David Yudkin
Footballguy
Given the plethora of Harrison threads, I figured we'd put this up to a vote. Which one ranks higher at the end of the year . . . total fantasy points scored only, no debates on PPG or adjustments for missed time, etc.
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums
This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
Battle of the Colts WRs (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter David Yudkin
- Start date
Iwannabeacowboybaby!
Footballguy
I'm an odds man, if it's straight up I'd go with Harrison because he's the starter and Manning can throw to him in his sleep.
If there were odds involved, I'd be tempted to take the upstart Gonzalez. Lots of folks thinking these Buckeye receivers are going to break out this year it looks like.
If there were odds involved, I'd be tempted to take the upstart Gonzalez. Lots of folks thinking these Buckeye receivers are going to break out this year it looks like.
Anonymous Internet User
Footballguy
here are the WRs i would absolutely take before harrison:
moss
owens
wayne
edwards
housh
chad johnson
colston
fitz
holt
smith
burress
andre johnson
that's a total of 12
here are the WRs i'm less certain of taking ahead of harrison, but would likely do so anyway:
boldin
marshall
calvin johnson
that's 3
here are the WRs i'd consider likely to finish on par with harrison this year:
welker
holmes
coles
cotchery
driver
roy williams
jennings
ward
bowe
evans
chambers
santana moss
anthony gonzalez
that's 13
in short, i wouldn't rank him better than WR 12 this year. i think he has an outside chance of posting WR 13-15. i think he has a very good chance of posting somewhere from WR 16-29.
the difference in point scoring from WR16-29 was 26 points on the season (1.625 pts/game) for non-ppr and 48 points in ppr (3 pts/game). no one can reasonably predict where in that range he will wind up with such a small point differential -- therefore, i'd only take guys from the third group over harrison that you're high on this year and have specific reason to think will perform better than i've got them ranked.
moss
owens
wayne
edwards
housh
chad johnson
colston
fitz
holt
smith
burress
andre johnson
that's a total of 12
here are the WRs i'm less certain of taking ahead of harrison, but would likely do so anyway:
boldin
marshall
calvin johnson
that's 3
here are the WRs i'd consider likely to finish on par with harrison this year:
welker
holmes
coles
cotchery
driver
roy williams
jennings
ward
bowe
evans
chambers
santana moss
anthony gonzalez
that's 13
in short, i wouldn't rank him better than WR 12 this year. i think he has an outside chance of posting WR 13-15. i think he has a very good chance of posting somewhere from WR 16-29.
the difference in point scoring from WR16-29 was 26 points on the season (1.625 pts/game) for non-ppr and 48 points in ppr (3 pts/game). no one can reasonably predict where in that range he will wind up with such a small point differential -- therefore, i'd only take guys from the third group over harrison that you're high on this year and have specific reason to think will perform better than i've got them ranked.
Jason Wood
Zoo York
Harrison was offering PHENOMENAL value for a time but his ADP has crept back to the WR20 level, so my hopes of stashing him away on a ton of rosters is dwindling fast. That said, I can't see how he doesn't summarily outperform Gonzo this year provided he stays on the field.
Raider Nation
Devil's Advocate
I went with Gonzo because he has a special chemistry with Sorgi.
Jason Wood
Zoo York
LOL, now that's funny!
NiceOpposing defenses seem to share that chemistry.
Last edited by a moderator:
