Slow day in here.....
Read this yesterday on the Ath letic. Thought some of you would enjoy this one. The story of Bowling Green hiring Mike Jinks
Bad hires happen all the time. Sometimes the can’t-miss coach is not up to the task of resurrecting a blueblood, or the hot up-and-coming coordinator ends up in over his head once he takes on the head coaching title.
But there is no shortage of confounding hires — coaches whom everyone questions at the time of their hire, before they go out there and end up proving everybody right. With UConn and Randy Edsall parting ways just two weeks into the 2021 season, it is worth revisiting that hire, and several others like it, to see just how correct the media and fans were in their prognostications.
This isn’t to say “I told you so,” but every now and then, these things are just so predictable. (Hey, it’s not like we’re knocking Nebraska for hiring Scott Frost or Texas for hiring Tom Herman. Most people thought they’d succeed.)
Sometimes the writing has been on the wall from previous stops, or the red flags are abundantly obvious to those who actually look into them.
These are not the worst coaching hires of the past 10 years, just the most confounding. We chose the years 2010-19, giving 2020 hires more runway to make good or bad impressions.
5. Gary Andersen, Utah State, 2019-20
The record: 7-9, (6-5 in MWC)
The ending: Fired after an 0-3 start in 2020
This is one where you simply ask: What exactly was Utah State expecting? The hire was more perplexing than damaging, as Andersen’s first Aggies team managed to go 7-6 after Matt Wells left for Texas Tech, before opening 2020 with three losses by an average of 28.3 points per game. (And Utah State made what looks like a strong hire in Blake Anderson after firing Gary Andersen.) For all of Andersen’s success the first time around in Logan, going 26-24 in four years before leaving for Wisconsin after the 2012 season, the red flags were there. The search was a mess. And Andersen had left the Badgers abruptly after two seasons, overseeing a 59-0 loss to Ohio State in the Big Ten title game before departing for Oregon State four days later. (And struggling with Wisconsin’s academic requirements, which he probably should have known about before taking that job). None of this even gets into his Oregon State tenure from 2015-17, when he resigned after a 1-5 start in his final season and left $12.6 million in guaranteed buyout money on the table. He was a loose cannon with his thoughts while in Corvallis, even if some found the sentiments admirable. And he never finished better than 4-8 with the Beavers, so it remains unclear what exactly the Aggies thought they were getting in Andersen the second time around.
4. Jeremy Pruitt, Tennessee, 2018-20
The record: 16-19 (10-16 in SEC)
The ending: Fired in January 2021 amid an internal investigation into potential recruiting violations
This one was doomed from the start, a coaching search that will likely have multiple books (and maybe even a “30 for 30”) documenting the zaniness that was Black Sunday in Knoxville. The CliffsNotes version: John Currie hired Greg Schiano, fans revolted, and both men lost their jobs. Phillip Fulmer then took over as athletic director and hired Pruitt, who was no better than the Vols’ sixth coaching choice, and the results on the field were once again outdone only by the craziness off it. Pruitt looked and sounded overwhelmed, losing to teams that Tennessee had no business losing to (Vanderbilt, Georgia State, Arkansas). His press conferences regularly became must-see TV for all the wrong reasons, often toeing the line of throwing his guys under the bus. In the end, the school might have thought it was a better bargain to have been exposed to NCAA sanctions and the uncertainty that that brings a program than it was to keep Pruitt (and Fulmer) around any longer to dig it in an even deeper hole — which says all you need to know about this sordid chapter in school history.
