It's as if the mayor is surprised every week that things the teachers and principals have been saying for months is brand new. So sick of this getting pushed back because they collectively couldn't get their #### together and deal with this earlier. Nothing has changed.El Floppo said:Just got this from our principal. NYC. In class was supposed to start on the 22nd (blended)
The Mayor announced just a few moments ago that elementary schools will not be open for live instruction until Tuesday, September 29th. Prior to the press conference today, school leaders were not given this information. I know that you all have many questions, and as of now, I do not have the answers.
Principals have been called to a meeting today at 1pm and I am hoping we will get some clarity. As of now, there is no information about instructional expectations for next week or how this change will effect the blended learning weekly schedule. We have removed our blended schedule from the website and will post an updated version once we get some clarity.
My HS set up a virtual boys bathroom so the kids have somewhere to meet to vape together. It’s important to establish a sense of normalcy,OK gotta say that one benefit of online school is that it's possible to smoke weed in between classes at online Parent's Night.
Our district is 100% remote. In the spring, that meant the teachers created lessons and assignments that the kids would complete on their own schedule. There was a 30-minute zoom every day for the kids to see each other and talk to the teacher, ask questions, do some kind of group lesson/activity, etc. Outside of that the teachers were available for 1-on-1 or small group zooms as needed. I know opinions/experiences varied wildly but it worked pretty well for our family.How is everyone holding up?
My son is struggling so bad with it so far. At this point, it's less the school's issue than it is his and ours. He needs constant monitoring ... he doesn't yet have the executive function (even in 8th grade) to stay on a boring-to-him task (Zoom call + in-class assignments) for 90 minutes.Things are getting better here in the full virtual until January world. Kids, teachers and parents are getting the hang of it.
Same here in Jersey. There was a case and they're going all remote for the week.Second case and school is all remote tomorrow
FYI, Today is NYCs first day in person across the city.My son's first day in-person today in NYC public school 8th grade. They were remote last week. Daughter goes tomorrow.
We'll see.
It’s very hit or miss. I have kids doing better than ever because their battle was just hating to leave the comfort of home and deal with the anxiety of all the people, drama, behaviors, etc. Other kids are just too disorganized and like you said lack the executive functioning to monitor it all, stick with the boring parts, etc. We are mostly doing flipped school so most of the teaching is done during the asynchronous periods and the time live in class is for practicing, getting help, teacher feedback and group work. The kids who are smart love it because they can basically just turn their cam off and do the work at their own pace without being tied to a desk in class hearing the teacher explaining things they already understand. The lower kids seem to like having all this extra time in class for personalized help. Also they like that they can pause and rewind the asynchronous lessons when something didn’t make sense.My son is struggling so bad with it so far. At this point, it's less the school's issue than it is his and ours. He needs constant monitoring ... he doesn't yet have the executive function (even in 8th grade) to stay on a boring-to-him task (Zoom call + in-class assignments) for 90 minutes.
In-class assignments, I'm not sure how they work. I know they get them, and they turn them in via Google Classroom/Google Drive. Other software is incorporated, as well (e.g. Nearpod, Khan Academy videos, more) ... IMHO, it's a few things too many. Probably should be streamlined and in common among all classes, all subjects. Just my non-expert opinion, though.How do your in class assignments work? Our kids are basically only required to be live in school for 3 hours a day: 8:30-9:30, 10:30-11:30 and 12:30-1:30. The rest of the time is set aside for kids to work independently but they don’t have to do it during those periods. They could do the work at midnight if that’s when they want to.
Yeah that’s a long time to be on Zoom all day. Rough. I also am annoyed with teachers using so many tools because it makes my job of managing my kids more difficult but I also get the idea of trying to avoid being monotonous. Our teachers use Khan and other things as resources but they are residing almost all of their own lessons so that it feels like class, kids can maybe get to know the teachers, it’s more personalized as they can mention kids names, incorporate student questions and work into lessons, etc. Of course they are able to do this because they aren’t live on Zoom 6 hours a day.In-class assignments, I'm not sure how they work. I know they get them, and they turn them in via Google Classroom/Google Drive. Other software is incorporated, as well (e.g. Nearpod, Khan Academy videos, more) ... IMHO, it's a few things too many. Probably should be streamlined and in common among all classes, all subjects. Just my non-expert opinion, though.
