Raider Nation
Devil's Advocate
Matt Hayes' 4/19 column in the new Sporting News: LINK
Bush bashers put too much stock in that "He wasn't even on the field on that 4th down play" argument. There could have been a million reasons why White got the call on that play, and none of them were an indication that Carroll and his staff had no confidence in Bush's ability to get the 1st down.Googled NFL draft and got 31.6 million possible web pages in 0.11 seconds. Now I see why Dan Pompei makes the big bucks.
So while Draft Boy Danny and the remaining 31.5999 mill or so fill your eyes and ears with 40 times and projections and sleepers and busts, I'll take you another direction. If you don't already think I'm an idiot, then you will soon enough.
Reggie Bush isn't the best player in this draft. He's not even the best running back -- his overweight if-he-ever-gets-his-Little-Debbie-eating-butt-in-shape teammate LenDale White is.
Every scout and personnel man and fantasy football geek will tell you Reggie Bush is the next Barry Sanders. He has speed and moves and strength and blah, blah, blah.
Did these guys watch the Rose Bowl?
Look, I'm no NFL talent evaluator, but I've got two eyes. When the teams' talent levels were the same in the Rose Bowl, when the defense had as much or more speed as the Southern California offense, suddenly Bush didn't look so untouchable, so incredible, so undeniably the best back in decades, as so many scouts have unequivocally claimed.
Bush had 13 carries for 82 yards and one score in the national title game. LenDale White had 20 carries for 124 yards and three touchdowns. And when the Trojans needed two yards, when the game was on the line and needed to be salted away, White got the ball. An NFL scout told me that night that the USC staff gambled by not putting the ball in the hands of their best player, the guy who had the best chance to pick up the first down.
I told him they did.
Watch the Rose Bowl again. Watch the USC offense try to stretch plays outside to create space for Bush. Watch how utterly fruitless it was. The Texas defense could run, and its front seven had fantastic lateral speed. And, in case you haven't heard: NFL defenses can run. Really fast.
USC obviously had rushing success against Texas, but the Trojans did so by running between the tackles. Bush (5-11, 202) is not a between-the-tackles guy. He needs space to allow his moves and speed to take over.
And enough with the Gale Sayers comparisons. I'm too young to have watched Sayers, but I know that D-linemen in the NFL in the 1960s were 240 pounds and ran 5.4 40s. D-linemen these days weigh nearly 300 pounds and run 4.7 40s.
It's simple physiology. How many elite 200-pound running backs are there in the NFL? How many of them have the goods to be the No. 1 overall pick and be compared to Barry Sanders and Gale Sayers -- merely two of the best backs in the history of pigskin?
It doesn't take 0.11seconds to figure that out.