 1.07, and I'm not sold on Blackmon.

Team A Gave

1.02

Ryan Mallett

Team B Gave -

1.07

Peyton Hillis

Deangelo Williams

Santonio Holmes

I don't put much stock in Hillis/DWilly/Holmes but at 1.07 there should still be someone halfway decent available as this is an incredible draft class.

 

[djb916420]

I'd like some thoughts on this one. I'm team A and took over a team in a league. I have Rodgers, Forte, and Dez Bryant, but need some startable pieces to compete. I think I can still get a very good player at 1.07, and I'm not sold on Blackmon.

Team A Gave

1.02

Ryan Mallett

Team B Gave -

1.07

Peyton Hillis

Deangelo Williams

Santonio Holmes

I don't put much stock in Hillis/DWilly/Holmes but at 1.07 there should still be someone halfway decent available as this is an incredible draft class.

This is a .5ppr RB and 1 PPR WR/TEHillis/dewilly were my rbs5&6. Holmes Wr4

Thought it was pretty even.

 

[loose circuits]

One of my 12 team NON PPRs had 2 now owners take over teams this week and one of them has made 5 trades already...A gave: Best/StroughterB gave: S Rice/K BellA gave: Ingram/4.01C gave: R Bush/A BrownA gave: Winslow/2013 4thD gave: Knox/MoeakiA gave: Witten/Flacco/A Brown/LT/HesterE gave: Flynn/P Manning/Crabtree/Pettigrew/Royster/3.05A gave: S Rice/MoeakiF gave: F Jones/J Ford/2.01

He just pulled another one...A gave up:Smith, Alex SFO QBBurleson, Nate DET WRYear 2012 Draft Pick 2.01Year 2012 Draft Pick 3.05Year 2013 Round 1 Draft Pick from AB gave up:Roethlisberger, Ben PIT QBManningham, Mario NYG WRYear 2012 Draft Pick 4.08Year 2012 Draft Pick 5.08Year 2013 Round 4 Draft Pick from BYear 2013 Round 5 Draft Pick from B

And yet another...A gave up:McCluster, Dexter KCC RBWoodhead, Danny NEP RBB gave up:Baldwin, Doug SEA WRRavens, Baltimore BAL DefYear 2012 Draft Pick 3.09

Baldwin clearly best player in that deal

 

[ebcpastor2004]

Another one from me- Zealots scoring, non PPR. I'm the Giants. We went back & forth a couple of times before we settled on this. Buffalo Bills will giveJohnson, Chris TEN RB Kerley, Jeremy NYJ WR Nicks, Hakeem NYG WR Year 2013 Round 4 Draft PickTo New York Giants forIngram, Mark NOS RB Jones, Julio ATL WR Year 2013 Round 1 Draft Pick (prob late) Year 2013 Round 1 Draft Pick (prob mid)ETA: After recent moves I will now be starting Eli, Forte, CJ2K, JStew, Calvin, Fitz, Nicks, Graham on offense

You got hosed again.

No. Way. Ingram hopes he becomes Chris Johnson & Nicks is way ahead of Jones in my book

You win. Solid trade.

You sticking it to me? I think you're sticking it to me. (unless it's not sarcasm in which case just ignore)Really, if you think I got hosed I'd like to get more of a why you think so rather than just you think so.

 

[Warpig]

16 team PPR/IDP with 40 man rosters. Basically, I saw it as 1.16 for Sean Lee and I upgraded across the board.

I gave up:

Louis Murphy

Emmanual Sanders

Travis Beckum

Erik Walden

Will Smith

rookie pick 1.16

He gave up:

Preston Parker

Mike Thomas

Kellen Davis

Damato Peko

Sean Lee

rookie pick 5.14

rookie pick 6.06

 

[SayWhat?]

