What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

2015 New York Giants - WK10 Cruz announces season ending calf surgery (1 Viewer)

2015 Schedule

Week 1: Sunday, Sept. 13 – at Dallas Cowboys, 8:30 p.m.
Week 2: Sunday, Sept. 20 -- vs. Atlanta Falcons, 1 p.m.
Week 3: Thursday, Sept. 24 – vs. Washington, 8:25 p.m.
Week 4: Sunday, Oct. 4 – at Buffalo Bills, 1 p.m.
Week 5: Sunday, Oct. 11 – vs. San Francisco 49ers, 8:30 p.m.
Week 6: Monday, Oct. 19 – at Philadelphia Eagles, 8:30 p.m.
Week 7: Sunday, Oct. 25 – vs. Dallas Cowboys, 4:25 p.m.
Week 8: Sunday, Nov. 1 -- at New Orleans Saints, 1 p.m.
Week 9: Sunday, Nov. 8 – at Tampa Bay Buccaneers, 4:05 p.m.
Week 10: Sunday, Nov. 15 – vs. New England Patriots, 4:25 p.m.
Week 11: Sunday, Nov. 22 – BYE WEEK
Week 12: Sunday, Nov. 29 – at Washington, 1 p.m.
Week 13: Sunday, Dec. 6 -- vs. New York Jets, 1 p.m.
Week 14: Monday, Dec. 14 -- at Miami Dolphins, 8:30 p.m.
Week 15: Sunday, Dec. 20 – vs. Carolina Panthers, 1 p.m.
Week 16: Sunday, Dec. 27 -- at Minnesota Vikings, 1 p.m.
Week 17: Sunday, Jan. 3 -- vs. Philadelphia Eagles, 1 p.m.

 
Favorable schedule. I'm going to be pessimistic and predict 8-8.

With this schedule, they should do better than that make the playoffs. If they don't, then Coughlin is probably done.

 
Favorable schedule. I'm going to be pessimistic and predict 8-8.

With this schedule, they should do better than that make the playoffs. If they don't, then Coughlin is probably done.
I think Coughlin will have to make the playoffs this year for sure. I am a Coughlin supporter, but will acknowledge that if they don't make playoffs this year he deserves to be let go.

 
So who do you guys think the Giants will take at 9?

My guess is Dupree from Kentucky (assuming that Cooper and White are gone)

He has the size that the Giants typically look for at DE
They never take who you would expect or want them them to take ... Any receiver other then Cooper would be a huge mistake.

I think they will reach for a DT or DE that hasn't been talked about as a top 15-20 pick and who will not contribute much.

Don't mean to be negative but I hate the way they draft since Reese took over.
Yeah drafting Beckham and Pugh, what a awful GM.

Look, I'm not a fan of Resse's drafts for the simple reason that he can't draft past the 2nd round. Seems every year they might as well just throw away their 3-7th round picks because they're wasted, typically on big project type players that can't have any real impact on day one. As far as his 1st and 2nd round choices, he's pretty lights out.

2014 - Beckham (Top 3 WR after year 1) & Richburg (Our starting center this year)

2013 - Pugh (Starting RT last two seasons) & Hankins (One of the best young DTs in the league right now)

2012 - Wilson & Randle - This was his worst season, Wilson busted and never really got a chance and Randle just can't learn a playbook.

2011 - Prince & Marvin Austin - Prince is a high level CB and Austin is no longer with the team, not a real hit though

2010 - JPP & Linval Joseph - We all know about JPP & Joseph got a huge contract from MIN last year.

My point is, he has had 3 of these picks miss in the last 5 years most of them were solid. I'm still of the opinion Wilson had the talent, he needed the coaching staff to give him more confidence and then as we know the injury. But Reese will draft more than likely 2 solid instant starters on the team in the first two rounds. The reason people can't stand the way Reese drafts is because he doesn't look at needs at all, just BPA. It's also what makes them damn near impossible to predict. You figure... we're drafting a #9. Lets assume Winston and Mariota come off the board before 9, which I think is likely simply because a lot of teams are kicking themselves for passing on Teddy last year, so they'll overdraft Mariota this year. That essentially puts us a pick 7, so presume the Top 7 on our board looks something like this:

1. Leonard Williams

2. Amari Cooper

3. Vic Beasley

4. Dante Fowler

5. Kevin White

6. Alvin Dupree

As for 7 it could be any number of guys really: Danny Shelton, Trae Waynes, Brandon Scherff, TJ Clemmings, Malcom Brown, Landon Collins, could still be Randy Gregory too.

