What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Devin Aromashodus Value (1 Viewer)

Shermdog4444

Footballguy
With the recent news that he stands to be the WR1 in Chicago what do you think this guys value is? A few weeks ago I was looking to trade him for a late first rounder in a rookie draft and was scoffed at. Now I don't think I could let him go for that little. I own him in all of my dynasty leagues and sort of want to hold him and see what happens. What do you think he could be traded for in a PPR dynasty league right now?

 
As a Bears fan...I am leaning towards Aromashodu and Knox starting with Bennett helping on 3 WR sets.

But then again who knows:

-Iglesius was a 3rd round pick last year that hasn't been used yet.

-Martz has a large effect on the offense...who starts, who is more effective with his routes, etc. (does he prefer short quick WR's or a 6'2 Aromashodu?)

-Cutler has more time with his WR's now and they could seperate(the starters or #1) in camp.

On Aromashodu's positives: He was a 4 star recruit coming out of HS.

Negatives: This will be his 5th NFL season I think....and has already bounced around to a a couple teams.

As far as value...I offered up the 2.3 in a rookie draft and was quickly declined.

 
I would definitely hold. His value will only increase as it gets closer to the start of the season - something like Garcon/Maclin range.

 
Not sure about your question specifically, but I'm definitely a believer. There were a couple guys here who had touted him early on, noting how much Cutler raved about him in practice and was begging for him to be put into action. Big thanks to those guys as he (combined with Cutler) won me my Week 17 championship.

I don't see what's not to like. Good size, good speed, goes up for the ball well...and major production when given the opportunity (think he had one stinker in the games where he saw real action), combined with continued opportunity with a QB who will throw early and often.

You obviously trade him for a stud but I don't think I'd swap him for many of those receivers ranked in the 15-25 range, the potential is hard to pass up.

 
Recent draft results that included college players and NFL FA's. Aroma went at 1.07 before Hardesty and Golden Tate

1.01 1. Mighty CSD * jurb26's, College Player FA Def Sun Apr 25 5:59:07 p.m. CT 2010 RB, Mark Ingram, Alabama

1.02 2. SYD Terrapin Mathews, Ryan SDC RB ® Sun Apr 25 5:59:07 p.m. CT 2010 Pick made based on Pre-Draft List

1.03 3. Terminator * ffgiant's, College Player FA Def Sun Apr 25 10:22:41 p.m. CT 2010 College player Ryan Williams RB Virginia Tech

1.04 4. Weaselicious * rabidfireweasel's, College Player FA Def Mon Apr 26 7:26:32 p.m. CT 2010 trent richardson rb alabama

1.05 5. Phoenix Rising Thomas, Demaryius DEN WR ® Tue Apr 27 10:23:48 a.m. CT 2010

1.06 6. Bear's Lair Tate, Ben HOU RB ® Tue Apr 27 3:58:21 p.m. CT 2010 Tough call for me - seems like a huge gamble

1.07 7. SYD Terrapin Aromashodu, Devin CHI WR Tue Apr 27 4:26:25 p.m. CT 2010

1.08 8. Wranglers Hardesty, Montario CLE RB ® Tue Apr 27 11:09:17 p.m. CT 2010 I need RB help and Hardesty seems like a solid pick here.

1.09 9. Helmet Heads Tate, Golden SEA WR ® Wed Apr 28 7:39:38 a.m. CT 2010

1.10 10. Phoenix Rising * Duckboy's, College Player FA Def Wed Apr 28 1:57:10 p.m. CT 2010 WR Michael Floyd, Notre Dame

1.11 11. Weaselicious Gerhart, Toby MIN RB ® Wed Apr 28 6:50:24 p.m. CT 2010 Good player- crummy situation. Given the dreck I have at rb, I am inclined to take the best talent.

