What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

Welcome to Our Forums. Once you've registered and logged in, you're primed to talk football, among other topics, with the sharpest and most experienced fantasy players on the internet.

Democratic leaders call for Omar to apologize for 'anti-Semitic tropes' (1 Viewer)

Because arguing the first allows people to demonize the left for making the comparison...rather than come to the realization of how we are treating these people. 
Which is why she needs to choose her words more carefully and account for the fact that there are a lot of dimwitted people more interested in getting hung up on semantics than addressing the cruelty being visited on these innocent children by our government. The majority of those people are unreachably awful, but I have to assume there are at least a few who draw the line at childr...ah #### it, who am I kidding.

 
Which is why she needs to choose her words more carefully and account for the fact that there are a lot of dimwitted people more interested in getting hung up on semantics than addressing the cruelty being visited on these innocent children by our government. The majority of those people are unreachably awful, but I have to assume there are at least a few who draw the line at childr...ah #### it, who am I kidding.
There's a good parallel here -- I think so anyway -- between this issue and the abortion thread.  When a pro-life person drops into an abortion argument and starts talking about murdering babies, all that accomplishes is derailing the conversation into a semantic argument about what the tern "murder" means and what a "baby" is, without actually addressing any of the underlying substantive issues.  If you just want to blow off some steam and fling some rhetoric around the internet, that's fine I suppose.  But if you actually want to have an adult conversation, it's important to choose your words accordingly.

 
When has she said something that was inflammatory and/or dumb? Haven't seen/read/heard anything from her that fits that description.
She really hasn’t regarding the prison camps.  Where kids are being sexually assaulted and abused.  It’s a rightwing talking point.  It’s just an excuse to look the other way.

 
https://twitter.com/willmenaker/status/1151945057852973056

Every single person who gave even a second's credence to the idea that Ilhan Omar harbors antisemitic beliefs or speaks in antisemitic "tropes".... come collect your prize!
No I reject this.

I was troubled by her Benjamins remark. I wrote that here. It may have been anti-semitic. I'm not sure. But I was concerned by it, and by some other statements by her.

But she is a citizen, a congresswoman, with a right to say what she wants, and nothing she has said was anti-American IMO. So I reject the notion that it's one or the other, that if I criticize her I'm on Trump's side. Sorry, but that is crap.

 
No I reject this.

I was troubled by her Benjamins remark. I wrote that here. It may have been anti-semitic. I'm not sure. But I was concerned by it, and by some other statements by her.

But she is a citizen, a congresswoman, with a right to say what she wants, and nothing she has said was anti-American IMO. So I reject the notion that it's one or the other, that if I criticize her I'm on Trump's side. Sorry, but that is crap.
I agree but I really wish Omar would tone down her rhetoric as I am very concerned it will cost us votes in the long run.

 
I was troubled by her Benjamins remark. I wrote that here. It may have been anti-semitic.
It wasn't.  At all.  

No I reject this.

But she is a citizen, a congresswoman, with a right to say what she wants, and nothing she has said was anti-American IMO. So I reject the notion that it's one or the other, that if I criticize her I'm on Trump's side. Sorry, but that is crap.
It's not to say that if you were troubled by one thing, you automatically believe in the other.  It's to say that the badfaith crocodile tears over "antisemitic tropes," which Democratic elites used to single Omar out in an extremely disingenuous way, absolutely teed her up for this trash.  

 
No I reject this.

I was troubled by her Benjamins remark. I wrote that here. It may have been anti-semitic. I'm not sure. But I was concerned by it, and by some other statements by her.

But she is a citizen, a congresswoman, with a right to say what she wants, and nothing she has said was anti-American IMO. So I reject the notion that it's one or the other, that if I criticize her I'm on Trump's side. Sorry, but that is crap.
First, I agree with your overall take that just because the crowd at Trump’s rally chanted “Send her back!” about Ilhan Omar doesn’t mean it was wrong to be critical of Omar’s statements regarding Jewish-Americans.

Second, I’m not sure if you’ve had a chance to listen to this audio where Omar seems to compare Al Qaeda to America or the American Army in the level of respect or disdain that should be accorded to those respective parties when saying them aloud.  One could certainly argue that the overall gist of her message is either that “Al Qaeda isn’t that bad to warrant a disdainful tone when mentioning them” or “America and the American Army deserve to be mentioned in as disdainful tone as Al Qaeda.”  I think either is a fair construction of her statements.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
One could certainly argue that the overall gist of her message is either that “Al Qaeda isn’t that bad to warrant a disdainful tone when mentioning them” or “America and the American Army deserve to be mentioned in as disdainful tone as Al Qaeda.”
One man's terrorists is another man's freedom fighter. 

 
One man's terrorists is another man's freedom fighter. 
That’s certainly true, but then it’s fair to question which label Omar is putting on which entity.

Plus it’s 2019.  We should switch “man” to “woman” in that maxim for greater wokeness.

 
First, I agree with your overall take that just because the crowd at Trump’s rally chanted “Send her back!” about Ilhan Omar doesn’t mean it was wrong to be critical of Omar’s statements regarding Jewish-Americans.