One of my 12 team NON PPRs had 2 now owners take over teams this week and one of them has made 5 trades already...A gave: Best/StroughterB gave: S Rice/K BellA gave: Ingram/4.01C gave: R Bush/A BrownA gave: Winslow/2013 4thD gave: Knox/MoeakiA gave: Witten/Flacco/A Brown/LT/HesterE gave: Flynn/P Manning/Crabtree/Pettigrew/Royster/3.05A gave: S Rice/MoeakiF gave: F Jones/J Ford/2.01

He just pulled another one...A gave up:Smith, Alex SFO QBBurleson, Nate DET WRYear 2012 Draft Pick 2.01Year 2012 Draft Pick 3.05Year 2013 Round 1 Draft Pick from AB gave up:Roethlisberger, Ben PIT QBManningham, Mario NYG WRYear 2012 Draft Pick 4.08Year 2012 Draft Pick 5.08Year 2013 Round 4 Draft Pick from BYear 2013 Round 5 Draft Pick from B

And yet another...A gave up:McCluster, Dexter KCC RBWoodhead, Danny NEP RBB gave up:Baldwin, Doug SEA WRRavens, Baltimore BAL DefYear 2012 Draft Pick 3.09

Baldwin clearly best player in that deal

If all those trades are in the same league then it looks like it is non ppr, in which case I assume you either didn't catch that or are thinking of the wrong Baldwin. In fact, it doesn't look to me like there is a "best player" in that deal.

 

[Buckna]

I'd like some thoughts on this one. I'm team A and took over a team in a league. I have Rodgers, Forte, and Dez Bryant, but need some startable pieces to compete. I think I can still get a very good player at 1.07, and I'm not sold on Blackmon.

Team A Gave

1.02

Ryan Mallett

Team B Gave -

1.07

Peyton Hillis

Deangelo Williams

Santonio Holmes

My only criticism would be you pulled the trigger too fast (I make that mistake at times still and I've been playing dynasty for years.) Had other owners (myself included) had known that the 1.02 was up for trade we would have made offers. In the end you may not have received a better offer than the one you took, but at least you would have had other options to consider and counter. WR's are gold in that league.

 

[solorca]

I'd like some thoughts on this one. I'm team A and took over a team in a league. I have Rodgers, Forte, and Dez Bryant, but need some startable pieces to compete. I think I can still get a very good player at 1.07, and I'm not sold on Blackmon.

Team A Gave

1.02

Ryan Mallett

Team B Gave -

1.07

Peyton Hillis

Deangelo Williams

Santonio Holmes

My only criticism would be you pulled the trigger too fast (I make that mistake at times still and I've been playing dynasty for years.) Had other owners (myself included) had known that the 1.02 was up for trade we would have made offers. In the end you may not have received a better offer than the one you took, but at least you would have had other options to consider and counter. WR's are gold in that league.

I don't disagree with that. I am actually really high on Santonio (I think he has a big bounce back), so he was the piece that put me over. You're right though, It probably would have served me well to hold off for a while. It was important to me to get a mid-first round pick, because I am not sold on Blackmon and don't need Luck or RGIII, so I think should be able to get one of the top guys on my board at 1.07.

 

[solorca]

Another one...

Team A Gave:

Mario Manningham

Team B Gave:

Randall Cobb

2.06 (18th rookie pick)

 

[nickdib]

10 team non-PPR, I needed help at RB so i really wanted to make sure i could get T Richardson

I gave:

Miles Austin

Benjarvus Green-Ellis

10th overall rookie pick

I received:

Denarius Moore

Kyle Rudolph

1st overall rookie pick

20th overall rookie pick

2013 3rd round rookie pick

What do you guys think?

 

[gianmarco]

10 team non-PPR, I needed help at RB so i really wanted to make sure i could get T RichardsonI gave:Miles AustinBenjarvus Green-Ellis10th overall rookie pickI receivedenarius MooreKyle Rudolph1st overall rookie pick20th overall rookie pick2013 3rd round rookie pickWhat do you guys think?

I think you should be in jail.

