What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Calvin Johnson to retire - CONFIRMED (1 Viewer)

If Calvin wants to retire, there's more than ample time for him to do it in a way that doesn't hurt the team.
I was thinking about this. On the one hand, the nicest thing he could do is decide soon, so the team can move on.

On the other hand, it's a big decision, and the Lions cap space shouldn't enter into his thinking. This is his career, and all indications are that they want him to take a pay cut.

He has 12 mill in new dollars due. He probably feels pretty confident he can get more than that on the open market.

 
If Calvin wants to retire, there's more than ample time for him to do it in a way that doesn't hurt the team.
I was thinking about this. On the one hand, the nicest thing he could do is decide soon, so the team can move on.

On the other hand, it's a big decision, and the Lions cap space shouldn't enter into his thinking. This is his career, and all indications are that they want him to take a pay cut.

He has 12 mill in new dollars due. He probably feels pretty confident he can get more than that on the open market.
What's this decide soon stuff? Reportedly, he informed Caldwell the day after their last game, and Caldwell told him to take some time to think it over.

 
If Calvin wants to retire, there's more than ample time for him to do it in a way that doesn't hurt the team.
I was thinking about this. On the one hand, the nicest thing he could do is decide soon, so the team can move on.

On the other hand, it's a big decision, and the Lions cap space shouldn't enter into his thinking. This is his career, and all indications are that they want him to take a pay cut.

He has 12 mill in new dollars due. He probably feels pretty confident he can get more than that on the open market.
What's this decide soon stuff? Reportedly, he informed Caldwell the day after their last game, and Caldwell told him to take some time to think it over.
Yep, and reportedly the Lions want him back at a reduced rate.

And reportedly, the Lions want the cap space more. http://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/2016/02/02/lions-seem-to-want-cap-space-more-than-they-want-megatron/

 
:popcorn: Stick it to 'em Calvin. Force them to cut you loose so you can team up with Belicheck, Brady & Gronk and make a run at a SB. Everyone knows he doesn't need the money so he can easily sign there for a 1 or maybe 2 year deal. He can go out a rich, winner instead of retiring a rich, loser.

 
:popcorn: Stick it to 'em Calvin. Force them to cut you loose so you can team up with Belicheck, Brady & Gronk and make a run at a SB. Everyone knows he doesn't need the money so he can easily sign there for a 1 or maybe 2 year deal. He can go out a rich, winner instead of retiring a somewhat less rich loser.
FYP

 
If Calvin wants to retire, there's more than ample time for him to do it in a way that doesn't hurt the team.
I was thinking about this. On the one hand, the nicest thing he could do is decide soon, so the team can move on.

On the other hand, it's a big decision, and the Lions cap space shouldn't enter into his thinking. This is his career, and all indications are that they want him to take a pay cut.

He has 12 mill in new dollars due. He probably feels pretty confident he can get more than that on the open market.
What's this decide soon stuff? Reportedly, he informed Caldwell the day after their last game, and Caldwell told him to take some time to think it over.
Yep, and reportedly the Lions want him back at a reduced rate.

And reportedly, the Lions want the cap space more. http://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/2016/02/02/lions-seem-to-want-cap-space-more-than-they-want-megatron/
Lol

Johnson: 2015 was my last season.

Lions: tell you what, we'll take you back at a reduced rate.

Johnson: :confused:

If he doesn't want to play @ $16M, he probably isn't interested at <$16M. Just guessing.

 
If Calvin wants to retire, there's more than ample time for him to do it in a way that doesn't hurt the team.
I was thinking about this. On the one hand, the nicest thing he could do is decide soon, so the team can move on.

On the other hand, it's a big decision, and the Lions cap space shouldn't enter into his thinking. This is his career, and all indications are that they want him to take a pay cut.

He has 12 mill in new dollars due. He probably feels pretty confident he can get more than that on the open market.
What's this decide soon stuff? Reportedly, he informed Caldwell the day after their last game, and Caldwell told him to take some time to think it over.
Yep, and reportedly the Lions want him back at a reduced rate.