Second, I’m not sure if you’ve had a chance to listen to this audio where Omar seems to compare Al Qaeda to America or the American Army in the level of respect or disdain that should be accorded to those respective parties when saying them aloud.  One could certainly argue that the overall gist of her message is either that “Al Qaeda isn’t that bad to warrant a disdainful tone when mentioning them” or “America and the American Army deserve to be mentioned in as disdainful tone as Al Qaeda.”  I think either is a fair construction of her statements.
Yeah, I’ve listened to it a number of times. I don’t get it, honestly. I have no idea what she was trying to say there. I suspect that she was laughing at her professor for some physical thing and you’d have to see it, but I don’t know. 

But let’s suppose the worst for a moment: that she loves al-qaeda. Does that make her anti-American? Not necessarily. It would certainly make her unsavory and not somebody I want to know (though I suspect this is true one way or another.) 

 
The party leaderships are extremely pro-Israel, and Ilhan Omar isn't.  It's as simple as that.  
There’s definitely truth to this.  We not only see the divide between between the Democratic Party’s position on Israel and some Squad member’s position on that State, but we’re also seeing a growing divide between the Democratic Party and their more Progressive base with regard to Israel.

 
Yeah, I’ve listened to it a number of times. I don’t get it, honestly. I have no idea what she was trying to say there. I suspect that she was laughing at her professor for some physical thing and you’d have to see it, but I don’t know. 

But let’s suppose the worst for a moment: that she loves al-qaeda. Does that make her anti-American? Not necessarily. It would certainly make her unsavory and not somebody I want to know (though I suspect this is true one way or another.) 
Again I ask,  why would someone that loves Al Qaeda vote YES for funding on the 9/11 First Responders bill.   So she "supported" the murders of thousands of people on that day but now wants to the best for the people that tried to save them.  Come on

also this idea that the Democratic party is the party that hates Jews while all the Republicans just love them all is laughable.  Probably equal amount on both sides.   I mean all you have to do is see the constant stereotypes that were used in the 2016 election including using the Star of David on an anti Hillary tweet.   Republicans just have other groups that they hate way way more.  

 
Last edited by a moderator:
https://twitter.com/AliAbunimah/status/1151983779126435840

The attacks on @IlhanMN are of course racist, sexist, xenophobic and Islamophobic. But if she were a Black woman like @condoleezzarice or @ambassadorrice, or Muslim like @realzalmaymk, who served & supported US empire & the status quo, she would be rewarded instead of attacked.

In other words, the threat @IlhanMN poses to the system is not that she is Black and Muslim and in Congress. It is that she is Black and Muslim and using her position in Congress to speak out against US militarism and support for Israel.

If @IlhanMN were content to be a show piece for "diversity," quietly going along with whatever garbage @SpeakerPelosi told her to go along with, she would be celebrated and rewarded. But her unforgiveable crime in eyes of regime elites is actually to represent people.

I don't support every position @IlhanMN takes, but her courage is real and she's getting bolder. I hope she's realizing that the price they make you pay for 1/100th of your convictions is the same as they make you pay for all your convictions. So might as well stand for something

 
https://twitter.com/AliAbunimah/status/1151983779126435840

The attacks on @IlhanMN are of course racist, sexist, xenophobic and Islamophobic. But if she were a Black woman like @condoleezzarice or @ambassadorrice, or Muslim like @realzalmaymk, who served & supported US empire & the status quo, she would be rewarded instead of attacked.

In other words, the threat @IlhanMN poses to the system is not that she is Black and Muslim and in Congress. It is that she is Black and Muslim and using her position in Congress to speak out against US militarism and support for Israel.

If @IlhanMN were content to be a show piece for "diversity," quietly going along with whatever garbage @SpeakerPelosi told her to go along with, she would be celebrated and rewarded. But her unforgiveable crime in eyes of regime elites is actually to represent people.

I don't support every position @IlhanMN takes, but her courage is real and she's getting bolder. I hope she's realizing that the price they make you pay for 1/100th of your convictions is the same as they make you pay for all your convictions. So might as well stand for something
Thanks, I was wondering what Ali Abunimah had to say on this.

 
Thanks, I was wondering what Ali Abunimah had to say on this.
By the way, I never had a problem with you posting tweets on here.  I think Twitter's a useful platform for information.  It's kind of weak to post about Maddow's ratings, or whatever clapback one of your slay kweens did, but I never had a problem with it.  

Abunimah is the editor for electronicintifada, and has spent most of his career covering the Palestine/Israel issue.  It's an issue that the actual left has been coming around on for a long time now.  But because he criticizes Democrats you're going to write him off rather than engage on substance.  Very lame

 
By the way, I never had a problem with you posting tweets on here.  I think Twitter's a useful platform for information.  It's kind of weak to post about Maddow's ratings, or whatever clapback one of your slay kweens did, but I never had a problem with it.  

Abunimah is the editor for electronicintifada, and has spent most of his career covering the Palestine/Israel issue.  It's an issue tha t the actual left has been coming around on for a long time now.  But because he criticizes Democrats you're going to write him off rather than engage on substance.  Very lame
What is a slay kween?

