EBF
Footballguy
I've never liked Duke much. I agree with a lot of what you said. He's a sprinter with long strides, limited cutting ability, and no functional power despite whatever his listed height/weight says. Reminiscent in some ways of Knile Davis, Karlos Williams, and Darren McFadden. Definitely not my type of runner. I generally like backs with a stronger lower body, more compact running style, and more short-area quickness. The defenses in the NFL are so tough that I think the ability to be fluid and weave in-and-out of tiny holes is stressed a lot more than in college, where pure speed alone is usually sufficient to dominate. The linear guys who can't function in chaos seem to struggle. Look at Andre Williams and Knile Davis this year. Lots of carries. Not lots of results. I think Duke is another guy who might struggle to adapt. Tevin Coleman and Melvin Gordon also have questions here, but to a lesser extent.
Chris Johnson is the one mega successful runner of this ilk, but his speed was on another level and he's more agile than many of those guys.
Chris Johnson is the one mega successful runner of this ilk, but his speed was on another level and he's more agile than many of those guys.