Edge defenders (4)
In: Aidan Hutchinson, Marcus Davenport, Al-Quadin Muhammad, Nate Lynn*
Out: Isaac Ukwu, Mitchell Agude
Injured: Josh Paschal, Ahmed Hassanein
Practice squad potential: Ukwu, Lynn
Analysis: Witnessing a frustrating lack of pass-rush production during the preseason finale, I posted on social media that I was strongly considering putting free agent Za’Darius Smith on my 53-man projection.
There was some truth to the jestful comment. Following Hassanein’s injury, the path is clear to re-add last year’s trade deadline acquisition, and I don’t think there’s any denying the Lions would benefit from a little more pocket disruption on the depth chart.
Do I anticipate a deal getting done ahead of Tuesday afternoon’s cutdown deadline? Not necessarily. So, for the time being, I’m giving the spot to Lynn while using one of those two IR spots for Hassanein. The rookie is expected to be down for a bit with the pec injury he suffered earlier this month.
Lynn is still developing and doesn’t have massive upside. However, he showed he can bring a little something to the pass-rush with double-digit pressures and a sack during the preseason, even if I'm skeptical it will translate against starting-caliber offensive tackles. On the plus side, he has the right body type to contribute to multiple special teams, enhancing his game-day value.
Defensive tackles (6)
In: DJ Reader, Tyleik Williams, Pat O’Connor, Roy Lopez, Chris Smith, Mekhi Wingo
Out: Keith Cooper Jr., Myles Adams, Brodric Martin
Injured: Alim McNeill
Practice squad potential: Cooper, Adams, Martin
Analysis: Here’s where I anticipate differing from some of my colleagues.
Wingo’s activation off the physically unable to perform list admittedly threw a wrench in my previous projections. By getting medical clearance so late in the offseason, he received zero team reps in the two practices he participated in and wasn’t active for Saturday’s game.
I asked Campbell about Wingo ahead of Thursday’s practice, which failed to add any clarity to the situation.
“He’s done all he can do to this point, and now it’s time for football to see where he’s at,” Campbell said. “I mean, it’s tough. It’s tough. There’s no easy answer to that. I don’t know if we can find out fast enough, so we have to make a decision there.”
Wingo has an unconventional body type for the position, and his production as a rookie last year was nondescript. It’s reasonable to think the team could get him through waivers. However, with Detroit’s former defensive coordinator running the Jets, and Wingo’s position coach from last season, Terrell Williams, now the d-coordinator in New England, that familiarity adds some risk to the equation. For that reason, I have Wingo making it.
I’m also going with Smith over camp darling Cooper. Yes, Cooper saw a lot of first-team work as an inside/outside option in the schematic mold of Paschal. Regardless, the undrafted rookie’s preseason performance was consistently underwhelming. Because his best work came on the practice field, away from the eyes of other teams' talent evaluators, it’s unlikely he gets claimed. That will allow the Lions to retain him on the practice squad and continue his development there.
Smith also got plenty of work with the first-team defense and was the go-to choice whenever Williams missed time or needed a breather. I thought Smith had a slow start to camp, but one of the stronger surges across the finish line. That matters.
As for someone who can fill the inside-out role up front, it’ll be O’Connor. He can line up anywhere across the front and give you good work, even if his best contributions on the edge will be against the run.
Linebackers (6)
In: Jack Campbell, Alex Anzalone, Derrick Barnes, Grant Stuard, Trevor Nowaske, Zach Cunningham
Out: Anthony Pittman, DaRon Gilbert
Injured: Malcolm Rodriguez, Ezekiel Turner
Practice squad potential: Pittman, Gilbert
Analysis: The corps has been relatively stable since Cunningham made a strong impression at the start of camp.
The starting trio needs no introduction, while commentary will be limited. We know Anzalone is all-in for this year after having the final year of his contract guaranteed. However, that tweak to the deal's language formally puts the kibosh on extension talks until next offseason per CBA guidelines.
