This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
I bow to your greatness.
Hands down?I thought it may be closer...and both had outstanding years.
I don't deny that Brees, Rodgers, and Brady all had outstanding years. But Brees seemed heads and shoulders over the other two this year.
How so?Because he threw for more yards?
Seriously, Brees was not "Head and Shoulders" above Rodgers unless you're simply talking about shampoo.
No way. Rodgers had more total touchdowns, less turnovers, nearly a full yard higher YPA, had the highest passer rating in the history of the NFL, and led a team with statistically the worst defense in the league to a 15-1 record. Brees was awesome this year as well, but Rodgers was just a little better.
Clearly, as reflected in the voting.
Well if that's the case the award should've went to Brady or Eli.
But, explain how on earth Brees destroys him in the Offensive MVP category...just vaporized him...and then Rodgers goes on to win MVP. Did he take snaps at LB when I wasn't looking?
Nothing was clearly reflected in the voting. At all.
Clearly proven wrong during the last game of the season.
Clearly Jay Cutler was just behind Peyton Manning then. Rodgers was an out-and-out gun this season. Flynn may be one of the next stars in the league, so to discount Rodgers' season because of one great game is simply ludicrous. The kid is a FREAK.
I think a lot of people's argument, mine included, is that the nfl is basically just giving the same award twice. Rodgers had a great season, but I am not convinced he is the most VALUABLE player to his team. Foster would be more fitting for that, imo.
That's right MOP, just like Steve Young showed that Montana was an over-rated system QB.
So the Packers have figured out this miracle system that teams like Browns haven't, and any 11 dorks could go out there and put up 42 points with it. Cool.Guess what? All teams have good systems that, if executed perfectly, results in a TD on every drive.Maybe, just maybe, the players actually have something to do with it.
Every QB plays in a system designed by the coaches. Every QB. So saying Rodgers is a system QB is only pointing out the obvious for every NFL Team out there.
It's the NFL MVP, not a team MVP.
And let's not forget that the QB Rating takes into account ALL of the important QB categories, not just passing yards.
What is your point? Most valuable in the league must first be most valuable to their team. So if I think players like foster are more valuable to their team, they should get the vote over Rodgers. Not that hard to understand. I think Rodgers should have been offensive POY but somebody else should be mvp.
The same, I thought both had about the exact same season. Rodgers had more wins, Brees set the all time passing record for yards, Brees more games played in. From the eyeball, I think Rodgers is the better player. However, I am surprised at the lopsided vote.
You can think certainly think that, but you'd be wrong.
Or if either could get along with Satan Holmes.
I don't think Holmes would pout about either of those guys slinging him the ball... but you never know I guess.
You're right. It was just an easy excuse for me to take a cheap shot at the guy so I took it.
He was'kwille said:
Would Denver had made the playoffs without Tim Tebow? Would Green Bay make the playoffs without Aaron Rodgers?That's not fishing, that's just making for spirited debate.Can we have a :mop: tag that is the same as'Ministry of Pain said:?This is approaching LHUCKS territory.
What a whiner.