He actually has two math courses (his weakest subject, probably two grade levels behind) -- one is regular 8th grade math, the other is a remedial course meant to reinforce 7th grade math. The math teachers lean hard on Khan Academy for their virtual students ... those videos bore both my son and me to tears. I don't have an appetite to make him sit after school and watch all that, so I teach the concepts to him myself.
...
A shortened school day would probably help the virtual learners, at least some of them. My son is on five 90-minute Zoom calls four days a week (8 am - 4 pm with 30 min lunch). As a middle-aged adult ... I myself zone out of online meetings that last that long. Back when I was in 8th grade, it would have been much worse ... and my son is dealing with the same issues.
That's WAY too long to be on zoom. Brutal. Our 7 year old (big age difference of course) only spends three hours a day on zoom but that also includes 30 minutes of breaks and snacks. With the various subjects, activities and the breaks it seems to work great.Yeah that’s a long time to be on Zoom all day. Rough. I also am annoyed with teachers using so many tools because it makes my job of managing my kids more difficult but I also get the idea of trying to avoid being monotonous. Our teachers use Khan and other things as resources but they are residing almost all of their own lessons so that it feels like class, kids can maybe get to know the teachers, it’s more personalized as they can mention kids names, incorporate student questions and work into lessons, etc. Of course they are able to do this because they aren’t live on Zoom 6 hours a day.
3 hours a day is all we are expecting of our high schoolers. 6 hours is insane, don't know who thought of that.That's WAY too long to be on zoom. Brutal. Our 7 year old (big age difference of course) only spends three hours a day on zoom but that also includes 30 minutes of breaks and snacks. With the various subjects, activities and the breaks it seems to work great.
7.5 hours/day here.3 hours a day is all we are expecting of our high schoolers. 6 hours is insane, don't know who thought of that.That's WAY too long to be on zoom. Brutal. Our 7 year old (big age difference of course) only spends three hours a day on zoom but that also includes 30 minutes of breaks and snacks. With the various subjects, activities and the breaks it seems to work great.
It's to do the entire school day as usual, except transmitted via Zoom to virtual students.Their design is totally f'd.7.5 hours/day here.
Of course, it's not your fault. At his age has to be trusted and given responsibility. Now is the time for him to struggle and learn some lessons- that is exactly what 8th grade is for. I get their idea of replicating the school day but the school day was probably too long without enough breaks to begin with. Plus this isn't the same an in-person school day, it's just not.It's to do the entire school day as usual, except transmitted via Zoom to virtual students.
It would be one thing if the 90 minutes were broken up a lot, or something. I don't know ... all I know is it's not working. And I'm not in a position to be able to sit with my son throughout the day and hand-hold him, even though I'm working from home.
I do walk over at the beginning of every period and make sure (a) he's not asleep, and (b) he's in front of the laptop when roll is called. Also a few pop-in checks throughout the day. He's been busted missing roll call and/or being asleep a few times already.
My 6- and 9-year olds are on zoom for 5 hours a day. It's a trainwreck. I've been saying it forever but the district unfortunately wasted the entire summer figuring out how to get kids back in the building instead of figuring out how to provide the best possible remote learning experience, and so now when they switched at the last moment to all-remote (like I predicted they would all along), we got this ####ty outcome. Crazy to think that for a long time the plan was to have teachers do this while simultaneously teaching almost half the class in-person. It would be even worse. I'm getting pretty close to just pulling the kids out until this is all over, I don't have any experience with formal homeschooling but I'm certain I can do better for them than what they're getting right now.That's WAY too long to be on zoom. Brutal. Our 7 year old (big age difference of course) only spends three hours a day on zoom but that also includes 30 minutes of breaks and snacks. With the various subjects, activities and the breaks it seems to work great.
This is what they are doing for our return to school at all grade levels. Unfortunately I fear that what has fortunately been overall pretty positive result with all remote thus far will now be a shell of what it was because of this hybrid approach.Crazy to think that for a long time the plan was to have teachers do this while simultaneously teaching almost half the class in-person. It would be even worse.
In the summer, our teachers made one demand: we will teach a class F2F with proper safety precautions or we will teach a class virtually but we won't do both.This is what they are doing for our return to school at all grade levels. Unfortunately I fear that what has fortunately been overall pretty positive result with all remote thus far will now be a shell of what it was because of this hybrid approach.
I agree...3 kids in three different schools (1st, 2nd, and 7th)...been over 8 weeks of full in-person school without issues. Wife teaches as well. All public schools in Georgia.My son has been back in school for weeks. Things going great.
