East Tennessee and Alabama/Mississippi have exactly nothing in common except being SEC country. East Tennessee was never cotton country, was not a big slavery area by the mid-19th century, and has always been rugged Appalachian country -- completely culturally different than AL, MS, etc. West TN is Deep South -- flat cotton country where slavery was deeply embedded in the culture. Even now West TN and East TN are remarkably different geographically, culturally, politically, and demographically.My![]()
Mississippi/Alabama is the dirty south, which I believe is the core of the deep south.
Extending outward, the deep south includes sections of Louisiana along the MS border, as well as an enlarged southeastern Tennessee quadrant (to include Nashville and Knoxville).
East Tennessee and Alabama/Mississippi have exactly nothing in common except being SEC country. East Tennessee was never cotton country, was not a big slavery area by the mid-19th century, and has always been rugged Appalachian country -- completely culturally different than AL, MS, etc. West TN is Deep South -- flat cotton country where slavery was deeply embedded in the culture. Even now West TN and East TN are remarkably different geographically, culturally, politically, and demographically.My![]()
Mississippi/Alabama is the dirty south, which I believe is the core of the deep south.
Extending outward, the deep south includes sections of Louisiana along the MS border, as well as an enlarged southeastern Tennessee quadrant (to include Nashville and Knoxville).
Memphis is considered the largest city in 3 states: TN by geography and MS and AR by culture and proximity.
Okie doke, if you say so: West Tennessee is Deep South (and not deep Midwest) and East Tennessee is not. I'm not going to debate indignant hillbilly.East Tennessee and Alabama/Mississippi have exactly nothing in common except being SEC country. East Tennessee was never cotton country, was not a big slavery area by the mid-19th century, and has always been rugged Appalachian country -- completely culturally different than AL, MS, etc. West TN is Deep South -- flat cotton country where slavery was deeply embedded in the culture. Even now West TN and East TN are remarkably different geographically, culturally, politically, and demographically.My![]()
Mississippi/Alabama is the dirty south, which I believe is the core of the deep south.
Extending outward, the deep south includes sections of Louisiana along the MS border, as well as an enlarged southeastern Tennessee quadrant (to include Nashville and Knoxville).
Memphis is considered the largest city in 3 states: TN by geography and MS and AR by culture and proximity.
Wow. That escalated quickly. Most people who have never been to TN don't understand its makeup. When Bud decided to bolt Houston early because the locals had turned their back on the lame duck franchise, he thought a 2-year stay in memphis before the stadium in Nashville was finished was the thing to do. Everyone in Middle TN knew that was a mistake. Memphis hates Nashville. 28,000 folks in a 62,000 seat stadium ain't pretty. So he quickly moved to Vandy -- a 40,000 seat stadium that was so bad he needed special permission from the NFL and NFLPA to play there.Okie doke, if you say so: West Tennessee is Deep South (and not deep Midwest) and East Tennessee is not. I'm not going to debate indignant hillbilly.East Tennessee and Alabama/Mississippi have exactly nothing in common except being SEC country. East Tennessee was never cotton country, was not a big slavery area by the mid-19th century, and has always been rugged Appalachian country -- completely culturally different than AL, MS, etc. West TN is Deep South -- flat cotton country where slavery was deeply embedded in the culture. Even now West TN and East TN are remarkably different geographically, culturally, politically, and demographically.Memphis is considered the largest city in 3 states: TN by geography and MS and AR by culture and proximity.My![]()
Mississippi/Alabama is the dirty south, which I believe is the core of the deep south.
Extending outward, the deep south includes sections of Louisiana along the MS border, as well as an enlarged southeastern Tennessee quadrant (to include Nashville and Knoxville).
