I've had enough beers to make this palatable:
Catcher: Wilson Ramos, Manny Pina, Jesus Sucre
I usually take more than three catchers and I maybe should have this year as well but it seems to me that Ramos and Pina are both the number one guys in their spots based on what I've read. Both are capable of being decent offensive options, Pina was pretty good defensively last season and Ramos was in 14/15/16, so I'm assuming the poor numbers there are injury/playing time related. Sucre is just Ramos insurance to hopefully insure PA's.
Corner IF: Paul Goldschmidt (1B), Jose Ramirez (3B), Austin Riley, Rio Ruiz, Vlad Guerrero Jr.
I used my first two picks here then did absolutely nothing to back them up. I kind of have the mentality that if one of them gets hurt, I'm ####ed anyway, so I focused everywhere else. I don't have much fear of either guy busting, both seem like "high floor" guys and safe picks, so hopefully that safety pays off.
Middle IF: Paul Dejong (SS), Starlin Castro (2B), Daniel Robertson, Chad Pinder, Joey Wendle, Ronny Rodriguez
I feel better about the Dejong pick after his extension, they're obviously nicely committed to him now. If he repeats 90% of last years numbers and is capable defensively that's fine. Castro should provide average-ish power and his BA/OBP look to be pretty BABIP dependent but he's another guy who gets 600+ PA's a year. After that I have the awful Rays 2b platoon and hoepfully Robertson plays some SS to provide some possible cover there as well.
Outfield: Lorenzo Cain, Avisail Garcia, Bradley Zimmer, Matt Joyce, Steve Pearce, Jacoby Ellsbury, Anthony Alford, Kirk Nieuwenhuis, Oscar Mercado, Travis Snider
I like Cain a lot for defense and top of the lineup. I think Avisail can not repeat last year's ridiculous numbers and still be a solid corner guy. Zimmer is a wild card with upside, Joyce had surprisingly strong numbers last year and is a starter again, he's worst case the good side of a platoon. Pearce is probably best case the weak side of the platoon but that's why I took him. I think Alford is way too good for the Jays to keep down long, but we'll see. I think those Nieuwenhuis and Mercado guys are really players. Travis Snider is the best and worst case can provide fantastic clubhouse meat platters.
Starters: Marcus Stroman, Lance McCullers, Drew Pomeranz, Aaron Sanchez, Matt Harvey, Jimmy Nelson, Robert Stephenson, Daniel Gossett, Hector Velazquez, Mike Wright, Roenis Elias, Taylor Guerrieri, Brett Anderson
I took Stroman as my "safe" choice, since he's been over 200 IP the last two seasons and no real injury fears, so he promptly developed shoulder tightness. Doesn't sound like he'll miss more than a start or two. My other "risky" Jays pick meanwhile, Sanchez, is breezing through spring training with no issues and if he's anywhere close to where he was in 2016 is a lot better than my #4. I love McCullers upside but he's not shown he can go deep in games really. Pomeranz will be good and then he'll be hurt and then he'll be good again and then he'll be hurt again. Harvey is getting lots of preseason love, we'll see how he looks in real games. Nelson was great for me last year, I hope he can provide 15-20 start cover for when one of my first 5 gets hurt. Stephenson is in a rotation battle with a bunch of nobodies and should get a good shot. The rest of the guys are nobodies who may get some starts at some point or may end up as bullpen guys or most likely will pitch some innings and get lit the #### up and I'll never think of them again.
Relievers: Justin Wilson (L), Ryan Buchter (L), Brett Cecil (L), Jeurys Familia (R), Fernando Rodney (R), A.J. Ramos (R), Danny Barnes (R), Tim Mayza (L), Mike Dunn (L), Tony Sipp (L), Brad Keller (R), John Axford (R), Al Alburquerque (R)
I like the first 7 a lot. I've been caught without lefties here before and found them hard to acquire, so I overcompensated with my first three picks being lefties, then switched to a bunch of high-k right handers. The rest of the guys are a mix of Blue Jays and more lefties, hopefully a couple of them step up for when a couple of the seven guys I actually like implode. If a bunch of left handers are good, I'll have some trade bait.