1.12 12. Pride of Pei Mei McCluster, Dexter KCC WR ® Thu Apr 29 8:53:09 a.m. CT 2010 - BPA -

1.13 13. Bishop Reign Clausen, Jimmy CAR QB ® Thu Apr 29 10:08:54 a.m. CT 2010

1.14 14. Serenity Now * soothsayer's, College Player FA Def Thu Apr 29 11:40:11 a.m. CT 2010 Jonathan Baldwin - WR - Pitt. I think he deserves to be in the mix with Floyd/Green as to who is the best WR prospect in the 2011 class. With three college guys likely to go before my next pick I didn't want to risk not getting him...jacked to be able to draft him here thx to the earlier trade with Offdee.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
His value is definitely already on the rise. Two recent examples from the past week from two of my leagues:

1) Dynasty trade: Matt Schaub and Vince Jackson for Drew Brees and Aromashadu.

2) saw him drafted at 6.05 in a keeper draft. However you should probably add about a round to get an idea for strict re-draft. He was selected before the likes of Britt, Housh, Royal, Driver, Cotchery, Breaston, and Sananta Moss.

I've been considering the bears situation and IMO there will be multiple WRs with good value there. The hard part is figuring out who. From what I'm speculating, Aroma will be the WR1 with either Bennett or Knox at the 2 and Hester in the slot. there will certainly be lots of of targets to go around and I'm certain that more than 1 of these guys will be useful.

Consider 2007 Lions as a floor:

McDonald - 79/943/6

Williams - 64/838/5

Furrey - 61/664/1

and 2006 Lions, a bit more optimistic:

Furrey - 98/1086/6

Williams - 82/1310/7

Kevin Jones was 3rd.

I'm expecting Aroma to fill that old Roy Williams role. Anyone have knowledge about how they use Furrey back then? Was he in the slot or the split end?

 
I've got him in a large 16 team salary league and it would be difficult for me to trade him right now. His value cannot go anywhere but up with the WR1 rumors, Martz offense and Cutlers arm.

 
In a 14 team league, I traded my (expected late) 1st round rookie/vewt pick in 2011 for the 2.02 and 2.03 this year. Took Aromashodu at 2.02 (and Mike Wiliams at 2.03).

I think Aroma is worth a late first, early second. Has as good of a chance to be a #1 WR than all but 2 or 3 of the rookie WRs. Worth the gamble.

 
WOW....y'all are infering an awful lot from not a whole lot. Arom. is an intriguing young prospect, but he's far from a sure bet to be the Bear's #1, let alone worthy of some of the players he's mentioned against here. While I obviously don't always agree with the staff rnakings, it's telling that he's ranked only in the mid 40's for dynasty, and one staffer didn't rank him at all.

FWIW, I would put him in the early to mid 30's...and would jump at the chance to add a known quality YOUNG WR like Maclin or a known semi-stud like Ocho for him. I think those of you sticking him in the top 20 are out of your minds!

 
To me, he's the leading "potential" WR out there. He's about where Miles Austin was at this point last year - not to say he'll be Miles Austin or anything, but it's similar in where he's regarded by owners.

I was offered Schilens and Brandon Tate for him, and I turned it down. Aroma is almost untradable straight up at this point, because nobody will move a stud/proven player (understandable), yet those who hold him aren't taking guys like Schilens, etc. He's a good second guy in a trade to make up value (I traded Colston for Bowe and Aroma earlier this year).

 
To me, he's the leading "potential" WR out there. He's about where Miles Austin was at this point last year - not to say he'll be Miles Austin or anything, but it's similar in where he's regarded by owners.

I was offered Schilens and Brandon Tate for him, and I turned it down. Aroma is almost untradable straight up at this point, because nobody will move a stud/proven player (understandable), yet those who hold him aren't taking guys like Schilens, etc. He's a good second guy in a trade to make up value (I traded Colston for Bowe and Aroma earlier this year).
I think you might be underestimating Schilens a bit with the addition of a viable starting QB in Oakland.
I traded Colston for Bowe and Aroma earlier this year.
That's a great trade for you.
Ehhh I disagree. I just don't think Bowe ever reaches the same high levels again.
 
Peso obviously thinks Devin is huge value

I would not trade Chad for him or Colston for Bowe and him in my league.

I think the 2007 Lions is a good qualifier and that the ball will get spread around. Cant stay with the Colts and lose out to Roy Hall still says alot to me.