My gut still tells me they'll end up taking Gregory, it just seems like a very "Reese" pick. Reese is the type of guy to look at Gregory and say "We have the coaching and team leadership to keep him out of substance abuse trouble. He showed up light to the combine due to being sick and still put up amazing numbers in every test." The Giants also strike me as the type of evaluation team to pickup on the fact that most of Gregory's "knocks" in the media are mainly bs. People say he gets slow off the line but a lot of that has to do with the way he was used at Nebraska as more of a run stopper than a all out rusher. He's one of those guys who isn't a Top 3 talent at any one thing but is a Top 10 talent at everything. With the way Spags and the Giants run the defense, this is the type of guy they want... someone who could be lined up all over the field. He can be a down DE who can run stop, rush or drop into coverage, he could be a stand up DE, could swap to OLB etc. he can do everything. The Giants friggin love themselves all around guys who can move. Where as a lot of these other pass rushers like Dupree, Beasley & Fowler are just rush OLB/DEs. That's really all they do.

My draft pick prediction is, Amari Cooper if he is available and otherwise Randy Gregory.

People will freak out and get upset because the 'media' has Gregory slipping. But lets not forget similar to someone like Bridgewater last year, Gregory was originally thought to be the top defensive talent in this draft back in December.
Pugh is only OK for a 1st round pick and he regressed this year ... he is the type of guy you can find in the mid rounds not a 1st round talent

Richburg was awful last season - Let's not get ahead of ourselves ...he hasn't done anything yet

Prince - Same as Pugh ... he is ok but shouldn't have been picked as high as he was.

Hankins they had to pick because they let Joseph walk ...It's a wash not a great move

So in 5 drafts you mentioned ...they came away with 2 picks worthy of a 1st round pick JPP after the 2nd round they may as well not even pick.

I don't think they will take any of the guys you listed because they never do

JPP, Beckham, Prince, Wilson , and Pugh were not expected to go as high as they did
Monk, you are far and away the most negative Giants fan I've ever met... and that's saying something.

Pugh didn't really regress, he didn't improve. That said, either way my point stands his natural position is Guard. There is a big gap in the style of play in Guard vs Tackle. I think he could be a Pro bowl level guard he wasn't meant to play tackle though, he just doesn't have a choice right now.

Richburg same thing, he is a true center, he was thrust into the role of Guard by Schwarz getting hurt and it being the only option. Same as with Guard vs Tackle, Guard vs Center is a big difference. Neither of these guys has truly played their position that they're trained in playing properly.

Prince I have no idea what you're talking about, we took him at 19th overall. He was unanimously thought of as a Top 15 draft pick in 2011. He was a steal at 19. He was widely considered one of the top players in the draft that year.

Proof: http://walterfootball.com/draft2011CB.php http://insider.espn.go.com/nfl/draft/rankings/_/year/2011 http://www.cbssports.com/nfl/draft/prospectrankings/TSX/2011

Wilson was also expected to go when he did... he was 33rd on Mayock's board (http://www.nfl.com/draft/story/09000d5d8288a470/article/mike-mayocks-top-100-nfl-draft-prospect-rankings),

JPP was a consensus Top 20 pick, he went at 15... not really a stretch. http://walterfootball.com/draft2010DE.php

And Beckham... what are you talking about? http://walterfootball.com/draft2014bigboard.phpRanked 14th, Mayock had him at 17th http://www.nfl.com/news/story/0ap2000000346744/article/2014-nfl-draft-mike-mayocks-top-100-prospects

And in the end... what the #### does it matter where they were "supposed" to go? Idk about you but some of the guys ranked above Beckham, Jake Matthews, Eric Ebron, Johnny Manziel, Kyle Fuller, Blake BOrtles, Clinton- Dix? I'd rather have had Beckham then and now.
Nobody is concerned that Pugh and Richburg are barley if even 300lbs?

That has to be the 2 smallest combined interior lineman in the league. They are going to get pushed around by some 330 pound beasts.

Pugh is hoping the Giants draft Sherff ... he'd better be careful what he hopes for. Sherff is exactly what they need and Pugh could be out of a job

 
Monk do you do any research before you post? There are a ton of starting centers who are barley 300 lbs.

Richburg is listed at 6’3 298 (Per Ourlads all heights and weights are from there)

Pugh 6’4 307

Here are the interior linemen combos for the NFC East (I’m assuming you think Pugh is going to move to guard)

You should notice that a combo of Pugh & Richburg will not be the smallest combo in the division (I don't have time to look at the whole league)

Dallas

C- Fredrick 312

LG- Leary 318

RG -Martin 308

Philly

C- Kelce 280

LG - Mathis 295

RG -Barbre 305

Washington

C - Litchenstieger 295

LG - Lauvao 315

RG - Chester 315

Giants

C - Richburg 298

LG - Pugh 307

RG - Schwartz 340

Last season’s 4 Pro Bowl centers were:

Mike Pouncey – 6’5 303

Travis Fredrick 6’4 312

Jason Kelce 6’3 280

Nick Mangold 6’4 307

Pro Bowl Tackles

Ryan Clady 6’6 325

Jason Peters 6’4 340

Tyron Smith 6’5 308

Joe Staley 6’6 315

Joe Thomas 6’7 312

Trent Williams 6’5 314

Pro Bowl Guards

Jahri Evans 6’4 318

Kyle Long 6’6 311

Mike Iupati 6’5 331

Zack Martin 6’4 308

Josh Sitton 6’3 318

Marshal Yanda 6’4 315

 
Monk do you do any research before you post? There are a ton of starting centers who are barley 300 lbs.