And reportedly, the Lions want the cap space more. http://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/2016/02/02/lions-seem-to-want-cap-space-more-than-they-want-megatron/
Lol

Johnson: 2015 was my last season.

Lions: tell you what, we'll take you back at a reduced rate.

Johnson: :confused:

If he doesn't want to play @ $16M, he probably isn't interested at <$16M. Just guessing.
It's almost like there's a business negotiation happening or something.

 
If Calvin wants to retire, there's more than ample time for him to do it in a way that doesn't hurt the team.
I was thinking about this. On the one hand, the nicest thing he could do is decide soon, so the team can move on.

On the other hand, it's a big decision, and the Lions cap space shouldn't enter into his thinking. This is his career, and all indications are that they want him to take a pay cut.

He has 12 mill in new dollars due. He probably feels pretty confident he can get more than that on the open market.
What's this decide soon stuff? Reportedly, he informed Caldwell the day after their last game, and Caldwell told him to take some time to think it over.
Yep, and reportedly the Lions want him back at a reduced rate.

And reportedly, the Lions want the cap space more. http://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/2016/02/02/lions-seem-to-want-cap-space-more-than-they-want-megatron/
Lol

Johnson: 2015 was my last season.

Lions: tell you what, we'll take you back at a reduced rate.

Johnson: :confused:

If he doesn't want to play @ $16M, he probably isn't interested at <$16M. Just guessing.
It's almost like there's a business negotiation happening or something.
His ankles are shot. But sorry you have him in dynasty.

 
:popcorn: Stick it to 'em Calvin. Force them to cut you loose so you can team up with Rivera Belicheck, Brady & Gronk Cam & Olsen and make a run at a SB. Everyone knows he doesn't need the money so he can easily sign there for a 1 or maybe 2 year deal. He can go out a rich, winner instead of retiring a rich, loser.
FYP

 
His ankles are shot. But sorry you have him in dynasty.
Not a heavily owned guy at all. I don't really have a dog in the fight.

And I'm not saying he won't give up $20m to retire -- it's possible.

But based on the current facts, prior situations like this one, and a dash of common sense, it's also possible this is part of a negotiation on where Calvin plays and how much he plays for in 2016.

 
:popcorn: Stick it to 'em Calvin. Force them to cut you loose so you can team up with Rivera Belicheck, Brady & Gronk Cam & Olsen and make a run at a SB. Everyone knows he doesn't need the money so he can easily sign there for a 1 or maybe 2 year deal. He can go out a rich, winner instead of retiring a rich, loser.
FYP
Add him to Benjamin/Olsen/Funchess, and their intramural hoops team would be da bomb.

 
ESPN's Adam Schefter reports the Lions informed interviewing coaches of the "concerns doctors had for [Calvin] Johnson's longevity and the condition of his ankles" in 2014.

This means the Lions have known any season could be Johnson's last for at least the last two years, and yet they still failed to adequately address the position in the last two drafts, which were two of the best receiver classes in recent memory. Dealing with real health concerns, all indications are Johnson is serious about retirement. He just turned 30 in September.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
If Calvin wants to retire, there's more than ample time for him to do it in a way that doesn't hurt the team.
I was thinking about this. On the one hand, the nicest thing he could do is decide soon, so the team can move on.

On the other hand, it's a big decision, and the Lions cap space shouldn't enter into his thinking. This is his career, and all indications are that they want him to take a pay cut.

He has 12 mill in new dollars due. He probably feels pretty confident he can get more than that on the open market.
What's this decide soon stuff? Reportedly, he informed Caldwell the day after their last game, and Caldwell told him to take some time to think it over.
Yep, and reportedly the Lions want him back at a reduced rate.

And reportedly, the Lions want the cap space more. http://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/2016/02/02/lions-seem-to-want-cap-space-more-than-they-want-megatron/
Lol

Johnson: 2015 was my last season.

Lions: tell you what, we'll take you back at a reduced rate.