 
His 1st 2 years he was buried behind Reggie Wayne and Marvin Harrison. I'm more concerned with why they let him go, and what happened to him his 3rd season, which looks like a lost season of sorts.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XW_QD3i5iik
What he does at the 245 mark and toward the end of the video is pretty good stuff. He also shows some pretty good field awareness, alway popping up and moving forward in case he isn't touched. Also knows when to get out of bounds. He hammered the Packers and the Vikings pretty good.
 
JPeso said:
Steed said:
Was just offered Ocho straight up for him in a dynasty league. Still chewing it over.
This feels forced to me. I'd rather gamble on Aroma.
omg
Chad maintains his current value for one more year, and then he hits the Driver-like value. I'd rather have Aroma and pay pennies for older productive players at 210 points rather than have my value be entirely with an older productive player at 230 points. Even if Aroma busts, you aren't out THAT much.
 
WOW....y'all are infering an awful lot from not a whole lot. Arom. is an intriguing young prospect, but he's far from a sure bet to be the Bear's #1, let alone worthy of some of the players he's mentioned against here. While I obviously don't always agree with the staff rnakings, it's telling that he's ranked only in the mid 40's for dynasty, and one staffer didn't rank him at all.FWIW, I would put him in the early to mid 30's...and would jump at the chance to add a known quality YOUNG WR like Maclin or a known semi-stud like Ocho for him. I think those of you sticking him in the top 20 are out of your minds!
People are assuming that a "Miles Austin" rears his head every season and the Aroma is that guy this season.
 
Peso obviously thinks Devin is huge valueI would not trade Chad for him or Colston for Bowe and him in my league.
Not huge by any means - it's more likely that I don't value Chad as much as some, and also don't see a material gap in Bowe and Colston.
 
I'm just deeply suspicious of anyone anointed as WR1 on the team by default. With Martz there you're already throwing darts trying to pick which inexperienced guy will put up numbers, and as Aroma becomes a more popular pick I prefer the idea of getting Bennet or Knox 5 rounds later. I know Aroma scored on Woodson last year but I don't suddenly see him putting up starting FF numbers weekly against top CBs.

 
This guy has more over-inflated, unsubstantiated value than any player I can remember in quite some time. If this were any other NFL team, besides the Bears, he would be on the roster bubble.

 
Aromashodu is a player that will be hard to know how he will produce.

There is good reason why he was drafted in 2006 (7th round) and this is his 5th(Dolphins, Colts, Texans, Redskins, Bears) team since the draft.

Miami Dolphins - failed to make the team's opening day roster.

Colts - Practice squad and 7 catches for 96 yards with the colts in the regular season.

Texans - practice squad

Redskins - practice squad

but when you look at the last 4 games of last season you seem to see a player that was cutlers favorite target, its a real small sample size but maybe something clicked. also Cutler lobbied last season to get him on the field and then we saw why cutler wanted him.

I am cautiously optimistic about Aromashodu.

If we extrapolates Devin Aromashodu's statistics from the final four games of 2009 and project them for a full season, they're pretty impressive - 88 receptions for 1,128 yards and 16 touchdowns. but that is not a good way to look at it as teams would make adjustment for him after some success.

 
This guy has more over-inflated, unsubstantiated value than any player I can remember in quite some time. If this were any other NFL team, besides the Bears, he would be on the roster bubble.
He makes Charles Woodson his plaything at about the 2:45 mark of the video. Just sayin. Defensive MVP we are talking about here. :rolleyes:
 
I was just offered Pierre Thomas for Aromashodu and 2011 2nd rounder. Im not sure If I will accept it.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I'm just deeply suspicious of anyone anointed as WR1 on the team by default. With Martz there you're already throwing darts trying to pick which inexperienced guy will put up numbers, and as Aroma becomes a more popular pick I prefer the idea of getting Bennet or Knox 5 rounds later. I know Aroma scored on Woodson last year but I don't suddenly see him putting up starting FF numbers weekly against top CBs.
Lets not forget Hester...dude was a CORNER in college, and has made steady improvement every year as a WR. People are writing him off too easily. I thnk Hester has every bit as much of a chance to to be the Bears top producer as any of them.
 