Richburg is listed at 6’3 298 (Per Ourlads all heights and weights are from there)

Pugh 6’4 307

Here are the interior linemen combos for the NFC East (I’m assuming you think Pugh is going to move to guard)

You should notice that a combo of Pugh & Richburg will not be the smallest combo in the division (I don't have time to look at the whole league)

Dallas

C- Fredrick 312

LG- Leary 318

RG -Martin 308

Philly

C- Kelce 280

LG - Mathis 295

RG -Barbre 305

Washington

C - Litchenstieger 295

LG - Lauvao 315

RG - Chester 315

Giants

C - Richburg 298

LG - Pugh 307

RG - Schwartz 340

Last season’s 4 Pro Bowl centers were:

Mike Pouncey – 6’5 303

Travis Fredrick 6’4 312

Jason Kelce 6’3 280

Nick Mangold 6’4 307

Pro Bowl Tackles

Ryan Clady 6’6 325

Jason Peters 6’4 340

Tyron Smith 6’5 308

Joe Staley 6’6 315

Joe Thomas 6’7 312

Trent Williams 6’5 314

Pro Bowl Guards

Jahri Evans 6’4 318

Kyle Long 6’6 311

Mike Iupati 6’5 331

Zack Martin 6’4 308

Josh Sitton 6’3 318

Marshal Yanda 6’4 315
I also read that Pugh has added 10lbs of lean mass. His listed "official" weights might not be accurate anymore.

First full offseason for Richburg, it would be expected he's stronger and possibly heavier.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Monk do you do any research before you post? There are a ton of starting centers who are barley 300 lbs.

Richburg is listed at 6’3 298 (Per Ourlads all heights and weights are from there)

Pugh 6’4 307

Here are the interior linemen combos for the NFC East (I’m assuming you think Pugh is going to move to guard)

You should notice that a combo of Pugh & Richburg will not be the smallest combo in the division (I don't have time to look at the whole league)

Dallas

C- Fredrick 312

LG- Leary 318

RG -Martin 308

Philly

C- Kelce 280

LG - Mathis 295

RG -Barbre 305

Washington

C - Litchenstieger 295

LG - Lauvao 315

RG - Chester 315

Giants

C - Richburg 298

LG - Pugh 307

RG - Schwartz 340

Last season’s 4 Pro Bowl centers were:

Mike Pouncey – 6’5 303

Travis Fredrick 6’4 312

Jason Kelce 6’3 280

Nick Mangold 6’4 307

Pro Bowl Tackles

Ryan Clady 6’6 325

Jason Peters 6’4 340

Tyron Smith 6’5 308

Joe Staley 6’6 315

Joe Thomas 6’7 312

Trent Williams 6’5 314

Pro Bowl Guards

Jahri Evans 6’4 318

Kyle Long 6’6 311

Mike Iupati 6’5 331

Zack Martin 6’4 308

Josh Sitton 6’3 318

Marshal Yanda 6’4 315
I surprised how small the Eagles are ... Philly list Kelce and mathis at 295 & 298

But Giants list Pugh at 301 & Richburg at 298

 
Have to assume that 0 posts about pick means everyone is as disappointed as me.
Flowers? Are you kidding me ... This guy will not help this year and will never be a LT.
Big and strong but can't pass protect. Poor balance and footwork, lots of penalties.
Local radio and NFL radio think it was one of the worst picks in the 1st round

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Have to assume that 0 posts about pick means everyone is as disappointed as me.

Flowers? Are you kidding me ... This guy will not help this year and will never be a LT.

Big and sting but can't pass protect. Poor balance and footwork, lots of penalties.

Local radio and NFL radio think it was one of the worst picks in the 1st round
I'm not a big fan of the pick, but it's mainly because I felt there were better options on the board at the pick.

When they picked Danny Shelton, Todd Gurley, Shane Ray, Bud Dupree, Damarious Randall, Randy Gregory and Malcom Brown were all still on the board. I just feel like all of those guys fit a bigger need for us than OT.

That said though, going into tonight, Gregory is still on the board. Landon Collins is still there. Jaelen Strong is still there (if they wanted another WR), Eli Harold is there who I'm less than enamored with I'd much prefer Eddie Goldman DT from Florida State.

All I'm saying, is there's still plenty of talent left. Guys that I thought should've gone in the first round and thanks to a few questionable picks by teams like the Colts are still on the board. I'd LOVE to see Gregory slide to them or for them to make a small move up tonight to grab him.