Johnson: :confused:

If he doesn't want to play @ $16M, he probably isn't interested at <$16M. Just guessing.
It's almost like there's a business negotiation happening or something.
Business negotiation? How does talking about retiring work as a negotiating tactic for Johnson?

If what he really wants is to be cut, then just say nothing about retiring, and decline to renegotiate the existing contract.

If what he really wants is some sort of extension, then again, say nothing about retiring and engage the Lions on re-working the contract.

 
:popcorn: Stick it to 'em Calvin. Force them to cut you loose so you can team up with Rivera Belicheck, Brady & Gronk Cam & Olsen and make a run at a SB. Everyone knows he doesn't need the money so he can easily sign there for a 1 or maybe 2 year deal. He can go out a rich, winner instead of retiring a rich, loser.
FYP
Add him to Benjamin/Olsen/Funchess, and their intramural hoops team would be da bomb.
if car wins the sb, everyone gets a raise, so how do they afford him?

 
:popcorn: Stick it to 'em Calvin. Force them to cut you loose so you can team up with Rivera Belicheck, Brady & Gronk Cam & Olsen and make a run at a SB. Everyone knows he doesn't need the money so he can easily sign there for a 1 or maybe 2 year deal. He can go out a rich, winner instead of retiring a rich, loser.
FYP
Add him to Benjamin/Olsen/Funchess, and their intramural hoops team would be da bomb.
if car wins the sb, everyone gets a raise, so how do they afford him?
Here's how:

  • Roughly 19 mill under the cap next year
  • Can clear 19 mill in cap space by cutting Jared Allen and Charles Johnson
Carolina has no cap issues next year. I was just horsing around regarding CJ to Carolina, but it's doable, especially if he was willing to play for 8-10 mill.

 
If Calvin wants to retire, there's more than ample time for him to do it in a way that doesn't hurt the team.
I was thinking about this. On the one hand, the nicest thing he could do is decide soon, so the team can move on.

On the other hand, it's a big decision, and the Lions cap space shouldn't enter into his thinking. This is his career, and all indications are that they want him to take a pay cut.

He has 12 mill in new dollars due. He probably feels pretty confident he can get more than that on the open market.
What's this decide soon stuff? Reportedly, he informed Caldwell the day after their last game, and Caldwell told him to take some time to think it over.
Yep, and reportedly the Lions want him back at a reduced rate.

And reportedly, the Lions want the cap space more. http://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/2016/02/02/lions-seem-to-want-cap-space-more-than-they-want-megatron/
Lol

Johnson: 2015 was my last season.

Lions: tell you what, we'll take you back at a reduced rate.

Johnson: :confused:

If he doesn't want to play @ $16M, he probably isn't interested at <$16M. Just guessing.
It's almost like there's a business negotiation happening or something.
Business negotiation? How does talking about retiring work as a negotiating tactic for Johnson?

If what he really wants is to be cut, then just say nothing about retiring, and decline to renegotiate the existing contract.

If what he really wants is some sort of extension, then again, say nothing about retiring and engage the Lions on re-working the contract.
Here's a nice read regarding this:

http://overthecap.com/what-happens-when-calvin-johnson-retires/

 
Not sure if this has been asked already here, but what do you think are the current odds of each of the 3 potential situations for 2016 -

Calvin is a Lion

Calvin is playing for one of the 31 other teams

Calvin is not playing in the NFL

I'm going 25%, 50%, 25% in order.
I'd say 75/15/10. Caldwell returning makes him likely to want to stay. There are contract issues that will need to be ironed out, but you have to assume Quinn doesn't want his first major action as GM to be getting rid of the greatest WR in franchise history. They'll work something out. The only uncertainties at this point are a) Calvin refusing to budge on his contract and b) him being serious about feeling beat up and not needing this crap anymore. But I'd still be surprised if he's not back.
Roughly 3 weeks later, should these three %s be updated?