Good to hear. I think things around here have mostly been good. Only a few schools here and there shut back down and it was only for a couple days at a timeMy son has been back in school for weeks. Things going great.
There was an isolated case the first week. But it didn't spread and there was no shutdownGood to hear. I think things around here have mostly been good. Only a few schools here and there shut back down and it was only for a couple days at a time
Yeah it seems like the districts having better results were the ones that prepped for the most likely outcome which is that it would be virtual at least to start.My 6- and 9-year olds are on zoom for 5 hours a day. It's a trainwreck. I've been saying it forever but the district unfortunately wasted the entire summer figuring out how to get kids back in the building instead of figuring out how to provide the best possible remote learning experience, and so now when they switched at the last moment to all-remote (like I predicted they would all along), we got this ####ty outcome. Crazy to think that for a long time the plan was to have teachers do this while simultaneously teaching almost half the class in-person. It would be even worse. I'm getting pretty close to just pulling the kids out until this is all over, I don't have any experience with formal homeschooling but I'm certain I can do better for them than what they're getting right now.
Around here we had a HS who had 6 positives on the soccer team but they shut the school down for a long weekend and I guess it was ok. One thing I will say, I am not entirely sure the schools are all being totally honest about exposures and who is at risk. I know someone from a school who had a positive (also related to sports) and the school didn't disclose it. Their rationale was "he didn't talk to anyone face to face for 15 minutes so there is no risk, we don't need to inform anyone". I guess that is the new standard and Michigan is pretty strict. There was also a parent who came to an open house to meet all the teachers who called a couple days later to report he had COVID. He said he lied on the forms he had to fill out ahead of the open house because while he had tested positive for COVID a few days earlier, he didn't believe it. However, he said he now had a 2nd positive result so he felt he should inform the school. I believe that was kept from the staff and families because it was deemed he wore a mask while at the school. Once the rumor leaked, a lot of people were upset they didn't at least get a heads up.There was an isolated case the first week. But it didn't spread and there was no shutdown
I was saying this from the start, but the only way to control the situation is to go for all virtual from the start. That gives everyone a full summer to prep. If things are fine and people can come back, that is an easy transition. Plus if you start with a solid virtual plan and run it for a month to start the year, everything is ready to flip back if things flare up again.Yeah it seems like the districts having better results were the ones that prepped for the most likely outcome which is that it would be virtual at least to start.
Feel bad for what some in here are going through![]()
Yeah but that just makes too much sense.I was saying this from the start, but the only way to control the situation is to go for all virtual from the start. That gives everyone a full summer to prep. If things are fine and people can come back, that is an easy transition. Plus if you start with a solid virtual plan and run it for a month to start the year, everything is ready to flip back if things flare up again.
Yep and democratic institutions are messy and there are always things like job security and school board elections that factor in. It's not easy getting a bunch of school board members and administrators all on the same page. Also this is a good lesson in how important it is for everyone to pay attention to school board elections. If you like or don't like how your school handled this, it's the elected school board to credit or blame.Yeah but that just makes too much sense.
This is my world. Only about 15-20% at home, but I hate the mix.My 6- and 9-year olds are on zoom for 5 hours a day. It's a trainwreck. I've been saying it forever but the district unfortunately wasted the entire summer figuring out how to get kids back in the building instead of figuring out how to provide the best possible remote learning experience, and so now when they switched at the last moment to all-remote (like I predicted they would all along), we got this ####ty outcome. Crazy to think that for a long time the plan was to have teachers do this while simultaneously teaching almost half the class in-person. It would be even worse. I'm getting pretty close to just pulling the kids out until this is all over, I don't have any experience with formal homeschooling but I'm certain I can do better for them than what they're getting right now.
You are not alone. The number of good, experienced teachers just hanging it up is scary. My wife is based out of the admin building, but she is out and about in the schools during her days and she says the numbers are significant. Another group that has resigned in large numbers are the school nurses.I've been teaching online for 8 weeks now. The video sessions 5 hours a day is draining. I put in way more time with meetings, planning, grading, parent contacts than before. My stress level is through the roof. I feel like I'm on the clock all day. I try to keep class time light, supportive, upbeat, interesting to try and keep students engaged. I've scaled back my curriculum and reconfigured my grading practices. It's just never enough. I feel like if this is the new norm, I'm pretty much done.