Now, my view on Flowers

He is probably the most physically gifted of the tackles in this draft. He's an absolute MONSTER in run blocking, he'll just take two guys and throw them around like Bane then grab the next guy. That said, he's a massive liability in Pass Protection. As you said, he has poor footwork, his balance isn't terrible I think his worst issue is his hands. He kind of looks like a fat guy falling down the stairs flailing his arms all over the place as he takes his steps back off the snap. I think we just need to hope that he can be coached. With some footwork coaching and hand work coaching he has all the physical talent to be an All-Pro OT. I think that's the reason they take him there. The Giants have A LOT of confidence in their ability to coach up players. They really feel that a guy with no character concerns, natural athletic ability and the drive to be amazing can be coached into his ability. And they've proven this before plenty of times in Coughlin's tenure. Pierre-Paul is a perfect example of a guy who was so raw his raw skills had raw skills. Two seasons later he was an all pro DE and still would be if not for his back injuries. They are hoping to get the same from Flowers.

IF they can fix his footwork and hand work he'll be one of the best tackles in the NFL

If they CAN'T? Well then this will be a pretty big bust pick.

I'm not a massive fan of the pick, but it was no where near one of the worst picks in the 1st round.

The Redskins took a offensive guard at 5th overall with arguably the #1 player still on the board in Leonard Williams. I'm personally happy about this though.

The Colts took a 2nd round grade (at best) WR in Phillip Dorsett when they already have TY Hilton, Duron Carter, Andre Johnson, Donte Moncrief. It made zero sense and was a seriously horrible pick. Malcom Brown WAS ON THE BOARD!

The Vikings took Trae Waynes, a lot of people felt he wasn't even close to the best corner in the draft. He's average at best and not worth anything near a Top 12 pick.

The Browns took a center at 19th overall when they already have Alex Mack who is a Top 3 NFL center. Made so little sense I couldn't even process the pick.

Do I love the pick? Was I jumping up and down in my living room like I was last year after they drafted Beckham? No. I was really really hoping they'd take Gurley it just made so much sense to me.

Do I hate the pick? Also no, this is an immediate upgrade to their offensive line in every way and they could very easily be this years Cowboys.

Their line went from the putrid look of

LT - Will Beatty

LG - John Jerry

C - Weston Richburg

RG - Geoff Schwartz

RT - Justin Pugh

to the much more healthy look of

LT - Will Beatty

LG - Geoff Schwartz

C - Weston Richburg

RG - Justin Pugh

RT - Ereck Flowers

He can develop his pass protection skills at RT for awhile and hopefully in 2-3 years he becomes the dominant tackle his athletic gifts should provide him and can then move to the blind side at LT.

 
Jerry Reese, Marc Ross & Coughlin Post-Draft Interviews

Honestly, I felt like Ross gave the most honest interview with the least amount of generic answers. The way Ross made it sound was that they probably had Scherff right above Flowers neck and neck on the board. But they fully were expecting Scherff to go before them so going into the draft they felt it likely that Flowers was going to be the pick and felt good about that going into last night.

Most of the NFL draft guys seem to agree, athletically he's probably the top OL in the draft. But he's incredibly raw. He'll have quite a few holding calls early in his career unless he makes a magic change to start hitting inside the chest.

 
No one really gets excited about the big uglies

I don’t love the pick but I don’t hate the pick either

The kid is huge and has terrific upside

I thought that I read a while ago the Schwartz prefers the RG spot

Hopefully this pick helps improve the run game right away

 
Also remember, we have one of the best offensive line coaches in the game in Pat Flaherty. It hasn't been until the last few years where the line was a mess because all of our talent retired. But he build the original dominant offensive line of the early 2000s. I have full confidence that if Flaherty saw Flowers and gave his stamp of approval he either knows that he can fix his technique issues or doesn't feel they're as bad as the media scouts seem to say.

 
Not an exciting pick but it does fill a need. With the run on Oline that happened after, would there have been a starter quality player left in the second round? Also it seems like first round linemen are usually considered a reach. The knocks on Flowers seem to be all coachable issues. He just turned 21 and came out as a junior. If he stayed in school another year he could have been the top OT. Sherif was a 5th year senior and he wasn't vastly better. Flowers has the size and the strength. That's a plus when the young guys on the line were knocked for their strength and physical attributes.

Yes, the commentators are saying it was a reach. But most quickly back pedal a bit saying that their grade was if he was picked to be a LT. That they like him better as a RT or G. For now he's not expected to be the LT on the Giants. He's raw but has a higher ceiling than the others. Maybe he was a reach, but I'm confident he'll be a starter and better than any of the backups on the roster.

Remember all the crap talked about the Cowboy's pick of Martin last year? Just hope it works out. I think it will.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
The talking heads at the draft just like to hear themselves talk,I don't put any stock in what they're saying,they're not privy to all the information teams have about these kids and the internal discussions taking place. Kiper said 20 of the 32 first round picks were a "reach",really?! In one breath Dilfer said the Flowers pick was a reach and he DIDN'T like it and before he finished talking he said he LOVED the pick,really?! It's all a crapshoot,we'll see in 3 years how good or bad all these picks were.

