What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

3D Printer Chronicles (1 Viewer)

PIK95 said:
So do these things just make a bunch of random plastic crap?  Why the hype?
The hobby ones do

Professional ones not so much

See also the links above in my post re steel 3D printing of spareparts and a functioning bridge in Amsterdam

 
We had our first failure over last night.  The z-axis brace print didn’t adhere to the build surface properly, peeling up at the corners and messing up the shapes.  We cancelled it.  Looking at this troubleshooting site, I think it’s probably the new cooling fan setup.  We’ll have to turn the fan off at first and see if that fixes it.

 
PIK95 said:
So do these things just make a bunch of random plastic crap?  Why the hype?
Hardly “random”.  Design and make whatever you want/need.  These are very popular in robotics circles.  Our kids created a battery holder, housing for a power switch, several custom pieces to connect robot parts.  It’s pretty cool when the kids say “we need something that can do ____”. And then they design and make what they need.

 
Hardly “random”.  Design and make whatever you want/need.  These are very popular in robotics circles.  Our kids created a battery holder, housing for a power switch, several custom pieces to connect robot parts.  It’s pretty cool when the kids say “we need something that can do ____”. And then they design and make what they need.
No offense intended.  I had a good buzz on and was just messing around.

 
If he's into mechanical engineering, get him into a metal shop class somewhere.  Knowing how to use (and the limits of) a lathe and a mill is very helpful.

 
Every time I think how awesome it would be to have one at home, I just think, "oh I'll just print it at work".
if you did this with car parts like someone else mentioned you would be a modern day johnny cash gettin it one piece at a time and that would rule take that to the bank bromigo

 
If he's into mechanical engineering, get him into a metal shop class somewhere.  Knowing how to use (and the limits of) a lathe and a mill is very helpful.
nowadays honest to god running an end mill is like a lost art or ancient latin if he can get good at that it would rule take that to the bank brochacho

 
I met an engineering research guy who specializes in 3D printing for the local university yesterday.  I've always been fascinated by this stuff.  They do industrial grade printing etc. 

I asked him what's the best consumer 3D printer to buy.  He said don't.  That they're really not there yet and they have about a 33% success rate.  And unless you know how to design in CAD, you'll just be printing other people's stuff off thingiverse or whatever.  I was pretty shocked by that.  

But, if I insisted, he recommended the LulzBot as a good consumer-grade printer for now.  He also said filament-based is better than resin-based because you can become sensitized to the chemicals with resin printers.  Interesting guy.  I would have asked him a lot more questions but didn't really have the time.  

 
And unless you know how to design in CAD, you'll just be printing other people's stuff off thingiverse or whatever.  I was pretty shocked by that.  
The only reason I would buy one of these for my kids is if they were interested in learning about modeling.  I don't see much usefulness if you aren't designing your own stuff.

 
Hardly “random”.  Design and make whatever you want/need.  These are very popular in robotics circles.  Our kids created a battery holder, housing for a power switch, several custom pieces to connect robot parts.  It’s pretty cool when the kids say “we need something that can do ____”. And then they design and make what they need.
What are "our kids"?  Are you a robotics coach?

 
If he's into mechanical engineering, get him into a metal shop class somewhere.  Knowing how to use (and the limits of) a lathe and a mill is very helpful.
Yeah, next year he's in high school and is excited about joining the robotics team, which has a metal shop available.

 
I met an engineering research guy who specializes in 3D printing for the local university yesterday.  I've always been fascinated by this stuff.  They do industrial grade printing etc. 

I asked him what's the best consumer 3D printer to buy.  He said don't.  That they're really not there yet and they have about a 33% success rate.  And unless you know how to design in CAD, you'll just be printing other people's stuff off thingiverse or whatever.  I was pretty shocked by that.  

But, if I insisted, he recommended the LulzBot as a good consumer-grade printer for now.  He also said filament-based is better than resin-based because you can become sensitized to the chemicals with resin printers.  Interesting guy.  I would have asked him a lot more questions but didn't really have the time.  
Agree. We have gone through several cheap printers and they inevitably all get moth balled at some point. We get overwhelmed with print requests, so faculty think it is a good idea to buy a bunch of desktop printers for studio. Student don't take care of them, but even if they did, they are far too finicky and highly unreliable. I have heard that the LulzBot are pretty good, regardless of the stupid name. 

We have several mid grade Stratasys machines. They are beasts in that we can print for thousands of hours until we get a faulty print. And there are times where these things are running for weeks at a time, non stop. 