This is similar to my wife's experiences, as well as her colleagues. It's hell doing the video and in-class stuff while trying to protect the kids.I've been teaching online for 8 weeks now. The video sessions 5 hours a day is draining. I put in way more time with meetings, planning, grading, parent contacts than before. My stress level is through the roof. I feel like I'm on the clock all day. I try to keep class time light, supportive, upbeat, interesting to try and keep students engaged. I've scaled back my curriculum and reconfigured my grading practices. It's just never enough. I feel like if this is the new norm, I'm pretty much done.
How long are these sessions?I've been teaching online for 8 weeks now. The video sessions 5 hours a day is draining. I put in way more time with meetings, planning, grading, parent contacts than before. My stress level is through the roof. I feel like I'm on the clock all day. I try to keep class time light, supportive, upbeat, interesting to try and keep students engaged. I've scaled back my curriculum and reconfigured my grading practices. It's just never enough. I feel like if this is the new norm, I'm pretty much done.
I didn't know school nurses still existedYou are not alone. The number of good, experienced teachers just hanging it up is scary. My wife is based out of the admin building, but she is out and about in the schools during her days and she says the numbers are significant. Another group that has resigned in large numbers are the school nurses.
Your daughter is the exact reason I expect we will try to keep this full time and maybe have a HS of 500 or so kids who only/mostly do virtualI don't envy these kids having to sit there in a zoom session that goes 4 hours. I would just lose it. My 16 year old daughter still loves her remote learning through the on line school. She likes being able to sleep in some days and watch the live lessons later. What is great is she can go hard in one class and finish it now and then tackle another class--so sort of like a block plan. She has days where she watches tv for a few hours in the morning, does a couple hours of lessons, takes a nap, does a few more hours in the afternoon and then maybe an hour in the evening. Two of her classes are AP and one is honors, so these are not cakewalk classes. They have clubs that are starting up now--she is in a leadership/debate type club and a book club. I wish they had this type of schooling when i was growing up---I would have jumped at it.
As I have mentioned before, she suffers from depression/anxiety. There are days where she struggles and we have to motivate her to get things done--so that is why on-line works so well for her vs having to physically go to a school. Thank goodness I am still able to work from home most days, so I am able to be here on those days to support her. The one day I went into work last week, I had prolonged contact with a person who tested positive two days later, so I am just at the point I hate leaving the house.
Y'all don't get paid enough.Anyone have any advice on how a teacher would
1. Broach the conversation with a parent that their kid needs a better environment for online school? I helped a kid today 1 on 1 through Zoom and a baby was crying, dog was barking, mom was yelling, an alarm ringing randomly every few minutes and their computer isn't working very well (I have told them multiple times the school will give them a new computer, just come by the office from 8-3, we have a ton of them charged and ready).
2. Starting a conversation with parents that their kid can not just write "CNN is fake" when their Govt teacher assigns them to watch a video from the site and write what they learned. Or call other kids in class "lib tards", post "Trump 2020" as a comment in the classroom over and over again or insist that rules about being nice are for people who need to toughen up. Politics aside, how does one deal with behaviors that are objectively disruptive to a work environment but are "political" and likely reflect the kind of things being said at home? I am at a loss here.
Regarding #1, that's a tough spot. Have you had the conversation regarding devices with the parents, or was it the kid you mentioned it to? Can you send an email to the entire school to highlight the importance of a productive home environment and some tips for that as well as mentioning the resources available to them regarding the devices. Though I get the impression that these parents may not be the type to read emails. The more direct route would be to set up a call with the parents and discuss the importance of a productive environment for their child, but again, I get the impression that they may not be receptive to that.Anyone have any advice on how a teacher would
1. Broach the conversation with a parent that their kid needs a better environment for online school? I helped a kid today 1 on 1 through Zoom and a baby was crying, dog was barking, mom was yelling, an alarm ringing randomly every few minutes and their computer isn't working very well (I have told them multiple times the school will give them a new computer, just come by the office from 8-3, we have a ton of them charged and ready).
2. Starting a conversation with parents that their kid can not just write "CNN is fake" when their Govt teacher assigns them to watch a video from the site and write what they learned. Or call other kids in class "lib tards", post "Trump 2020" as a comment in the classroom over and over again or insist that rules about being nice are for people who need to toughen up. Politics aside, how does one deal with behaviors that are objectively disruptive to a work environment but are "political" and likely reflect the kind of things being said at home? I am at a loss here.