I'm just deeply suspicious of anyone anointed as WR1 on the team by default. With Martz there you're already throwing darts trying to pick which inexperienced guy will put up numbers, and as Aroma becomes a more popular pick I prefer the idea of getting Bennet or Knox 5 rounds later. I know Aroma scored on Woodson last year but I don't suddenly see him putting up starting FF numbers weekly against top CBs.
Lets not forget Hester...dude was a CORNER in college, and has made steady improvement every year as a WR. People are writing him off too easily. I thnk Hester has every bit as much of a chance to to be the Bears top producer as any of them.
I agree with this. But that said, I think there is just as good a chance that Hester is the WR/PR/KR again if Martz likes two guys more than him. I could see him excelling in the Az Hakim role. Right now it looks like you have 4 guys atop the depth chart. And if you have 4 front runners, you really have none.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
This guy has more over-inflated, unsubstantiated value than any player I can remember in quite some time. If this were any other NFL team, besides the Bears, he would be on the roster bubble.
:goodposting: Was fixing to post the same thing. By far the single most overrated FF prospect I've seen in years. Talking about an average-at-absolute-best talent, a guy who's been passed around the league like a hot potato, he of 24 catches last year. I mean, seriously, WTF? Is all this hype coming off one game? Please join my league, give me 75/1000 and I'll give you 24/300. Please.
 
I'm a Bears homer, and I like Aromashodu, and even I think that his value is a little insane right now.

People very familiar with the Bears have absolutely no idea how things will shake out with the WRs this year, so I don't get how so many people are convinced that Aromashodu is going to be Brandon Marshall part 2. No one really knows what's going to happen with these WRs since none of them are exceptionally talented and Martz is kind of crazy. Martz has previously forced the ball into Mike Furrey's hands for a whole season. He's also said that the WRs on this team are the strength of the team, and that you can "put it in granite"! Really? How can anyone pretend to do anything more than make a poorly educated guess on this group of guys? If that is all you have on Aromashodu, then you should not be parting with middle to early 1sts in order to get him. JMO.

Hester, Aromashodu, and Knox have all been the flavor of the month at some point or another with Bears, with Aromashodu benefiting from the recency effect - he's the last one to get hot, so he's the one on everyone's minds. Even Earl Bennett has had a brief run of fantasy relevancy. With all of these guys in the mix, none of them clearly outplaying anyone else, Cutler being kind of wild and Martz being weird as ever, you just can't be sure of anything here.

Here's something I'm curious about: if people are consistently shooting down offers of a late 2010 1st for Aromashodu in dynasty leagues (accounts in this thread and my own experiences support this), we can assume that many value him at being worth at least a mid 1st rounder. What other WRs, then, do we see consistently going for around a middle 1st round 2010 pick? I am curious to see what other WRs are going for about that level of compensation...

 
This guy has more over-inflated, unsubstantiated value than any player I can remember in quite some time. If this were any other NFL team, besides the Bears, he would be on the roster bubble.
Weeks 14-17 are hard to ignore and Cutler loves him.14 21.6 vs Packers 8 76 1 12 15 3.0 at Ravens 2 10 10 16 28.0 vs Vikings 7 150 1 9 17 21.6 at Lions 5 46 2 8
 
Just drafted him at 3.08 in one rookie/fa draft, and feel that was good value, considering some of the talent available in the back of the 3rd.If I already owned him, I'm not sure I'd let him go for anything less than 1.07-1.09, where I know I could land someone like D Thomas or Benn to replace him (ie, a young, penciled-in WR1). I dont think I could land equal potential in the top of the second round of this particular draft class.It might be only four games of fantasy relevancy, but its still four more games of proof than any rookie, Cutler lobbied *a lot* for his playing time, and he could easily put up WR2 numbers in Martz's system if he is the full-time WR1.Further to that, Reggie Wayne laid a sound bite on him last year, which is the same kind of nugget regarding Garcon from Caldwell which we all clamped on to ("somewhat of a force"):

Jan 25thReggie Wayne thinks that Devin Aromashodu can be "a starter and a big-time guy in this league."Wayne got to know Aromashodu while the emerging Bears wideout was with the Colts in 2006 and 2007. While Aromashodu hasn't been declared a starter yet, Jay Cutler's obsession with him combined with his late-season push makes it certain that he'll at least get to compete for a job in camp.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
This guy has more over-inflated, unsubstantiated value than any player I can remember in quite some time. If this were any other NFL team, besides the Bears, he would be on the roster bubble.
:shrug: Was fixing to post the same thing. By far the single most overrated FF prospect I've seen in years. Talking about an average-at-absolute-best talent, a guy who's been passed around the league like a hot potato, he of 24 catches last year. I mean, seriously, WTF? Is all this hype coming off one game?