 
Wow, from the article:

If Johnson were to return this summer the Lions would not only have his $12.9 million dead charge on the books but would then reinstate his $16M salary bringing his total cap number to nearly $29 million. Considering the Lions would have prepared all offseason for life without Johnson, this would put them in a position where they would be unable to keep him on the roster and comply with the cap. Johnson would gain a tremendous amount of leverage and they would have no choice but to release him or sign him to a new deal with very favorable terms. So if Johnson was really looking for a clean break from the Lions without having to ask for a trade this would be the way to do it. That would be a pretty impressive move by the player if it ever happened.
 
ESPN's Adam Schefter reports the Lions informed interviewing coaches of the "concerns doctors had for [Calvin] Johnson's longevity and the condition of his ankles" in 2014.

This means the Lions have known any season could be Johnson's last for at least the last two years, and yet they still failed to adequately address the position in the last two drafts, which were two of the best receiver classes in recent memory. Dealing with real health concerns, all indications are Johnson is serious about retirement. He just turned 30 in September.
Good info from Schefty. Thanks.

Lions handled WR right. They signed Golden Tate as FA in 2014 rather than draft a stud. Calvin gets hurt, GT immediately plays like a #1, makes the Pro Bowl and carries them to the playoffs. Best FA signing of 2014. They saw value and talent and struck.

They also draft two late developmental WRs and use their 1st rounder to draft Ebron as a TE weapon. I'm not defending the Ebron pick as worth a #10, especially with the Jimmy Graham role in the offense gone with Lombardi. The problem wasn't just what if Calvin can't play - but what if he can.

The offense struggled finding roles for Tate and Calvin when on the field at the same time. Add an OBJ into that mix and now you have HUGE $$ tied up in WRs and who gets the ball. At least with Ebron - you're theoretically creating mismatches with options in the run game. (They should've taken A. Donald instead anyways)

If Calvin retires, GT becomes the #1 and they draft or sign a stud to pair with him. The problem is what do you do this year in the draft.

Quinn has watched NE succeed with plug and play WR's, I doubt that he sees WR as the critical position to spend his salary cap dollars at.

 
Wow, from the article:

If Johnson were to return this summer the Lions would not only have his $12.9 million dead charge on the books but would then reinstate his $16M salary bringing his total cap number to nearly $29 million. Considering the Lions would have prepared all offseason for life without Johnson, this would put them in a position where they would be unable to keep him on the roster and comply with the cap. Johnson would gain a tremendous amount of leverage and they would have no choice but to release him or sign him to a new deal with very favorable terms. So if Johnson was really looking for a clean break from the Lions without having to ask for a trade this would be the way to do it. That would be a pretty impressive move by the player if it ever happened.
That's slightly misleading. First off, they are already accounting for $24M of those dollars on their cap today, so it's "only" $5M more. Second off, they may opt not to structure it that way. Here's how it breaks down:

They have $12.9M of past bonuses to amortize, $8M of which is scheduled for 2016 and $4.9 for 2017.

2016: $8M

2017: $4.9M

He has a salary (non-guaranteed) of $16M.

2016: $8M + $16M = $24M cap number for 2016, which they are currently accounting for.

2017: $4.9M (plus salary, but different discussion since it's not guaranteed)

If he retires, they can stick with the above amortization, or they can just pay the entire $12.9M cap hit all in 2016.

2016: $8M

2017: $4.9M

-or-

2016: $12.9M

2017: $0

If they choose the second option, but then he comes back, they have to now account for the $16M salary again, and that's where the $29M is coming from.

2016: $8M + $16M = $24M

2017: $4.9M

-or-

2016: $12.9M + $16M = $29M

2017: $0

Worst case, they end up with $4.9M more on their 2016 cap than they originally planned, but that's presumably positive since it means he's coming back.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Hankmoody said:
Worst case, they end up with $4.9M more on their 2016 cap than they originally planned, but that's presumably positive since it means he's coming back.
That's the whole problem, the Lions are planning on not carrying that that cap number. They don't want to pay him that much. The worst case scenario is holding 11 mill in cap space for a player that may not play. 11 mill is two good starters.

