Comparing the last 2 years at the top: RB (1 Viewer)

[bigreese82]

Wanted to look at the top consensus picks at the skills positions(mostly 1st two round guys, used the Bloom 100 for the 07 group).

First the QBs...based upon their/your draft grades...how do you rank them if it was one draft will these players. Try not to heavily weigh last years rookie performances too much. How did these guys grade out of college to you? Hopefully we can get some good discussion here

Ranking the RBs..06 vs 07

RBs

Reggie Bush

Laurence Maroney

DeAngelo Williams

Joseph Addai

Lendale White

Maurice Drew

….................................

Adrian Peterson

Marshawn Lynch

Antonio Pittman

Michael Bush

Lorenzo Booker

Kenny Irons

 

[bigreese82]

not a lot of votes..I know alot of guys will be forced to make a decision on these guys

 

[Biabreakable]

I would think most will favor Reggie Bush here as there has not been such a highly regarded RB prospect as him in a long time.

Is he the best RB for FF? Maybe maybe not.

 

[-OZ-]

Bush

Peterson

Maroney

MJD

Lynch

 

[Buckeyedawgs]

I am skepticle of Peterson because of his injury history. Bush was good like advertised but not in the fantasy elite because of the situation and system he plays in just as I projected. I projected Addia to be the best back of rookies this year before season started and hit it on the $$$$. Best talent doesn't always win!

There is no way to be able to project the 2007 rookie class until after the draft just as Bush proved this year.

Drew would get my vote. He surprised me big time. Never thought he would have the impact he did this fast.

The qb;s all were pretty much on my projection this year also. (The big 3)

None of them really had top 6 rb rookie value. Leinnart has best chance of the three I would think but he had some real downer games that worries me.

Way to early to even try and project this years batch. That LSU dude can really be good if he gets in right system though.