Please join my league, give me 75/1000 and I'll give you 24/300. Please.
This same sort of argument was often made regarding Ray Rice last year as his perceived value steadily increased throughout the summer. The writing was on the wall for those will to take the plunge.... same as Aromashadu. People were yacking/hating about Rice's value getting too high as it crept up into the 5th, 4th, and finally late 3rd round (redraft) as the season got closer, and many people threw in the towel and said forget it. Don't you think they wish they'd spent that 3.11 pick on Rice in retrospect? sometimes you have to go with instinct (backed up by research of course). The comparison of Rice pre-2009 and Aromashadu pre-2010 are actually fairly consistent. There WERE lots of carries and receptions to be had in the Baltimore backfield, it was just a matter of figuring out who was going to get them. When the Ravens shipped out that full back, i forget his name, it was obvious that McClain would play FB with Rice and McGahee splitting duty at HB. Same situation for the Bears. Under Martz and Cutler, THERE WILL BE TARGETS. Enough for several WRs to have fantasy value. You just have to figure out who. It's already been stated that Martz wants Hester in the slot and back returning punts. Knox and Bennet are NOT WR1 material.

Furthermore, it's not ONE game, and not even that he had some nice fantasy points in 3 of the last 4 games. he also had major targets, even in the Baltimore game when he only had two catches. 39 targets in 4 games. that's a pace of 156 targets in 16 games. We all know Cutler can lock onto his favorite WR for better or worse.... Brandon Marshall had 180 targets in 2008.

As for the 24 catches.... hmm I wonder who else had a season like that before breaking out big time..... wait for it...... Brandon Marshall once again!

Marshall 2006 - 20 catches, 309 yards, 2 TDs

Marshall 2007 - 102 catches, 1325 yards, 7 TDs

Aromashadu 2009 - 24 catches, 298 yards, 4 TDs

Aromashadu 2010?

If he gets 150 targets, and maintains his 56% catch rate.... 84 receptions... at his current YPC (12.4) thats 1,041 yards. Keep in mind this is before the MARTZ effect.

If you can get Aromashadu now, do it. Before the news comes out in training camp/preseason that he will, in fact, be the flanker in Martz's offense. The writing is on the wall.

 
This guy has more over-inflated, unsubstantiated value than any player I can remember in quite some time. If this were any other NFL team, besides the Bears, he would be on the roster bubble.
:lmao: Was fixing to post the same thing. By far the single most overrated FF prospect I've seen in years. Talking about an average-at-absolute-best talent, a guy who's been passed around the league like a hot potato, he of 24 catches last year. I mean, seriously, WTF? Is all this hype coming off one game? Please join my league, give me 75/1000 and I'll give you 24/300. Please.
This sounds like someone who hasn't seem him play much. If you have, I don't see how you can't see that he has potential.
 
there is no such precedent for a player bouncing around or floundering in obscurity then finally catching on and succeeding........oh wait there are. u also cannot ignore how much Cutler loves this guy. when Cutler loves a guy and the radar lock is on, watchout. pretty sure he lead the team in targets everyweek once he got his chance to shine. Targets are like the #1 precursor for predicting a breakout player.

 
This guy has more over-inflated, unsubstantiated value than any player I can remember in quite some time. If this were any other NFL team, besides the Bears, he would be on the roster bubble.
:thumbup: Was fixing to post the same thing. By far the single most overrated FF prospect I've seen in years. Talking about an average-at-absolute-best talent, a guy who's been passed around the league like a hot potato, he of 24 catches last year. I mean, seriously, WTF? Is all this hype coming off one game?