 
If they don't want to carry that they have an easy remedy, just cut him. That's the contact they signed, there's not a whole lot of choice.

 
massraider said:
grateful zed said:
:popcorn: Stick it to 'em Calvin. Force them to cut you loose so you can team up with Rivera Belicheck, Brady & Gronk Cam & Olsen and make a run at a SB. Everyone knows he doesn't need the money so he can easily sign there for a 1 or maybe 2 year deal. He can go out a rich, winner instead of retiring a rich, loser.
FYP
Add him to Benjamin/Olsen/Funchess, and their intramural hoops team would be da bomb.
if car wins the sb, everyone gets a raise, so how do they afford him?
Here's how:

  • Roughly 19 mill under the cap next year
  • Can clear 19 mill in cap space by cutting Jared Allen and Charles Johnson
Carolina has no cap issues next year. I was just horsing around regarding CJ to Carolina, but it's doable, especially if he was willing to play for 8-10 mill.
:jawdrop: can we say dynasty?

 
Last edited by a moderator:
he won a couple of titles on my team including one this year. makes sense for him to go out on top. the rings i give my team are from vending machines but still really cool.

 
Shocking news to be released tomorrow apparently.

EDT: Didn't happen.... source might have been wrong, sorry guys.

EDT2: Calvin Caldwell on Jan 4th he was retiring but they kept it quiet till today.
This was probably the most amazing thing I have read on FBG. You nailed it. Prior to your post I didn't think there was anyway he would retire.

 
massraider said:
grateful zed said:
:popcorn: Stick it to 'em Calvin. Force them to cut you loose so you can team up with Rivera Belicheck, Brady & Gronk Cam & Olsen and make a run at a SB. Everyone knows he doesn't need the money so he can easily sign there for a 1 or maybe 2 year deal. He can go out a rich, winner instead of retiring a rich, loser.
FYP
Add him to Benjamin/Olsen/Funchess, and their intramural hoops team would be da bomb.
if car wins the sb, everyone gets a raise, so how do they afford him?
Here's how:

  • Roughly 19 mill under the cap next year
  • Can clear 19 mill in cap space by cutting Jared Allen and Charles Johnson
Carolina has no cap issues next year. I was just horsing around regarding CJ to Carolina, but it's doable, especially if he was willing to play for 8-10 mill.
:jawdrop: can we say dynasty?
They'll go 8-8 next year after winning the big one.

 
massraider said:
grateful zed said:
:popcorn: Stick it to 'em Calvin. Force them to cut you loose so you can team up with Rivera Belicheck, Brady & Gronk Cam & Olsen and make a run at a SB. Everyone knows he doesn't need the money so he can easily sign there for a 1 or maybe 2 year deal. He can go out a rich, winner instead of retiring a rich, loser.
FYP
Add him to Benjamin/Olsen/Funchess, and their intramural hoops team would be da bomb.
if car wins the sb, everyone gets a raise, so how do they afford him?
Here's how:

  • Roughly 19 mill under the cap next year
  • Can clear 19 mill in cap space by cutting Jared Allen and Charles Johnson
Carolina has no cap issues next year. I was just horsing around regarding CJ to Carolina, but it's doable, especially if he was willing to play for 8-10 mill.
:jawdrop: can we say dynasty?
They'll go 8-8 next year after winning the big one.
that will get them in the playoffs from that division.

 
:popcorn: Stick it to 'em Calvin. Force them to cut you loose so you can team up with Rivera Belicheck, Brady & Gronk Cam & Olsen and make a run at a SB. Everyone knows he doesn't need the money so he can easily sign there for a 1 or maybe 2 year deal. He can go out a rich, winner instead of retiring a rich, loser.
FYP
Add him to Benjamin/Olsen/Funchess, and their intramural hoops team would be da bomb.
if car wins the sb, everyone gets a raise, so how do they afford him?
Here's how:

  • Roughly 19 mill under the cap next year
  • Can clear 19 mill in cap space by cutting Jared Allen and Charles Johnson
Carolina has no cap issues next year. I was just horsing around regarding CJ to Carolina, but it's doable, especially if he was willing to play for 8-10 mill.
3 of their 4 starters in the defensive backfield are UFAs after the Super Bowl: Norman, Harper, and Tillman. Along with backup CB Finnegan. Others they might want to bring back include Tolbert, Remmers, Love, and Alexander.