Why are yankees so rude?Okie doke, if you say so: West Tennessee is Deep South (and not deep Midwest) and East Tennessee is not. I'm not going to debate indignant hillbilly.East Tennessee and Alabama/Mississippi have exactly nothing in common except being SEC country. East Tennessee was never cotton country, was not a big slavery area by the mid-19th century, and has always been rugged Appalachian country -- completely culturally different than AL, MS, etc. West TN is Deep South -- flat cotton country where slavery was deeply embedded in the culture. Even now West TN and East TN are remarkably different geographically, culturally, politically, and demographically.My![]()
Mississippi/Alabama is the dirty south, which I believe is the core of the deep south.
Extending outward, the deep south includes sections of Louisiana along the MS border, as well as an enlarged southeastern Tennessee quadrant (to include Nashville and Knoxville).
Memphis is considered the largest city in 3 states: TN by geography and MS and AR by culture and proximity.
YOU LIE !!Why are yankees so rude?Okie doke, if you say so: West Tennessee is Deep South (and not deep Midwest) and East Tennessee is not. I'm not going to debate indignant hillbilly.East Tennessee and Alabama/Mississippi have exactly nothing in common except being SEC country. East Tennessee was never cotton country, was not a big slavery area by the mid-19th century, and has always been rugged Appalachian country -- completely culturally different than AL, MS, etc. West TN is Deep South -- flat cotton country where slavery was deeply embedded in the culture. Even now West TN and East TN are remarkably different geographically, culturally, politically, and demographically.My![]()
Mississippi/Alabama is the dirty south, which I believe is the core of the deep south.
Extending outward, the deep south includes sections of Louisiana along the MS border, as well as an enlarged southeastern Tennessee quadrant (to include Nashville and Knoxville).
Memphis is considered the largest city in 3 states: TN by geography and MS and AR by culture and proximity.
yeah well SE Ohio and WVA may very well lead that pack.any state where the average number of teeth per mouth is roughly equal to the number of children per household.
I could have sworn I distinguished between western and eastern Tennessee in my original post.Wow. That escalated quickly.Most people who have never been to TN don't understand its makeup. When Bud decided to bolt Houston early because the locals had turned their back on the lame duck franchise, he thought a 2-year stay in memphis before the stadium in Nashville was finished was the thing to do. Everyone in Middle TN knew that was a mistake. Memphis hates Nashville. 28,000 folks in a 62,000 seat stadium ain't pretty. So he quickly moved to Vandy -- a 40,000 seat stadium that was so bad he needed special permission from the NFL and NFLPA to play there.Okie doke, if you say so: West Tennessee is Deep South (and not deep Midwest) and East Tennessee is not. I'm not going to debate indignant hillbilly.East Tennessee and Alabama/Mississippi have exactly nothing in common except being SEC country. East Tennessee was never cotton country, was not a big slavery area by the mid-19th century, and has always been rugged Appalachian country -- completely culturally different than AL, MS, etc. West TN is Deep South -- flat cotton country where slavery was deeply embedded in the culture. Even now West TN and East TN are remarkably different geographically, culturally, politically, and demographically.Memphis is considered the largest city in 3 states: TN by geography and MS and AR by culture and proximity.My![]()
Mississippi/Alabama is the dirty south, which I believe is the core of the deep south.
Extending outward, the deep south includes sections of Louisiana along the MS border, as well as an enlarged southeastern Tennessee quadrant (to include Nashville and Knoxville).
Culturally West TN is where the rednecks are. East TN is where the hillbillies are.
Edit: Stupid phone.
Add Western PA to that list too. West Opennsyltucky, baby. Not Deep South, but it's something that's for damn sure.yeah well SE Ohio and WVA may very well lead that pack.any state where the average number of teeth per mouth is roughly equal to the number of children per household.
That's low.New Orleans is 2 feet below sea level that's pretty deep.