Please join my league, give me 75/1000 and I'll give you 24/300. Please.
This same sort of argument was often made regarding Ray Rice last year as his perceived value steadily increased throughout the summer. The writing was on the wall for those will to take the plunge.... same as Aromashadu. People were yacking/hating about Rice's value getting too high as it crept up into the 5th, 4th, and finally late 3rd round (redraft) as the season got closer, and many people threw in the towel and said forget it. Don't you think they wish they'd spent that 3.11 pick on Rice in retrospect? sometimes you have to go with instinct (backed up by research of course). The comparison of Rice pre-2009 and Aromashadu pre-2010 are actually fairly consistent. There WERE lots of carries and receptions to be had in the Baltimore backfield, it was just a matter of figuring out who was going to get them. When the Ravens shipped out that full back, i forget his name, it was obvious that McClain would play FB with Rice and McGahee splitting duty at HB. Same situation for the Bears. Under Martz and Cutler, THERE WILL BE TARGETS. Enough for several WRs to have fantasy value. You just have to figure out who. It's already been stated that Martz wants Hester in the slot and back returning punts. Knox and Bennet are NOT WR1 material.

Furthermore, it's not ONE game, and not even that he had some nice fantasy points in 3 of the last 4 games. he also had major targets, even in the Baltimore game when he only had two catches. 39 targets in 4 games. that's a pace of 156 targets in 16 games. We all know Cutler can lock onto his favorite WR for better or worse.... Brandon Marshall had 180 targets in 2008.

As for the 24 catches.... hmm I wonder who else had a season like that before breaking out big time..... wait for it...... Brandon Marshall once again!

Marshall 2006 - 20 catches, 309 yards, 2 TDs

Marshall 2007 - 102 catches, 1325 yards, 7 TDs

Aromashadu 2009 - 24 catches, 298 yards, 4 TDs

Aromashadu 2010?

If he gets 150 targets, and maintains his 56% catch rate.... 84 receptions... at his current YPC (12.4) thats 1,041 yards. Keep in mind this is before the MARTZ effect.

If you can get Aromashadu now, do it. Before the news comes out in training camp/preseason that he will, in fact, be the flanker in Martz's offense. The writing is on the wall.
I don't see the comparison with Rice. Rice was a high draft pick, Aromashadu a 7th rounder. Rice is on his original team, Aromashadu has bounced around a bunch of teams, none of whom really made any effort to keep the guy.
 
His 1st 2 years he was buried behind Reggie Wayne and Marvin Harrison. I'm more concerned with why they let him go, and what happened to him his 3rd season, which looks like a lost season of sorts.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XW_QD3i5iik
I prefer Knox and Hester as dark horse WR's, but those highlights were better than expected. I actually looked up the Vikings roster to make sure that the DB that Aroma ate up late in the game really was Antoine Winfield. I still wouldn't hesitate to trade him for Ocho, Pierre Thomas, or a late 1st rounder, but he could very well prove me wrong by putting up a monster year.
 
dude looks like a player....ain't gonna back it up with stats, etc, but he looks like a guy that has figured it out...and Cutler can definately get him the ball....doesn't really matter if Cutler likes him (which he does).....it's more that Cutler respects his skills......if Cutler is going to have anybody over for Thanksgiving dinner, it will probably be Bennett......but that don't mean crap in fantasy......Cutler knows who can go and get his passes......and thats all I really care about.....DA got his passes last year and was a solid target......sometimes all you have to do is watch things....kinda like Finley last year with the Packers....you can just see it....hopefully everybody keeps passing on him and trading him away.....meanwhile the rest of us will keep a stud or grab serious value......

 
Last edited by a moderator:
for a comparison, I could see Aromashodu having a career similar to Jimmy Smith. Smith never really "got it" in Dallas before emerging in Jacksonville.

 
This guy has more over-inflated, unsubstantiated value than any player I can remember in quite some time. If this were any other NFL team, besides the Bears, he would be on the roster bubble.
:unsure: Was fixing to post the same thing. By far the single most overrated FF prospect I've seen in years. Talking about an average-at-absolute-best talent, a guy who's been passed around the league like a hot potato, he of 24 catches last year. I mean, seriously, WTF? Is all this hype coming off one game?