 

[Banemorth]

10 team non-PPR, I needed help at RB so i really wanted to make sure i could get T RichardsonI gave:Miles AustinBenjarvus Green-Ellis10th overall rookie pickI receivedenarius MooreKyle Rudolph1st overall rookie pick20th overall rookie pick2013 3rd round rookie pickWhat do you guys think?

I think you should be in jail.

I concur

 

[inzanitee]

10 team non-PPR, I needed help at RB so i really wanted to make sure i could get T RichardsonI gave:Miles AustinBenjarvus Green-Ellis10th overall rookie pickI receivedenarius MooreKyle Rudolph1st overall rookie pick20th overall rookie pick2013 3rd round rookie pickWhat do you guys think?

Horrible.ETA: Horrible for the other guy. I'd be angry if I was in that league as that's a blatantly unbalanced trade.

 

[jeter23]

10 team non-PPR, I needed help at RB so i really wanted to make sure i could get T RichardsonI gave:Miles AustinBenjarvus Green-Ellis10th overall rookie pickI receivedenarius MooreKyle Rudolph1st overall rookie pick20th overall rookie pick2013 3rd round rookie pickWhat do you guys think?

That would have been a great deal for 1.01 alone. You got Moore, Rudolph and picks for free. Great deal!

 

[Cold Dead Hands]

Ok, now I think people are just making **** up.

 

[nickdib]

Ok, now I think people are just making **** up.

No I'm not

 

[cstu]

Miles Austin is worth more than TRich in non-PPR? That's basically what the trade boils down to.

 

[nickdib]

Miles Austin is worth more than TRich in non-PPR? That's basically what the trade boils down to.

I'm not saying that at all, I'm just saying I'm not making anything up

 

[HAM]

Team A trades picks 1.8 & 3.10

Team B trades picks 1.7 & 4.6

 

[Warpig]

Recent trade in one of my leagues:

Team A gave - 1.02 and 3.08

Team B gave - 1.04 and 1.06



This is a 12 team start 2 QB league. It is assumed Luck is going #1. This guy said he wanted to secure RGIII with the 1.02.

 

[Skeletore Eh]

10 team non-PPR, I needed help at RB so i really wanted to make sure i could get T RichardsonI gave:Miles AustinBenjarvus Green-Ellis10th overall rookie pickI receivedenarius MooreKyle Rudolph1st overall rookie pick20th overall rookie pick2013 3rd round rookie pickWhat do you guys think?

That would have been a great deal for 1.01 alone. You got Moore, Rudolph and picks for free. Great deal!

That would be a ridiculous deal for 1.1 alone, not great. Add in the 20th pick, a third next year, and the upside of young guys like Moore and Rudolph, oh boy am I jealous

 

[cstu]

Recent trade in one of my leagues:Team A gave - 1.02 and 3.08Team B gave - 1.04 and 1.06 This is a 12 team start 2 QB league. It is assumed Luck is going #1. This guy said he wanted to secure RGIII with the 1.02.

Stupid.

 

[Dr. Octopus]

Team F trades 2012 Draft Pick 2.05, D. Clark TE and J. Kerley WR to Team N for R. Wayne WR

 

[cstu]

Team F trades 2012 Draft Pick 2.05, D. Clark TE and J. Kerley WR to Team N for R. Wayne WR

 

[Warpig]

Recent trade in one of my leagues:Team A gave - 1.02 and 3.08Team B gave - 1.04 and 1.06 This is a 12 team start 2 QB league. It is assumed Luck is going #1. This guy said he wanted to secure RGIII with the 1.02.

Stupid.

Yep. Then that same guy offers me two middle 3rd round picks for my 1.08. I told him he threw the market out of whack and it was bad business to come at me with what he did.