You did, but you lumped the mountainous area with the scenery in with the flat cotton country of AL and MS. East TN is way more like Western VA and Western NC. I'm not saying it's some bastion of enlightenment and sophistication, it's just nothing like the Deep South.I could have sworn I distinguished between western and eastern Tennessee in my original post.To add:Wow. That escalated quickly.Most people who have never been to TN don't understand its makeup. When Bud decided to bolt Houston early because the locals had turned their back on the lame duck franchise, he thought a 2-year stay in memphis before the stadium in Nashville was finished was the thing to do. Everyone in Middle TN knew that was a mistake. Memphis hates Nashville. 28,000 folks in a 62,000 seat stadium ain't pretty. So he quickly moved to Vandy -- a 40,000 seat stadium that was so bad he needed special permission from the NFL and NFLPA to play there.Okie doke, if you say so: West Tennessee is Deep South (and not deep Midwest) and East Tennessee is not. I'm not going to debate indignant hillbilly.East Tennessee and Alabama/Mississippi have exactly nothing in common except being SEC country. East Tennessee was never cotton country, was not a big slavery area by the mid-19th century, and has always been rugged Appalachian country -- completely culturally different than AL, MS, etc. West TN is Deep South -- flat cotton country where slavery was deeply embedded in the culture. Even now West TN and East TN are remarkably different geographically, culturally, politically, and demographically.Memphis is considered the largest city in 3 states: TN by geography and MS and AR by culture and proximity.My![]()
Mississippi/Alabama is the dirty south, which I believe is the core of the deep south.
Extending outward, the deep south includes sections of Louisiana along the MS border, as well as an enlarged southeastern Tennessee quadrant (to include Nashville and Knoxville).
Culturally West TN is where the rednecks are. East TN is where the hillbillies are.
Edit: Stupid phone.
Eastern Tennessee - Better natural scenery
Western Tennessee - Better music
I'm so glad we could work together and pinpoint the center of the universe.You did, but you lumped the mountainous area with the scenery in with the flat cotton country of AL and MS. East TN is way more like Western VA and Western NC. I'm not saying it's some bastion of enlightenment and sophistication, it's just nothing like the Deep South.I could have sworn I distinguished between western and eastern Tennessee in my original post.To add:Wow. That escalated quickly.Most people who have never been to TN don't understand its makeup. When Bud decided to bolt Houston early because the locals had turned their back on the lame duck franchise, he thought a 2-year stay in memphis before the stadium in Nashville was finished was the thing to do. Everyone in Middle TN knew that was a mistake. Memphis hates Nashville. 28,000 folks in a 62,000 seat stadium ain't pretty. So he quickly moved to Vandy -- a 40,000 seat stadium that was so bad he needed special permission from the NFL and NFLPA to play there.Okie doke, if you say so: West Tennessee is Deep South (and not deep Midwest) and East Tennessee is not. I'm not going to debate indignant hillbilly.East Tennessee and Alabama/Mississippi have exactly nothing in common except being SEC country. East Tennessee was never cotton country, was not a big slavery area by the mid-19th century, and has always been rugged Appalachian country -- completely culturally different than AL, MS, etc. West TN is Deep South -- flat cotton country where slavery was deeply embedded in the culture. Even now West TN and East TN are remarkably different geographically, culturally, politically, and demographically.Memphis is considered the largest city in 3 states: TN by geography and MS and AR by culture and proximity.My![]()
Mississippi/Alabama is the dirty south, which I believe is the core of the deep south.
Extending outward, the deep south includes sections of Louisiana along the MS border, as well as an enlarged southeastern Tennessee quadrant (to include Nashville and Knoxville).
Culturally West TN is where the rednecks are. East TN is where the hillbillies are.
Edit: Stupid phone.
Eastern Tennessee - Better natural scenery
Western Tennessee - Better music
Interestingly (to me anyway) is the fact that Fulmer always got bashed for not being able to recruit Memphis, which was "right there in state". Never mind that 7 of the 11 other SEC schools (then, now it's 9 of 13) are closer to Memphis than UT, and 6 (excluding Vandy) are culturally much more similar to Memphis than U
Those states don't exist anymore.How about any state where at least 30% of the people claim that flying the "Confederate" flag (in any form) is about "heritage".