Please join my league, give me 75/1000 and I'll give you 24/300. Please.
This same sort of argument was often made regarding Ray Rice last year as his perceived value steadily increased throughout the summer. The writing was on the wall for those will to take the plunge.... same as Aromashadu. People were yacking/hating about Rice's value getting too high as it crept up into the 5th, 4th, and finally late 3rd round (redraft) as the season got closer, and many people threw in the towel and said forget it. Don't you think they wish they'd spent that 3.11 pick on Rice in retrospect? sometimes you have to go with instinct (backed up by research of course). The comparison of Rice pre-2009 and Aromashadu pre-2010 are actually fairly consistent. There WERE lots of carries and receptions to be had in the Baltimore backfield, it was just a matter of figuring out who was going to get them. When the Ravens shipped out that full back, i forget his name, it was obvious that McClain would play FB with Rice and McGahee splitting duty at HB. Same situation for the Bears. Under Martz and Cutler, THERE WILL BE TARGETS. Enough for several WRs to have fantasy value. You just have to figure out who. It's already been stated that Martz wants Hester in the slot and back returning punts. Knox and Bennet are NOT WR1 material.

Furthermore, it's not ONE game, and not even that he had some nice fantasy points in 3 of the last 4 games. he also had major targets, even in the Baltimore game when he only had two catches. 39 targets in 4 games. that's a pace of 156 targets in 16 games. We all know Cutler can lock onto his favorite WR for better or worse.... Brandon Marshall had 180 targets in 2008.

As for the 24 catches.... hmm I wonder who else had a season like that before breaking out big time..... wait for it...... Brandon Marshall once again!

Marshall 2006 - 20 catches, 309 yards, 2 TDs

Marshall 2007 - 102 catches, 1325 yards, 7 TDs

Aromashadu 2009 - 24 catches, 298 yards, 4 TDs

Aromashadu 2010?

If he gets 150 targets, and maintains his 56% catch rate.... 84 receptions... at his current YPC (12.4) thats 1,041 yards. Keep in mind this is before the MARTZ effect.

If you can get Aromashadu now, do it. Before the news comes out in training camp/preseason that he will, in fact, be the flanker in Martz's offense. The writing is on the wall.
I don't see the comparison with Rice. Rice was a high draft pick, Aromashadu a 7th rounder. Rice is on his original team, Aromashadu has bounced around a bunch of teams, none of whom really made any effort to keep the guy.
Yes, and Rice's first name starts with R and Aromashodu's starts with D. Rice played at Rutgers and Aroma at Auburn. Rice is a RB and Aroma a WR. etc etc. Fact is, Martz doesn't care what round you were drafted in, or who gave up on you before. See: Kurt Warner and Mike Furrey.The comparison is in the opportunity to be a breakout fantasy star.

 
His 1st 2 years he was buried behind Reggie Wayne and Marvin Harrison. I'm more concerned with why they let him go, and what happened to him his 3rd season, which looks like a lost season of sorts.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XW_QD3i5iik
I prefer Knox and Hester as dark horse WR's, but those highlights were better than expected. I actually looked up the Vikings roster to make sure that the DB that Aroma ate up late in the game really was Antoine Winfield. I still wouldn't hesitate to trade him for Ocho, Pierre Thomas, or a late 1st rounder, but he could very well prove me wrong by putting up a monster year.
Winfield was not himself after coming back from injury, but yes it was him. I'm intrigued like others by him. He could be anything from a decent WR1 for the Bears to a situational player. But, the flashes of upside he showed last year is exciting.
 
Love Aroma. Traded a lot to get him a month ago in a dynasty league. I think he is going to have a huge year and post serious WR1 numbers in that offense with Cutler chunking it all over. He flashed some real potential last season.

 
I think everyone blowing this guy's trumpet is nuts, to be honest. Going from Martz's history you could just as easily make the case that Johnny Knox is going to be the guy in his offense - or Earl Bennett - or Devin Hester - or even Iglesias. Sure, he had a nice little run at the end of the season but very often random obscure players have nice little runs at the end of the season which fool everyone. Samkon Gado anyone? Remember him?

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top