And who said I had a problem with the tweet? Just found it amusing given all the criticism I have received over supposedly posting random tweets from obscure tweeters that no one has ever heard of.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Abunimah is the editor for electronicintifada, and has spent most of his career covering the Palestine/Israel issue.  
This seems to be a superfluous sentence. I wouldn’t expect somebody who calls his website “electronicintifada” to be focused on China vs Taiwan. 

(I also have doubts that anyone who edits such a website is going to have good feelings about Israel, lol.) 

 
It is also okay to be critical of Israel, their policies, and our relationship with Israel and not be anti Semitic.
I agree 100%.  It is also okay for people to be critical of AOC and Omar and not be racist or misogynist.  I think that is where most in this forum lose their way and have a difficult time discerning.   My dad always taught me to be an "aware" liberal.  Don`t just drink Kool-Aid because someone tells you to, and think for yourself. 

 
I agree 100%.  It is also okay for people to be critical of AOC and Omar and not be racist or misogynist.  I think that is where most in this forum lose their way and have a difficult time discerning.   My dad always taught me to be an "aware" liberal.  Don`t just drink Kool-Aid because someone tells you to, and think for yourself. 
True. But to most people in America  when a white person tells a person of color to "go back to were you came from"  that's being racist. 

 
So now squistion is chiding other posters for copying and pasting random stuff from social media.
Heaven forbid you make an offhanded comment about the DSM when he's already brought it into the conversation. He might jump down your throat and ask you about gays and mental illness for the week.

R U OR R U NOT A MENTAL ILL LIKE EMINMENCE? 

I couldn't tell whether he was still mad about the Marshall Mathers LP or Stuart Ullman's old alias. 

As for Omar, I really think Coal Man and you both have it nailed. But I also say this country, especially with so many seeking asylum, has a temperament where we actually want those glad to be here and there's no stain on our country when we'd rather have these "communities" that vote forth these people under more scrutiny at the entry points to our country. 

 
Last edited by a moderator:
True. But to most people in America  when a white person tells a person of color to "go back to were you came from"  that's being racist. 
Sure, when the comment is made based solely on ethnicity or the color of someone's skin. When it is made due to perceived anti-American comments, it isn't racist. Maybe racially insensitive but not racist.

 
rockaction said:
As for Omar, I really think Coal Man and you both have it nailed. But I also say this country, especially with so many seeking asylum, has a temperament where we actually want those glad to be here and there's no stain on our country when we'd rather have these "communities" that vote forth these people under more scrutiny at the entry points to our country. 
I honestly believe that there is a bit of racism and paternalism at play when we expect gratitude from those who come here, especially because it always seems to be centered at minorities. 

Freedom is freedom. When Omar came to this country as a kid she started attending our schools and she was taught you’re free to think anything you like. You’re free to be critical of the government or society if you don’t like something. You’re not in Somalia anymore. I think that’s great. 

 
Mile High said:
True. But to most people in America  when a white person tells a person of color to "go back to were you came from"  that's being racist. 
What do we label it when a black person tells a person of color to go back to their own country?

 
It's okay to dislike Ilhan Omar and also be glad that our country welcomes people like her.  
We should also make sure not to confuse disingenuous smears of her positions and beliefs, with genuine disagreement on her actual policies and views.  

The antisemitic remarks that Ilhan Omar never made have swiftly become a commonly accepted myth.

 
IvanKaramazov said:
So now squistion is chiding other posters for copying and pasting random stuff from social media.
No, I wasn't. I found it amusing and somewhat ironic that after the constant criticism I received for supposedly posting random tweets (none of which were actually chosen randomly as they all related to the subject matter that was under discussion) if the same thing is done by someone on the right the response is always :crickets: (as it has been here).

 
I honestly believe that there is a bit of racism and paternalism at play when we expect gratitude from those who come here, especially because it always seems to be centered at minorities. 

Freedom is freedom. When Omar came to this country as a kid she started attending our schools and she was taught you’re free to think anything you like. You’re free to be critical of the government or society if you don’t like something. You’re not in Somalia anymore. I think that’s great. 
Yeah, that's a good point. I'm not really commenting on the "send her back" chants, which are typically odious. I'm more talking about a deeper, more personally-held reaction. I think that personally, I'm very grateful for my late ancestors' immigration to the New World. One often hopes the same of other recipients of such open arms. Alas, it is indeed sometimes that people see outside of provincialism and become fierce critics. Omar's response to our response to radical Islamism may be her Solzhenistyn moment at Harvard in its presience if lack of gratitude. 

 
No, I wasn't. I found it amusing and somewhat ironic that after the constant criticism I received for supposedly posting random tweets (none of which were actually chosen randomly as they all related to the subject matter that was under discussion) if the same thing is done by someone on the right the response is always :crickets: (as it has been here).
It’s been explained to you many times that when someone does it once in a blue moonit’s not a big deal 

When you do it every day , it’s annoying 

what part of that don’t you understand?

 
It’s been explained to you many times that when someone does it once in a blue moonit’s not a big deal 

When you do it every day , it’s annoying 

what part of that don’t you understand?
I don’t understand it because I have never found it annoying. 

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top