Terrible food except for the BBQ. Moved back to the north last summer though. I won't miss it a bit.You are a resident of the deepest deep South. Please educate us.Texas is opposed to same state penetration.Does the deep south penetrate Texas?![]()
Where are you now GB?Terrible food except for the BBQ. Moved back to the north last summer though. I won't miss it a bit.You are a resident of the deepest deep South. Please educate us.Texas is opposed to same state penetration.Does the deep south penetrate Texas?![]()
West Virginia ain't the Deep South. Not by anybody's definition.I recently came back from a trip to the "Deep" South.
Quite frankly, I find these people anything but deep.
I was in West Virgina. This is the kind of place where people read the Sunday comics with a yellow highlighter, in case they stumble upon a particularly meaningful passage in Beetle Bailey.
I went to my first square dance in West Virginia. Here's an activity I don't get nearly enough of, huh? I go out to dance, I go to express myself. These people are into being ordered around the floor by some neo-fascist Sam Drucker, some bizarre BF Skinner hoedown.
Hill country ain't the Deep South. KY-TN-WV got plenty of hillbillies but that's not the same thing.I recently came back from a trip to the "Deep" South.
Quite frankly, I find these people anything but deep.
I was in West Virgina. This is the kind of place where people read the Sunday comics with a yellow highlighter, in case they stumble upon a particularly meaningful passage in Beetle Bailey.
I went to my first square dance in West Virginia. Here's an activity I don't get nearly enough of, huh? I go out to dance, I go to express myself. These people are into being ordered around the floor by some neo-fascist Sam Drucker, some bizarre BF Skinner hoedown.
Well. By mine it is. It is both west and south of Philly.West Virginia ain't the Deep South. Not by anybody's definition.I recently came back from a trip to the "Deep" South.
Quite frankly, I find these people anything but deep.
I was in West Virgina. This is the kind of place where people read the Sunday comics with a yellow highlighter, in case they stumble upon a particularly meaningful passage in Beetle Bailey.
I went to my first square dance in West Virginia. Here's an activity I don't get nearly enough of, huh? I go out to dance, I go to express myself. These people are into being ordered around the floor by some neo-fascist Sam Drucker, some bizarre BF Skinner hoedown.
West Virginia was a Union state. All yours GB.I recently came back from a trip to the "Deep" South.
Quite frankly, I find these people anything but deep.
I was in West Virgina. This is the kind of place where people read the Sunday comics with a yellow highlighter, in case they stumble upon a particularly meaningful passage in Beetle Bailey.
I went to my first square dance in West Virginia. Here's an activity I don't get nearly enough of, huh? I go out to dance, I go to express myself. These people are into being ordered around the floor by some neo-fascist Sam Drucker, some bizarre BF Skinner hoedown.
"detailed studies have concluded that there were nearly equal numbers of Union and Confederate soldiers."West Virginia was a Union state. All yours GB.I recently came back from a trip to the "Deep" South.
Quite frankly, I find these people anything but deep.
I was in West Virgina. This is the kind of place where people read the Sunday comics with a yellow highlighter, in case they stumble upon a particularly meaningful passage in Beetle Bailey.
I went to my first square dance in West Virginia. Here's an activity I don't get nearly enough of, huh? I go out to dance, I go to express myself. These people are into being ordered around the floor by some neo-fascist Sam Drucker, some bizarre BF Skinner hoedown.
I agree with this, hence:The Deep South is a state of mind.
fantasycurse42 said:I'm not looking for a Wiki answer here, more so what comes to mind when you think of the deep south, and which states would you associate with this?
From Alabama so I think I have some expertise here.fantasycurse42 said:I'm not looking for a Wiki answer here, more so what comes to mind when you think of the deep south, and which states would you associate with this?
No, Texas has nothing to do with the SouthDoes the deep south penetrate Texas?![]()
West Virginia soldiery numbers in the Civil War have never been reliable. If I remember my Civil War history right, I think both the Confederacy and the Union drafted soldiers out of West Virginia. Either way, there's no dispute that West Virginia seceded from Virginia because Virginia seceded from the Union and because Richmond and the agricultural low country didn't really give much of a rat's ### about the mountain country."detailed studies have concluded that there were nearly equal numbers of Union and Confederate soldiers."West Virginia was a Union state. All yours GB.I recently came back from a trip to the "Deep" South.