 
Ereck Flowers Scouting Report

By Charlie Campbell

Strengths:

  • Powerful run-blocker
  • Heavy hands
  • Excellent ability to sustain blocks
  • Able to kick slide on the edge
  • Can handle speed rushers
  • Anchors well against the bull rush
  • Stonewalls bull rushes
  • Can bully defensive linemen
  • Constantly pushes defenders out of their gap
  • Powerful drive blocker
  • Quick to the second level
  • Can get out and lead a run downfield
  • Intelligent
  • Good hand placement
  • Asset in short yardage
  • Ready to start immediately
  • Good at adjusting to blitz pick up
  • High floor
  • Only 20 years old with huge upside
  • Long arms (34 1/2 inches)
  • Works hard in the weight room
  • Mean streak
  • Scheme versatile
  • Durable
Weaknesses:
  • May not end up a left tackle
  • Not a natural bender
  • Can get too wide with his arms
  • Should improve overall technique; a little raw
  • Summary: The 2015 draft class features a strong group of offensive line prospects, and Flowers is in the running to be the first tackle selected. He played left tackle at Miami, but most are projecting him to move to right tackle in the NFL.Flowers was excellent for Miami over the past few seasons. As a sophomore, he took the left tackle job from Seantrel Henderson and put the former No. 1 recruit on the right side. Flowers went on to be a force for the Hurricanes in 2014 despite having minor surgery on his knee during the season.

    Throughout 2014, the junior was a powerful run-blocker for Duke Johnson. Flowers is extremely powerful and consistently pushes defensive linemen out of their gap. He can maul linebackers and push them around the field. Flowers also is quick to fire to the second level and hit blocks, pull or lead blocks downfield. His raw power with long arms is extremely impressive, and he sustains his blocks through the whistle with a bullying attitude. Flowers' power was on display at the Combine as he had the highest total on the bench press despite having long arms.

    Flowers was also very reliable in pass protection for Miami and was an asset as the blind-side protector for Brad Kaaya. That was apparent against Nebraska when Flowers won the vast majority of his plays against Randy Gregory. Gregory beat him on a couple of plays, but overall, Flowers got the better of the matchup. Flowers also played well against Virginia in late November despite a couple of bad plays against edge rusher Eli Harold. Overall though, Flowers was impressive when going against the best competition he saw all season.

    As a pass-blocker, Flowers is quick enough in his quick slide to negate speed rushers and is strong enough to hold his ground with bull rushers. His agility and impressive length make it harder for rushers to get around him. He could use more work on his technique as his arms can get too wide.

    Flowers could end up as one of the top right tackles in the NFL. Moving to the right side would hide that he isn't quite a natural bender. However, Flowers is only 20 years old and has a ton of upside. He could develop into a starting left tackle and would be one of the most powerful left tackles in the league.

    In the 2015 NFL Draft, Flowers is worthy of being selected in the top 20. Multiple teams have indicated to WalterFootball.com that they have a first-round grade on Flowers. He should hear his name called on Thursday night.

    Read more at http://walterfootball.com/scoutingreport2015eflowers.php#VOeILQQ1kuwyP7ro.99

 
The talking heads at the draft just like to hear themselves talk,I don't put any stock in what they're saying,they're not privy to all the information teams have about these kids and the internal discussions taking place. Kiper said 20 of the 32 first round picks were a "reach",really?! In one breath Dilfer said the Flowers pick was a reach and he DIDN'T like it and before he finished talking he said he LOVED the pick,really?! It's all a crapshoot,we'll see in 3 years how good or bad all these picks were.
True. And it think Flowers was rising up teams boards as they got closer to the draft and the commentators are going with opinions formed months ago.

He also beat out Seantrel Henderson for the LT spot at the U. Seantrel Henderson was a 7th round pick due to off the field issues and played really well for the Bills.

http://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/2015/03/13/seantrel-henderson-leads-all-players-in-performance-based-pay/

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I just saw Pro Football Talk’s 2nd round mock

They have the Giants taking S Landon Collins @ 40 (8th in 2nd round) with the Rams taking DE Randy Gregory @ 41.

I think I would rather the Giants took a chance on Gregory if he was there.

What do you guys think?

 
Not an exciting pick but it does fill a need. With the run on Oline that happened after, would there have been a starter quality player left in the second round? Also it seems like first round linemen are usually considered a reach. The knocks on Flowers seem to be all coachable issues. He just turned 21 and came out as a junior. If he stayed in school another year he could have been the top OT. Sherif was a 5th year senior and he wasn't vastly better. Flowers has the size and the strength. That's a plus when the young guys on the line were knocked for their strength and physical attributes.

Yes, the commentators are saying it was a reach. But most quickly back pedal a bit saying that their grade was if he was picked to be a LT. That they like him better as a RT or G. For now he's not expected to be the LT on the Giants. He's raw but has a higher ceiling than the others. Maybe he was a reach, but I'm confident he'll be a starter and better than any of the backups on the roster.