 

[solorca]

Trying to get this team in order. Here's another one

Team A Gave - Peyton Hillis

Team B Gave - Jacoby Ford, 2.05

 

[whe48071]

12 team non-PPR

Team A gives- Tim Tebow, Isaac Redman

Team B gives- Leonard Hankerson, James Starks

 

[Couch Potato]

12 team PPR

Fighting Couch Potatoes 4 gave up:

Gerhart, Toby MIN RB

Gettis, David CAR WR

Year 2012 Draft Pick 3.02

Team X gave up:

Brown, Donald IND RB

Year 2012 Draft Pick 3.09

Year 2013 Round 4 Draft Pick from Team X

 

[ExaltedOne]

16 team PPR/IDP with 40 man rosters. Basically, I saw it as 1.16 for Sean Lee and I upgraded across the board.I gave up:Louis MurphyEmmanual SandersTravis BeckumErik WaldenWill Smithrookie pick 1.16He gave upreston ParkerMike ThomasKellen DavisDamato PekoSean Leerookie pick 5.14rookie pick 6.06

Upgraded across the board? No. I'd much rather have what you gave up.

 

[B. Nugget]

12 team PPRFighting Couch Potatoes 4 gave up:Gerhart, Toby MIN RBGettis, David CAR WRYear 2012 Draft Pick 3.02Team X gave up:Brown, Donald IND RBYear 2012 Draft Pick 3.09Year 2013 Round 4 Draft Pick from Team X

CP, you might mention that team X owns ADP for full disclosure.

 

[ExaltedOne]

Another one...Team A Gave: Mario ManninghamTeam B Gave:Randall Cobb2.06 (18th rookie pick)

Maybe it's just me but I have Cobb higher than Manningham in dynasty. 2.06 is just icing.

 

[loose circuits]

Another one...Team A Gave: Mario ManninghamTeam B Gave:Randall Cobb2.06 (18th rookie pick)

pick on the wrong side of this one?

 

[ExaltedOne]

10 team non-PPR, I needed help at RB so i really wanted to make sure i could get T RichardsonI gave:Miles AustinBenjarvus Green-Ellis10th overall rookie pickI receivedenarius MooreKyle Rudolph1st overall rookie pick20th overall rookie pick2013 3rd round rookie pickWhat do you guys think?

Wow you bent him over good. I'd have taken just the 1st for what you gave up, but you got some nice pieces thrown in.

 

[Couch Potato]

12 team PPRFighting Couch Potatoes 4 gave up:Gerhart, Toby MIN RBGettis, David CAR WRYear 2012 Draft Pick 3.02Team X gave up:Brown, Donald IND RBYear 2012 Draft Pick 3.09Year 2013 Round 4 Draft Pick from Team X

CP, you might mention that team X owns ADP for full disclosure.

I'd like to mention that team X owns ADP for full disclosure.

 

[solorca]

Another one...Team A Gave: Mario ManninghamTeam B Gave:Randall Cobb2.06 (18th rookie pick)

Maybe it's just me but I have Cobb higher than Manningham in dynasty. 2.06 is just icing.

That's what I was thinking too. We were going back and forth on different offers and he threw this one out, so I accepted. I am actually pretty high on Manningham, but I like the option of having Cobb a little better...especially since I own Aaron Rodgers as well.

 

[jmo87usc]

Team A Gave:

Demaryius Thomas

Donald Brown

Vereen

Green Ellis

2012 16th Overall rookie pick

Team B Gave:

Darren McFadden

Taiwan Jones

Roy E Williams

2012 36th Overall rookie pick

 

[SproutDaddy]

Non PPR league12 Teams, start qb, 2rb, 2wr, te, 1flex(rb, wr, te), k, defstandard scoring (4pts td for QBs)Team A gave up Dalton, Andy CIN QB; Brown, Antonio PIT WR; Year 2012 Draft Pick 1.11;Year 2012 Draft Pick 2.09Team B gave up Hunter, Kendall SFO RB;Rodgers, Jacquizz ATL RB; Year 2012 Draft Pick 2.01

This trade makes no sense.