Quite frankly, I find these people anything but deep.
I was in West Virgina. This is the kind of place where people read the Sunday comics with a yellow highlighter, in case they stumble upon a particularly meaningful passage in Beetle Bailey.
I went to my first square dance in West Virginia. Here's an activity I don't get nearly enough of, huh? I go out to dance, I go to express myself. These people are into being ordered around the floor by some neo-fascist Sam Drucker, some bizarre BF Skinner hoedown.
How did you ever come away with the impression that West Virginia was part of the south?I recently came back from a trip to the "Deep" South.
Quite frankly, I find these people anything but deep.
I was in West Virgina. This is the kind of place where people read the Sunday comics with a yellow highlighter, in case they stumble upon a particularly meaningful passage in Beetle Bailey.
I went to my first square dance in West Virginia. Here's an activity I don't get nearly enough of, huh? I go out to dance, I go to express myself. These people are into being ordered around the floor by some neo-fascist Sam Drucker, some bizarre BF Skinner hoedown.
This seems about right to me. The southeaster counties were more loyal to Virginia/the Confederacy.West Virginia soldiery numbers in the Civil War have never been reliable. If I remember my Civil War history right, I think both the Confederacy and the Union drafted soldiers out of West Virginia. Either way, there's no dispute that West Virginia seceded from Virginia because Virginia seceded from the Union and because Richmond and the agricultural low country didn't really give much of a rat's ### about the mountain country."detailed studies have concluded that there were nearly equal numbers of Union and Confederate soldiers."West Virginia was a Union state. All yours GB.I recently came back from a trip to the "Deep" South.
Quite frankly, I find these people anything but deep.
I was in West Virgina. This is the kind of place where people read the Sunday comics with a yellow highlighter, in case they stumble upon a particularly meaningful passage in Beetle Bailey.
I went to my first square dance in West Virginia. Here's an activity I don't get nearly enough of, huh? I go out to dance, I go to express myself. These people are into being ordered around the floor by some neo-fascist Sam Drucker, some bizarre BF Skinner hoedown.
Establishing that a portion of West Virginia was/is part of the South.This seems about right to me. The southeaster counties were more loyal to Virginia/the Confederacy.West Virginia soldiery numbers in the Civil War have never been reliable. If I remember my Civil War history right, I think both the Confederacy and the Union drafted soldiers out of West Virginia. Either way, there's no dispute that West Virginia seceded from Virginia because Virginia seceded from the Union and because Richmond and the agricultural low country didn't really give much of a rat's ### about the mountain country."detailed studies have concluded that there were nearly equal numbers of Union and Confederate soldiers."West Virginia was a Union state. All yours GB.I recently came back from a trip to the "Deep" South.
Quite frankly, I find these people anything but deep.
I was in West Virgina. This is the kind of place where people read the Sunday comics with a yellow highlighter, in case they stumble upon a particularly meaningful passage in Beetle Bailey.
I went to my first square dance in West Virginia. Here's an activity I don't get nearly enough of, huh? I go out to dance, I go to express myself. These people are into being ordered around the floor by some neo-fascist Sam Drucker, some bizarre BF Skinner hoedown.
Interesting quick read. Pretty telling numbers from the Wheeling Convention link: 37,451 Virginians voted against secession (against 132,201 for). Of those 37,451 votes, an estimated 34,677 came from counties that would comprise West Virginia, which means 2774 people in modern Virginia voted against secession (against 113,080 for).wdcrob said:This seems about right to me. The southeaster counties were more loyal to Virginia/the Confederacy.Tennessee_ATO said:West Virginia soldiery numbers in the Civil War have never been reliable. If I remember my Civil War history right, I think both the Confederacy and the Union drafted soldiers out of West Virginia. Either way, there's no dispute that West Virginia seceded from Virginia because Virginia seceded from the Union and because Richmond and the agricultural low country didn't really give much of a rat's ### about the mountain country.Joe Summer said:"detailed studies have concluded that there were nearly equal numbers of Union and Confederate soldiers."GoFishTN said:West Virginia was a Union state. All yours GB.Jack%20White said:I recently came back from a trip to the "Deep" South.
