Caddy or Ronnie (1 Viewer)

[Crimson King]

I know that both have struggled with consistency in the past, but both have also shown flashes of solid talent. Going forward, which one has the greater dynasty value? Is there a significant difference in terms of talent? All feedback appreciated. Thanks.

 

[acme]

I know that both have struggled with consistency in the past, but both have also shown flashes of solid talent. Going forward, which one has the greater dynasty value? Is there a significant difference in terms of talent? All feedback appreciated. Thanks.

I don't know. I currently have Caddy in a dynasty league and am looking to trade him straight up with the disgruntled Ronnie Brown owner. I doubt he'll bite on it, but I'll probably throw in a little something to sweeten it. I also have Lorenzo Booker on my taxi squad, which doesnt' mean anything to anyone but makes getting Ronnie a little 'safer' looking forward to more input from guys that know more than me.

 

[TheFanatic]

Well, Cameron was the guy that ran the San Diego D. LT is struggling without him. BRown was used very much in an LT type mode. Lots of yards on the ground and in the air and multiple TD's. Seems to be in a better system. Although I don't know if they have the talent in the middle of that line in Miami to maintain that.

Caddy has a bunch of young guys on the line with loads of potential. As the season goes on the better they should get.

Both have an aging vet at QB that can get it done. Either could go down pretty quickly considering their age. But long term, I would say Ronnie Brown is better off. They will get help on the interior of that line in the offseason....

 

[munchkin]

I am a patient RBrown owner so I certainly hope he has the greater upside since I drafted him over Caddy. Caddilac has been injury prone. Caddy probably has more talent as a rb but he can't stay healthy.

 

[Crimson King]

Thanks for the feedback guys. I am looking forward to hearing more people's opinions. I am really divided on this topic and seem to change on a daily basis.

 

[az_prof]

I am a Brown owner and wouldn't trade him for Caddy. I just feel like Caddy doesn't have the ability to stay healthy as a featured back. Ronnie showed us what he can do despite having a horrible line. Caddy may do better this year, but I still feel long term Brown is the better player to own.

 

[zamboni]

I've had Caddy since his rookie year, and I'd trade him for Brown in a heartbeat. I think Brown is a much more well-rounded, every down/situation RB. And yes, the durability concern with Caddy plays a role as well.