As for Barnes, who netted a sparkling three-year contract this past offseason, the Lions are tweaking his role once again. After spending 2024's camp working from the line of scrimmage, he’s primarily back to operating off the ball. The most exciting component of that shift is his potential as a blitzer, which really extends to the entire starting group.
With the backups, Stuard is awesome. I’m a big fan of what he brings to the table, both the skill set and the emotional energy. He flies around the field, loves to hit, and has exceptional first-step quickness. He’s an underrated offseason addition who provides depth and elite special teams contributions, potentially even as a kick returner. There's legitimate fan favorite potential here.
Meanwhile, Nowaske quietly had some of the biggest developmental growth this offseason. He’s diagnosing better, putting him in positions to make more stops in the run game. Plus, he has a knack for the blitzing element of the position.
This is a strong group. And at some point in October, maybe early November, the depth will only get better with the reintroduction of Rodriguez, who remains on the fast track back from last year’s ACL tear.
As noted in my previous projection, I hated having to cut Ezekiel Turner. I think highly of his special teams production, which will matter more this season with the kickoff rule adjustments. Unfortunately, the decision was likely taken out of the Lions' hands after he suffered a potential Achilles injury in Saturday’s game.
Defensive backs (9)
In: Terrion Arnold, DJ Reed, Amik Robertson, Brian Branch, Kerby Joseph, Rock Ya-Sin, Avonte Maddox, Khalil Dorsey, Loren Strickland
Out: Luq Barcoo, Allan George, D.J. Miller, Tyson Russell, Nick Whiteside, Erick Hallett, Ian Kennelly, Morice Norris
Injured: Ennis Rakestraw, Dan Jackson
Practice squad potential: Hallett, Russell, Whiteside, Kennelly, Norris, George
Analysis: The starting five, including Robertson in the slot, has effectively been set in stone since the start of camp. It’s the depth that’s been fluid and one of the most interesting areas to follow.
At the start of camp, Maddox was safety three, while Rakestraw and Ya-Sin were primed to battle to be the first outside corner off the bench, at least until Rakestraw went down with an injury.
Then, further down the depth chart, what was supposed to be a five-horse race for a fourth safety job saw one horse drop out early when Hallett was shifted to the slot. Then it was three when Jackson was lost for the season. Norris’ scary concussion in the second preseason game thinned the situation out even further.
There has been more deck shuffling, beyond Hallett. Ya-Sin unexpectedly shifted to safety, despite no prior experience, and Maddox flipped back to cornerback, more specifically, nickel. Defensive coordinator Kelvin Sheppard suddenly has a lot of versatility at his disposal.
Maddox and Ya-Sin are no-brainers for roster spots. The additions have delivered on expectations after signing this offseason. And we’re comfortable sliding Khalil Dorsey into the mix, as well, following his recent activation from the PUP list. He’s been one of the best gunners in the league, playing a prominent role on Detroit’s record-setting punt coverage unit in 2024.
With the final spot, we’re flipping from Kennelly to Strickland. It was a close call all camp, but we were swayed by Strickland’s strong finish in Saturday’s game, where he racked up nine tackles. Kennelly, the Michigan native and former Grand Valley State standout, has undeniable promise with a prototypical build and elite athleticism. Still, he needs a little more seasoning before he’s ready to contribute, and there's minimal risk he gets claimed off waivers. Strickland, who saw time on special teams last year, can help those units now if active on game day.
Hallett is my toughest cut. He showcased so much unexpected versatility through camp. If the Lions opt to keep six receivers, which would be a reasonable approach, he's who I'm adding in place of Meeks/Lovett.
Specialists (3)
In: Jack Fox, Jake Bates, Hogan Hatten
Out: None
Practice squad potential: None
Analysis: Fox is elite. Bates has the potential to be and is off to a great start to his career, making 26-of-29 field goals last season, including a long of 58. It wouldn’t be surprising to see him knock one down from 60 or longer this season, if the opportunity presents itself.
And did you see Hatten get down the field and make a stop in punt coverage on Saturday? It won’t get talked about much, because long snappers rarely do, but his athleticism is unique and a weapon.