Quite frankly, I find these people anything but deep.
I was in West Virgina. This is the kind of place where people read the Sunday comics with a yellow highlighter, in case they stumble upon a particularly meaningful passage in Beetle Bailey.
I went to my first square dance in West Virginia. Here's an activity I don't get nearly enough of, huh? I go out to dance, I go to express myself. These people are into being ordered around the floor by some neo-fascist Sam Drucker, some bizarre BF Skinner hoedown.
Please.Tennessee_ATO said:Add Western PA to that list too. West Opennsyltucky, baby. Not Deep South, but it's something that's for damn sure.Binky The Doormat said:yeah well SE Ohio and WVA may very well lead that pack.Scoresman said:any state where the average number of teeth per mouth is roughly equal to the number of children per household.
I think you're thinking of central PA. East and West PA are pretty good. It's the center of the state that has banjos playing on loop.Tennessee_ATO said:Add Western PA to that list too. West Opennsyltucky, baby. Not Deep South, but it's something that's for damn sure.Binky The Doormat said:yeah well SE Ohio and WVA may very well lead that pack.Scoresman said:any state where the average number of teeth per mouth is roughly equal to the number of children per household.
I hail from western PA. My mom's family hails primarily from eastern OH, right on the river. My maternal grandfather's family comes from West Virginia coal country. Lots of Welsh background on my mom's side (both of her parents' families) -- a wee people who were very useful in the coal mines of the region way back when.Please.Tennessee_ATO said:Add Western PA to that list too. West Opennsyltucky, baby. Not Deep South, but it's something that's for damn sure.Binky The Doormat said:yeah well SE Ohio and WVA may very well lead that pack.Scoresman said:any state where the average number of teeth per mouth is roughly equal to the number of children per household.
Drive 15 minutes outside of Pittsburgh in any direction and let me know what you find. I'm going with mountains, multi-generational poverty, and a history rooted in the Appalachian culture everywhere. I'll give you the field.I think you're thinking of central PA. East and West PA are pretty good. It's the center of the state that has banjos playing on loop.Tennessee_ATO said:Add Western PA to that list too. West Opennsyltucky, baby. Not Deep South, but it's something that's for damn sure.Binky The Doormat said:yeah well SE Ohio and WVA may very well lead that pack.Scoresman said:any state where the average number of teeth per mouth is roughly equal to the number of children per household.
Then what is the "south east"??Rick James said:Georgia
Alabama
South Carolina
Tennessee
North Carolina
Mississippi
Southern Kentucky
Northern Florida
Louisiana
The Deep South. HTHThen what is the "south east"??Rick James said:Georgia
Alabama
South Carolina
Tennessee
North Carolina
Mississippi
Southern Kentucky
Northern Florida
Louisiana
I grew up there too. The North Hills and South Hills areas - more than 15 minutes outside of Pittsburgh - are very affluent. As is most of all of northern Washington County. There are pockets of poverty, but you've got to be in your 50s and 60s to even vaguely remember a predominance of active coal mining activity.I hail from western PA. My mom's family hails primarily from eastern OH, right on the river. My maternal grandfather's family comes from West Virginia coal country. Lots of Welsh background on my mom's side (both of her parents' families) -- a wee people who were very useful in the coal mines of the region way back when.Please.Tennessee_ATO said:Add Western PA to that list too. West Opennsyltucky, baby. Not Deep South, but it's something that's for damn sure.Binky The Doormat said:yeah well SE Ohio and WVA may very well lead that pack.Scoresman said:any state where the average number of teeth per mouth is roughly equal to the number of children per household.
I know of which I speak.