They are definitely in good cap position, but some of that cap space will be eaten up by re-signing these players or otherwise addressing their positions. In particular, Norman can be expected to sign for a premier CB contract that will eat up a good amount of that cap space.

 
Harper and Tillman will get paid peanuts. Remmers is restricted, he won't cost anything.

If they sign Norman to a long term deal, they can sign anyone. 2017 is a different kettle of fish, with Short and Lotulelei both cashing in.

Panthers have core players locked up, they can sing CJ to a one year deal for the same money anyone else would be willing to.

 
Friendly suggestion...you'll find a lot more readers eager to dissect the nuances of Carolina's cap situation in the Panthers offseason thread.

It's been a while since any of this has had even tangential bearing on Calvin Johnson's status...

 
Pretty sure Calvin won't want to play with another QB that throws horrible passes that put him in situations where he can be knocked out of a game like Brown just was.

 
Somebody wants to get themselves cut from the dumpster fire that is the Detroit Lions.  That somebody is Calvin Johnson.

Now that's not to say that that somebody necessarily wants to play somewhere else next season, but that somebody may genuinely want to retire.  But that somebody wants the option of playing somewhere else in the event he unretires.

 
Somebody wants to get themselves cut from the dumpster fire that is the Detroit Lions.  That somebody is Calvin Johnson.

Now that's not to say that that somebody necessarily wants to play somewhere else next season, but that somebody may genuinely want to retire.  But that somebody wants the option of playing somewhere else in the event he unretires.
That's the way I see it. He's being as nice as possible but he's played for incompetent coaching his whole career and pretty much been a loser his whole NFL career. He wants out of Detroit.

 
So peyton did he broncos right by making his decision. 

Time for calvin to step up and #### or get off the pot
Peyton was about to get cut if he did not retire and he did not want to go out that way, was not doing anyone a favor.

Calvin has no such deadline to worry about, at least not personally.

 
Peyton was about to get cut if he did not retire and he did not want to go out that way, was not doing anyone a favor.

Calvin has no such deadline to worry about, at least not personally.
The lions could save something like 11 million if he retires or is cut. Him prolonging his decision does hurt the franchise

 
The lions could save something like 11 million if he retires or is cut. Him prolonging his decision does hurt the franchise
Don't disagree which is why I said for him personally. For Calvin he's be better off forcing the teams hand to release him so if/when he wants to play he's a FA.

Peyton on the other hand was getting cut even if he wanted to come back which is why I said he was not doing anyone a favor. Broncos always knew where they stood with him, he was not coming back it was just a matter of who was going to pull the plug.

 
http://www.detroitlions.com/news/article-1/Calvin-Johnson-retires-from-the-National-Football-League/b5fbfa4d-8354-44c2-aa28-2987ba7f0171

Calvin Johnson retires from the National Football League.



[SIZE=11pt]Allen Park, Mich. –[/SIZE][SIZE=10pt]Detroit Lions wide receiver [/SIZE][SIZE=10pt]Calvin Johnson[/SIZE][SIZE=10pt], who for the past nine seasons established himself as one of the greatest wide receivers in National Football League history, today announced his retirement from the NFL effective immediately.[/SIZE]
[SIZE=11pt] [/SIZE]
[SIZE=11pt]Johnson also filed his retirement papers with the NFL today in advance of the new League year which begins at 4 p.m. ET Wednesday, March 9.[/SIZE]
[SIZE=11pt] [/SIZE]
[SIZE=11pt]The Lions also announced, with respect to Johnson’s contract, that those “matters were settled to the satisfaction of the parties.”[/SIZE]

 

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top