Remember all the crap talked about the Cowboy's pick of Martin last year? Just hope it works out. I think it will.
Well said. This is how I feel about it too.

 
I just saw Pro Football Talk’s 2nd round mock

They have the Giants taking S Landon Collins @ 40 (8th in 2nd round) with the Rams taking DE Randy Gregory @ 41.

I think I would rather the Giants took a chance on Gregory if he was there.

What do you guys think?
I would be very happy if Collins is available. I don't want Gregory. Unlike with Flowers, I am not confident that Gregory's issues are coachable.

 
I just saw Pro Football Talk’s 2nd round mock

They have the Giants taking S Landon Collins @ 40 (8th in 2nd round) with the Rams taking DE Randy Gregory @ 41.

I think I would rather the Giants took a chance on Gregory if he was there.

What do you guys think?
I would be very happy if Collins is available. I don't want Gregory. Unlike with Flowers, I am not confident that Gregory's issues are coachable.
I disagree, you put enough of a support group around any player and they can come together well. Look at the "troubled" players who have come into this league with questions and succeeded and the ones who failed. The ones who fail, your Josh Gordon's, Johnny Manziel's, Jamarcus Russell's of the world are drafted by terrible organizations with no stability in their infrastrucre. How can a player feel confident in himself and want to play for his team when every year himself, his coaches and his general manager are on thin ice.

Look at the other guys like Dez who went to a good organization with stability in it's ranks and panned out fine.

In my opinion that's all that matters, the Giants are a good organization, arguably one of the best when it comes to this stuff. I think with JPP, Beason, Coughlin, Eli, Beckham, Cruz etc. all really high character guys on this team that Gregory would have constant motivation to play better for his team. The Giants aren't like the Browns where you hear guys like Joe Thomas and Joe Haden come out talking about how Johnny is a train wreck. Please, if one of Coughlin's players did that he'd have their balls in a jar of pickle juice in his office.

If the Giants get Gregory I'll be so happy I'll shed real tears for the first time in years. Because I think from a talent perspective he is far and away the best defensive lineman in this draft. If he can be helped with his character concerns, he can become a multiple All-Pro talent. Collins on the other hand is a decent run stopping safety. I personally thought Randall was a better prospect but he went off the board last night.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I just saw Pro Football Talk’s 2nd round mock

They have the Giants taking S Landon Collins @ 40 (8th in 2nd round) with the Rams taking DE Randy Gregory @ 41.

I think I would rather the Giants took a chance on Gregory if he was there.

What do you guys think?
I would be very happy if Collins is available. I don't want Gregory. Unlike with Flowers, I am not confident that Gregory's issues are coachable.
I disagree, you put enough of a support group around any player and they can come together well. Look at the "troubled" players who have come into this league with questions and succeeded and the ones who failed. The ones who fail, your Josh Gordon's, Johnny Manziel's, Jamarcus Russell's of the world are drafted by terrible organizations with no stability in their infrastrucre. How can a player feel confident in himself and want to play for his team when every year himself, his coaches and his general manager are on thin ice.

Look at the other guys like Dez who went to a good organization with stability in it's ranks and panned out fine.

In my opinion that's all that matters, the Giants are a good organization, arguably one of the best when it comes to this stuff. I think with JPP, Beason, Coughlin, Eli, Beckham, Cruz etc. all really high character guys on this team that Gregory would have constant motivation to play better for his team. The Giants aren't like the Browns where you hear guys like Joe Thomas and Joe Haden come out talking about how Johnny is a train wreck. Please, if one of Coughlin's players did that he'd have their balls in a jar of pickle juice in his office.

If the Giants get Gregory I'll be so happy I'll shed real tears for the first time in years. Because I think from a talent perspective he is far and away the best defensive lineman in this draft. If he can be helped with his character concerns, he can become a multiple All-Pro talent. Collins on the other hand is a decent run stopping safety. I personally thought Randall was a better prospect but he went off the board last night.
Will Hill is the pin to burst your bubble.

Granted each individual is different. Some choose to get their act together some don't. Will Hill was given great opportunities with the Giants and he really showed a lack of appreciation towards the Giants by continuing to fail drug tests. He seems to have stayed clean the past year with the Ravens. But I think it's only a matter of time till he fails another pee test.

 
I just saw Pro Football Talks 2nd round mock

They have the Giants taking S Landon Collins @ 40 (8th in 2nd round) with the Rams taking DE Randy Gregory @ 41.

I think I would rather the Giants took a chance on Gregory if he was there.

What do you guys think?
I would be very happy if Collins is available. I don't want Gregory. Unlike with Flowers, I am not confident that Gregory's issues are coachable.
I disagree, you put enough of a support group around any player and they can come together well. Look at the "troubled" players who have come into this league with questions and succeeded and the ones who failed. The ones who fail, your Josh Gordon's, Johnny Manziel's, Jamarcus Russell's of the world are drafted by terrible organizations with no stability in their infrastrucre. How can a player feel confident in himself and want to play for his team when every year himself, his coaches and his general manager are on thin ice.