3. Randy Edsall, UConn, 2017-21
The record: 6-32, (2-22 in AAC) (UConn did not play in 2020)
The ending: Announced on Sept. 5 that he would retire at season’s end, before the school announced the next day that it came to the “mutual decision” for Edsall to step down immediately after an 0-2 start
Who in their right mind was excited about the idea of Edsall returning to UConn? Yes, he helped get the program off the ground during his first stint from 1999-2010, but his ugly exit, coupled with an underwhelming tenure at Maryland, did not exactly endear him to Huskies fans the second time around. Edsall’s six wins are, frankly, a mirage, as three of those wins came against FCS teams. As colleague Chris Vannini noted, 10 losses came by 40 points or more, and the 2018 defense ranked statistically among the worst in the sport’s history. Then there were the incentives, which got more ridiculous with each line. And the fact that Edsall was extended two years this past March. It was a bad job that was made worse by the move to become an independent, but the Edsall tenure ensures that this will be the least attractive job on the market come the end of the season. And it proves — much as Andersen’s second time around at Utah State did — that no sport trips over itself trying to recreate the past more than college football does.
2. Charlie Weis, Kansas, 2012-14
The record: 6-22 (1-18 in Big 12)
The ending: Fired after a 2-2 start in 2014
The scene: Weis’ introductory press conference in December of 2011. The lasting words from AD Sheahon Zenger: “We believe that we needed a power surge, and that power surge is Coach Weis.” Weis then promptly got up to the podium and uttered the immortal first words: “I need my hip replaced.” Weis picked up where he left off at Notre Dame, going 1-11 in his debut season in Lawrence, and 0-9 in Big 12 play. Things didn’t get much better from there, with colleague Max Olson outlining the scholarship disadvantage that Weis put his successor in by booting 20 players off the team, bringing in 27 juco transfers his first two seasons and, by the time new coach David Beaty took over, leaving the Jayhawks with just 38 scholarship players. If you ever want to get a Kansas alum really going, just ask him or her about Weis and the damage that he inflicted upon the program. The Jayhawks, in many ways, are still reeling from the Weis era, although their last coach didn’t exactly help matters during his brief tenure in Lawrence. …
1. Les Miles, Kansas, 2019-20
The record: 3-18 overall (1-16 in Big 12)
The ending: “Parted ways” with Kansas in March 2021 after sexual harassment allegations surfaced in an LSU-commissioned report from his time with the Tigers
Yes, the same program occupies the top two spots on this list. And that should tell you everything you need to know about how Kansas football got to the place it has been for much of the past decade. Every once in a while, predictable situations turn out to be even worse than the potential worst-case scenario everyone describes. That’s the Miles tenure at Kansas. No AD wanted to touch Miles after his 2016 firing from LSU … other than then-new Kansas AD and old Miles buddy Jeff Long, that is. And it turned out — thanks to the botched firing of previous Beaty — that Long never really ran an actual coaching search when targeting Miles. The move ended up costing both men their jobs, as Miles’ lackluster performance as a coach ended up being outdone by his checkered past, which came to light in March in two public reports commissioned by LSU that alleged that Miles made sexual advances toward two female students in 2013 while he was the Tigers’ coach. The atmosphere inside Kansas’ football facility was awkward enough even without all of the losing, too. It will be hard to outdo this performance, from beginning to end.
Honorable mentions: Bobby Petrino proved that leopards don’t change their spots during his second stint at Louisville (2014-18). … Scottie Montgomery (2016-18) wasn’t exactly viewed as a terrible choice when East Carolina hired him, but the firing of Ruffin McNeill was, and remains, inexplicable. The program is still recovering from it.
… The decision behind Bowling Green’s hiring of Mike Jinks (2016-18) — the Toledo Blade reported that then-AD Chris Kingston Googled top offenses, then hired the most affordable assistant from Texas Tech’s staff — is an all-timer in its lack of due diligence. … USC’s failure to properly vet Steve Sarkisian (2014-15), and Washington’s immediate upgrade when he left, played out as bad (and as good) as the Trojans (and Huskies) could have hoped for. … Mike Riley’s Nebraska tenure (2015-17) went better than Frost’s has so far, but it still didn’t go well, and then-AD Shawn Eichorst was widely questioned at the time for hiring the coach most opposite Bo Pelini in style, and not the best coach available.