Fact:
Belichick has now failed to make the playoffs in New England in both seasons where Tom Brady was not his starting QB.
That's not fair. 11-5 should of gotten them in. I hate BB, but I'll give credit where it's due. It was a helluva coaching job.
I agree BB did a great job but you cannot deny their schedule was easy -- one of the easiest in the past 20 or so years. I know you can only play the teams on your schedule but the Patriots didn't do so well when they faced a quality opponent.
The easy schedule thing is a double-edged sword, meaning that New England only lost badly to one quality opponent -
Pittsburg. New England dominated Indy most of that game, running at will, only to lose due to two drive-killing screwups by Gaffney and Thomas.
They barely lost to the Jets the week before the Jets crushed the Titans.
Early losses to Miami and San Diego were exactly that: early losses. The Miami loss was later avenged, quite convincingly.
In the end, NE failed to do what it needed to do to get into the playoffs, and therefore I won't go overboard praising BB for his coaching, but my point is that there isn't that much evidence that NE couldn't hang with the best outside of a BAD loss to Pittsburg (much like Pittsburg BAD loss to Tennessee).