Look at the other guys like Dez who went to a good organization with stability in it's ranks and panned out fine.

In my opinion that's all that matters, the Giants are a good organization, arguably one of the best when it comes to this stuff. I think with JPP, Beason, Coughlin, Eli, Beckham, Cruz etc. all really high character guys on this team that Gregory would have constant motivation to play better for his team. The Giants aren't like the Browns where you hear guys like Joe Thomas and Joe Haden come out talking about how Johnny is a train wreck. Please, if one of Coughlin's players did that he'd have their balls in a jar of pickle juice in his office.

If the Giants get Gregory I'll be so happy I'll shed real tears for the first time in years. Because I think from a talent perspective he is far and away the best defensive lineman in this draft. If he can be helped with his character concerns, he can become a multiple All-Pro talent. Collins on the other hand is a decent run stopping safety. I personally thought Randall was a better prospect but he went off the board last night.
Will Hill is the pin to burst your bubble.Granted each individual is different. Some choose to get their act together some don't. Will Hill was given great opportunities with the Giants and he really showed a lack of appreciation towards the Giants by continuing to fail drug tests. He seems to have stayed clean the past year with the Ravens. But I think it's only a matter of time till he fails another pee test.
No worry, we traded for Collins. Love the pick.

 
I'm psyched out of my mind about Landon Collins !!

I would have been fine with the Giants taking Collins in the 1st after Scherff was taken,

To get him in the 2nd makes the Flowers pick better

 
Life has been damn busy, so I dont profess to know that much about Flowers, but it seems like he is a great powerful run blocker, at the least. And at the Tackle position.

Most gifted (aka Tremendous Upside) in the draft.

How many times have we not gotten that yard? That push on the oline?

If Flowers can, with all his physical skills, become just an adequate pass blocker, the run game is boosted hugely while setting up much better play action opportunities to get ODB time for separation AND there will be that split second more for pure passing at times because the run should be more effective.

Thats the floor, apparently. You can't train natural ability and he has it in droves. Let's hope he can learn and evolve.

What is the character side? He a good guy, hard worker, good teammate? Thx

 
Life has been damn busy, so I dont profess to know that much about Flowers, but it seems like he is a great powerful run blocker, at the least. And at the Tackle position.

Most gifted (aka Tremendous Upside) in the draft.

How many times have we not gotten that yard? That push on the oline?

If Flowers can, with all his physical skills, become just an adequate pass blocker, the run game is boosted hugely while setting up much better play action opportunities to get ODB time for separation AND there will be that split second more for pure passing at times because the run should be more effective.

Thats the floor, apparently. You can't train natural ability and he has it in droves. Let's hope he can learn and evolve.

What is the character side? He a good guy, hard worker, good teammate? Thx
I've read he's a workout warrior. Very quiet. Instead of going out, he'd be getting in a second workout. High motor.

 
Hell, at this rate Gregory might skip to us in the third.
I doubt it but I hope you are right
He didn't but I like the pick of Owamagbe Odighizuwa. Should've been a late first-early 2nd round pick. He's a beast at run stopping for a DE. I can see the Giants acutally sloting him into DT in the middle on a lot of snaps. In Spags old 3 or 4 DE DLine sets he used to run so much.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Hell, at this rate Gregory might skip to us in the third.
I doubt it but I hope you are right
He didn't but I like the pick of Owamagbe Odighizuwa. Should've been a late first-early 2nd round pick. He's a beast at run stopping for a DE. I can see the Giants acutally sloting him into DT in the middle on a lot of snaps. In Spags old 3 or 4 DE DLine sets he used to run so much.
I don't know much about him

He seems to fit a need however I am a bit worried about his injury history

Solid draft for the Giants

 
Very happy so far.
Yeah, I initially was upset about the Flowers pick because I felt like he was a huge reach there. But they've more than made up for it by somehow having two first round talents at huge need positions fall right into their laps in the 2nd and 3rd round. It's a little upsetting that they had to forfeit their 4th round pick to go up and get Collins but I think it was likely worth it. I doubt they made their pick at 9 thinking he'd be available at the top of the 2nd round.

 
Giants throw away their 5th round pick on S MYKKELE THOMPSON ... Basically non existent on NFL.com and the Internet.

If you are going to throw away a pick why not take a chance on La'el Collins or Jay Ajayi

 
Giants throw away their 5th round pick on S MYKKELE THOMPSON ... Basically non existent on NFL.com and the Internet.

If you are going to throw away a pick why not take a chance on La'el Collins or Jay Ajayi
The Giants have 3 S on the roster and you complain about them drafting one?

 
Life has been damn busy, so I dont profess to know that much about Flowers, but it seems like he is a great powerful run blocker, at the least. And at the Tackle position.

Most gifted (aka Tremendous Upside) in the draft.

How many times have we not gotten that yard? That push on the oline?