 

[whe48071]

12 team IDP non-PPR

Team A gave

Reggie Bush

Steve Smith (CAR)

Team B gave

Jimmy Graham

Rookie 5.6

 

[plastik]

10 team non-PPR, I needed help at RB so i really wanted to make sure i could get T RichardsonI gave:Miles AustinBenjarvus Green-Ellis10th overall rookie pickI receivedenarius MooreKyle Rudolph1st overall rookie pick20th overall rookie pick2013 3rd round rookie pickWhat do you guys think?

That would have been a great deal for 1.01 alone. You got Moore, Rudolph and picks for free. Great deal!

That would be a ridiculous deal for 1.1 alone, not great. Add in the 20th pick, a third next year, and the upside of young guys like Moore and Rudolph, oh boy am I jealous

Total steal. I recently offered this (to a Gator alum)in a 12 team .5ppr and was quickly rejected:TebowDemaryius ThomasMichael Bush1.051.10for 1.011.07

 

[Couch Potato]

12 team PPR

Fighting Couch Potatoes 4 gave up:

Nelson, David BUF WR

Bennett, Martellus DAL TE

Clark, Dallas IND TE

Team X gave up:

Celek, Brent PHI TE

 

[Banemorth]

This one made me throw up in my mouth a little...

Team A Gave:

Cam Newton

Andre Johnson

Team B Gave:

RGIII

Gronk

 

[cstu]

This one made me throw up in my mouth a little...

Team A Gave:

Cam Newton

Andre Johnson

Team B Gave:

RGIII

Gronk

I'm assuming you think the RG3/Gronk side is better. RG3 could easily bust and Cam is proven.

 

[Banemorth]

This one made me throw up in my mouth a little...

Team A Gave:

Cam Newton

Andre Johnson

Team B Gave:

RGIII

Gronk

Maybe I'm too high on Cam Newton but I wouldn't trade him for a rookie QB, even RGIII, and a top tight end. Let alone throw in Andre Johnson to boot.

 

[inzanitee]

This one made me throw up in my mouth a little...

Team A Gave:

Cam Newton

Andre Johnson

Team B Gave:

RGIII

Gronk

Maybe I'm too high on Cam Newton but I wouldn't trade him for a rookie QB, even RGIII, and a top tight end. Let alone throw in Andre Johnson to boot.

I don't think it's a bad trade really. As good as Cam is, Gronk broke records this year too.

 

[Banemorth]

This one made me throw up in my mouth a little...

Team A Gave:

Cam Newton

Andre Johnson

Team B Gave:

RGIII

Gronk

Maybe I'm too high on Cam Newton but I wouldn't trade him for a rookie QB, even RGIII, and a top tight end. Let alone throw in Andre Johnson to boot.

I don't think it's a bad trade really. As good as Cam is, Gronk broke records this year too.

I know and Cam still put up 100 more fantasy points.

 

[inzanitee]

This one made me throw up in my mouth a little...

Team A Gave:

Cam Newton

Andre Johnson

Team B Gave:

RGIII

Gronk

Maybe I'm too high on Cam Newton but I wouldn't trade him for a rookie QB, even RGIII, and a top tight end. Let alone throw in Andre Johnson to boot.

I don't think it's a bad trade really. As good as Cam is, Gronk broke records this year too.

I know and Cam still put up 100 more fantasy points.

I wouldn't compare Cam to Gronk -- QBs score more than other positions. What you do is compare Gronk with every other TE and see how he compares. Same with Cam.

 

[djmich]

Recent trade in one of my leagues:Team A gave - 1.02 and 3.08Team B gave - 1.04 and 1.06 This is a 12 team start 2 QB league. It is assumed Luck is going #1. This guy said he wanted to secure RGIII with the 1.02.

Stupid.

Which side was stupid? In a 2QB 12 team league getting RGIII is huge.

 

[djb916420]

12 Team PPR league:

Team A gave:

Collie

1.11 rookie pick

2013 first rounder

Team B gave:

Bowe

 

[The Captain]

12 Team No-ppr

Team A gave Kendall Hunter, pick 1.08

Team B gave Mendenhall