 
Home made 3D printed jet engine

From my LinkedIn feed: The maker's own words

A reminder that Additive Manufacturing is capable of far more than people realize. In 2013 I produced an all AM turbine in conjunction with EOS and tested it in 2014/2015. It worked just fine... Eventually I will put it on a model and fly it. When it arrived at Kraftwurx, homeland security came with it asking what it was going to be used for...

 
Well, we've got a problem with our X axis right side - it bonks the frame over there.  I still haven't done the troubleshooting on it yet.  We're still muddling through modification prints, rotating things in the slicer program so they don't print near the right side.  We put painter's tape on the bed, altered the fan settings, and everything is sticking well.

 
Boy ran into the house to get to the PC, I figured to play his tank game... instead, he was eager to get on Inventor to solve a problem.  In the car, my wife had been frustrated when she wanted to plug in her iPhone, but the charging cord tip was somewhere on the floor in the winter sludge.  So, my boy spent about 10 minutes on Inventor to create a shape that clamps on to her air vent and holds 5 cord tips up in front of the vent.  The print took 9 hours (and got him down to about 10 inches of filament remaining - didn't think it was going to have enough) and put it in my wife's car for the next day.

He's a badass.

 
Tick said:
Boy ran into the house to get to the PC, I figured to play his tank game... instead, he was eager to get on Inventor to solve a problem.  In the car, my wife had been frustrated when she wanted to plug in her iPhone, but the charging cord tip was somewhere on the floor in the winter sludge.  So, my boy spent about 10 minutes on Inventor to create a shape that clamps on to her air vent and holds 5 cord tips up in front of the vent.  The print took 9 hours (and got him down to about 10 inches of filament remaining - didn't think it was going to have enough) and put it in my wife's car for the next day.

He's a badass.
Indeed. It sounds like he's got the knack

 
Tick said:
Boy ran into the house to get to the PC, I figured to play his tank game... instead, he was eager to get on Inventor to solve a problem.  In the car, my wife had been frustrated when she wanted to plug in her iPhone, but the charging cord tip was somewhere on the floor in the winter sludge.  So, my boy spent about 10 minutes on Inventor to create a shape that clamps on to her air vent and holds 5 cord tips up in front of the vent.  The print took 9 hours (and got him down to about 10 inches of filament remaining - didn't think it was going to have enough) and put it in my wife's car for the next day.

He's a badass.
This is awesome. 

Folkowing. Very cool. Keep us updated. Would love for my girls to get into this. 

 
Is the print area set correctly in the slicer?
Yes, I checked that.  I think the zero is off, but haven't sorted it out yet.  For now, we're just rotating things so they don't get close to the right edge.  I'm trying not to dive in immediately to let him troubleshoot.

We started a sort of resume yesterday, listing some of the projects he's done over the years and what he learned with each project.  I don't know what the goal really is there, but it seems to me that having that information organized would be useful when applying for college admission or an internship... I know that we hired our co-op student based on his interests out of school as much as anything - he obviously had the knack.

 
Hah - kid is capitalizing on the Olympics, printing and selling finger skis and finger snowboards.

 
The printer had a problem - it was failing to feed the filament to the head.  It wasn't constant, but occasional, and would stop 70% through an 8-hour print, which really sucks.  Boy took it apart and tried to clean the printer head, even convinced us to buy a heat gun to help, but nothing worked.  We were ready to buy a new head, but they were out of stock... then he looked at it when it was cold and found a plug of filament in the head, removed it, and everything's good again.

It's one of those things where after the plug is removed, the difference is obvious - you can see through the head now, but it was blocked before... but unless you looked at a clean one, there was nothing to compare to, and it might have been normal to not be able to see through it.

He just finished a 28-hour print with no problems.  He printed a Nerf stock that holds 3 magazines of darts (yawn).

 
Are Monoprice 3d printers good for a beginner? I would like something that's not going to break
but I can't break the bank on spending.

 
I think they are a good bang for your buck, and entry level printers.  You can get very good results if you're prepared to do a little research.  The Maker Select had some issues frying connections, but I believe they have that mostly corrected.  I've heard the Mini is a good printer out of the box but has a small build surface.
I know the mini has a small build surface but for $220ish I don't mind the trade off it is a decent printer.
I'm good with mechanical stuff but just O.K. with technical. Youtube is supposed to be very good with
helping on the research. Thanks. 

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top