If Flowers can, with all his physical skills, become just an adequate pass blocker, the run game is boosted hugely while setting up much better play action opportunities to get ODB time for separation AND there will be that split second more for pure passing at times because the run should be more effective.

Thats the floor, apparently. You can't train natural ability and he has it in droves. Let's hope he can learn and evolve.

What is the character side? He a good guy, hard worker, good teammate? Thx
I've read he's a workout warrior. Very quiet. Instead of going out, he'd be getting in a second workout. High motor.
Life has been damn busy, so I dont profess to know that much about Flowers, but it seems like he is a great powerful run blocker, at the least. And at the Tackle position.

Most gifted (aka Tremendous Upside) in the draft.

How many times have we not gotten that yard? That push on the oline?

If Flowers can, with all his physical skills, become just an adequate pass blocker, the run game is boosted hugely while setting up much better play action opportunities to get ODB time for separation AND there will be that split second more for pure passing at times because the run should be more effective.

Thats the floor, apparently. You can't train natural ability and he has it in droves. Let's hope he can learn and evolve.

What is the character side? He a good guy, hard worker, good teammate? Thx
I've read he's a workout warrior. Very quiet. Instead of going out, he'd be getting in a second workout. High motor.
That's encouraging. To see this and intelligence as a strength, coupled with his really young age has to get you a bit juiced. Wouldn't it seem well within reason that, with the coaching staff we have, he becomes at least decent in protection? And we know he can mash in the run game... which sets up the vertical pass.

Really like the pick. If it works Ill be fifty and he will be in his prime (42 now).

 
Giants throw away their 5th round pick on S MYKKELE THOMPSON ... Basically non existent on NFL.com and the Internet.

If you are going to throw away a pick why not take a chance on La'el Collins or Jay Ajayi
What I'm reading is he was originally a QB. Made leaps his senior year when Coach Strong took over the DBs. Had a great pro day. Really fast. Blurbs about his ability remind me of Will Hill minus the off the field issues.

My guess is the Giants feel they found in him a gem in the rough and it only takes one other team to think the same for them not to get him. Or if they did draft what should have been a FA in the 5th, so be it. They've had better luck recently with UFA types than they have with mid-late round draft pics anyway!

 
Giants throw away their 5th round pick on S MYKKELE THOMPSON ... Basically non existent on NFL.com and the Internet.

If you are going to throw away a pick why not take a chance on La'el Collins or Jay Ajayi
The Giants have 3 S on the roster and you complain about them drafting one?
Are you kidding me ? There are a at least 5-10 unsigned FA's that would help more then this guy will.

Best case you see this guy on the field in 2 years

 
Player has all the control in this situation. The money will pretty much be the same from every team. It's going to be where he has a chance to start that will be the deciding variable. That's where he can make some of the bonus money UDFA get based on playing time.

There are other teams where he'd be a sure bet to start. Best the Giants can offer is to compete with Flowers and Pugh for a starting spot. I'd like Collins but it'd be a shock if he went with the Giants since there are situations elsewhere that make for better opportunity.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
http://www.bigblueview.com/2015/5/8/8572937/new-york-giants-rookie-mini-camp-report-day-1-ereck-flower-landon-collins-owa-odighizuwa

The very first thing I noticed was that during the initial defensive drill second-round pick Landon Collins. in his first practice, was helping second-year player Bennett Jackson get lined up properly.

It was admittedly only one workout against a majority of players who will never play a down in the NFL, but Coughlin said he saw enough to believe Collins can be much more than a box safety, an impression which is part of the reason Collins fell to the Giants at No. 33.

"What I saw today went back to what I really do believe, and that is that he can play in the middle of the field, he can play in the deep half, he can do those things as well as come down and be a physical force in the tackle box," Coughlin said.

  • Third-round pick Owamagbe Odighizuwa is really quick off the snap. Either that or offensive tackle Sean Donnelly, one of the undrafted free agent signees, is really slow. On three successive plays during an abbreviated 11-on-11 stretch Odighizuwa had the corner before the seemingly slow-footed 6-foot-8 Donnelly was out of his stance.
  • CFL center Brett Jones, who signed a three-year contract, was getting an earful from offensive line coach Pat Flaherty about dropping his hands between punches in a blocking sled drill.
  • First-round pick Ereck Flowers is a monstrously large person who moves very well for a 329-pounder. Coughlin believes Flowers will do well in pass protection. "He's a big man. You're going to have to navigate a lot to get around him," Coughlin said. Read absolutely nothing into this, but Flowers spent his first practice lined up at left tackle.
  • Wide receiver Geremy Davis, drafted in the sixth round, was being used as a gunner during punt drills.
  • Matt LaCosse, a tight end from Illinois who was one of the six UDFAs to sign contracts, is a player to remember. He looks like a guy who can catch the ball well, might be able to stretch defenses while lined up in the slot and, while you can't judge blocking in shorts and t-shirts, showed a willingness to do that.
 
It looks like the Texans are going to release safety DJ Swearinger. Does anyone know anything about his game and if he might fit in with the Giants

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top