Guys:I've been thinking that analyzing players and possible trades is useful, we might want to look at analyzing whole rosters, or at least the IDP portions. While I realize some of us will be in the same leagues, I think might be useful to see:1. How others allocate roster spots to IDP. Do they tend to go light or heavy.2. How rosters age: old-young, develop players at a particular position, etc.3. Different scoring systems, & the philosphies for dealing with them.4. How much strong IDP can make up for weak IOP, and ways to address.5. Feedback enabling the owner to get stronger.I've given some thought to presentation; at a minimum:Roster/positional limits, including cap if anyRoster, including contracts if anyRequired starting lineupScoring systemWhat do you guys think?
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums
Welcome to Our Forums. Once you've registered and logged in, you're primed to talk football, among other topics, with the sharpest and most experienced fantasy players on the internet.
Dynasty Roster Analysis Threads - Good idea? (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter stevec
- Start date
houndirish
Footballguy
I'd do it. 
I will try and get this rolling by the end of the week. I will post a fomrat I think covers things pretty well in a day or so - very busy right now.Not going to fly until Monday.I will try and put together a format for the initial post over the weekend.
Last edited by a moderator:
I would be interested in participating in this. I currently subscribe to Fantasy Football Champs for their analysis of trades and players.QB:B.Leftwich, D.Garrard, JP Losman, K.HolcombRB:W.McGahee, D.McCalister, C.BensonWR:S.Smith, D.Branch, D.Givens, A.Battle, J.Reed, J.MathisTE:J.Witten,C.AndersonK:J.HallDL:Kevin Williams,T.Suggs,J.Hall, T.Cole, A.Hargrove, T.LaboyLB:K.Dansby, Derrick johnson, A.Thomas, D.Thornton, M.Washington, L.Hill, J.BabinDB:S.Taylor, K.Rhodes, A.Archuleta, T.Vincent, B.Scott, S.Schwiegert, J.BullocksWe have 40 man roster, 4 round rookie draft. 16 team league. I have the 2.1, 2.7, 3.16, 4.2, & 4.7 picks. Lost in finals this past season. Offensive scoring is 1 pt per 10 yards passing, rushing & receiving. 1 pt per catch & 6 pts per TD.Defensive scoring is 1 pt per tackle, .5pt per assist. 3 pts per sack, 4 pts per intereception, 6 pts per TD, 2 pts per forced fumble & fumble recovery. we can start the following options. 1 QB, 1 RB, 4WR, 0TE, 1K or 1 QB, 2RB, 3 WR, 0TE & 1K or 1QB, 1RB, 2WR, 2TE, 1K or 1QB, 1 RB, 3WR, 1TE, 1K or 1QB, 1RB, 2WR, 2TE, 1K or 1QB, 2RB, 2WR, 1TE, 1K. Defensive formations, 3 or 4 DL, 4 - 6 DB, & 2 - 4 LB Hope this is enough info.Thanks for all replies.jason
Last edited by a moderator:
Team Legacy
Footballguy
16 Team League Salary Cap/Contract League(initial draft was last yr...players from back to 2003 could be put on the dts) Drafted 13th in Vet Draft, 1.4 in Rook Draft(traded it). We are going into our 2nd year.
this team was 15-1 after the reg. season
(and the highest scoring team too)
and lost its final 2 games
Pierce Injury hurt BAD caused me to activate Crowder who put up a 1pt effort(if memory serves me), had a bye in the playoffs and in week 2 lost to the eventual champ who put up his Highest score of the yr and I put up my lowest , lost the conolation bowl to finish in 4th but drafting is seeded by reg season after the two super bowl contestants
We are in rules discussion now and there is a chance we may get rid of the contract aspect in 2 yrs...we feel the salarys(which escalate yrly and are performance based on top of a base) will create enough turnover...I am pretty much in cap hell after this yr...think i have one more good run from this squad...not sure if i need to tinker or basically leave the core alone...I know I need some DBs but they are the most plentifull thing avail on the WW and there will be some avail in RFA...We also have FRANCHISE TAGS and TRANSITIONAL TAGS(I will not be using any this yr).
$1219/2 Brees, Drew SDC QB
$1376/3 Hasselbeck, Matt SEA QB
RFA Wallace, Seneca SEA QB
$1801/4 Johnson, Rudi CIN RB
$1795/3 Jordan, Lamont OAK RB
$1713/3 Lewis, Jamal BAL RB
$ 765/2 Morris, Maurice SEA RB
$ 723/1 Taylor, Chester BAL RB
$1689/4 Smith, Steve CAR WR
$1626/5 Williams, Roy DET WR
$1193/1 Smith, Rod DEN WR
RFA Vines, Scott DET WR
RFA Boerigter, Marc KCC WR
RFA Gardner, Rod GBP WR
$ 929/2 Smith, L.J. PHI TE
RFA Becht, Anthony TBB TE
RFA Clark, Desmond CHI TE
$ 92/1 Brown, Kris HOU PK
RFA Akers, David PHI PK
$1112/1 Strahan, Michael NYG DE
$898/2 Berry, Bert ARI DE
RFA Walker, Gary HOU DE
RFA Bernard, Robert SEA DT
RFA Sapp, Warren OAK DT
RFA Redding, Cory DET DE
$1703/5 Vilma, Jonathan NYJ LB
$1518/4 Pierce, Antonio NYG LB
$ 908/2 Gold, Ian DEN LB
$ 650/3 Crowder, Channing MIA LB
$ 640/3 Henderson, E.J. MIN LB
$ 276/1 Bruschi, Tedy NEP LB
RFA Vrabel, Mike NEP LB
$1378/5 Williams, Roy DAL S
$ 513/1 Dawkins, Brian PHI S
RFA Bly, Dre' DET CB
RFA Mathis, Rashean JAC CB
RFA Woolfolk, Andre TEN CB
RFA Carpenter, Keion ATL S
RFA Clark, Ryan WAS S
CAP OVERVIEW
Total Salary: $24871
Salary Cap: $30000
Cap Room Available: $5128
I will have to fill some roster spots and that will strain the cap...we carry a 40 man roster during the season...1 cap yr must be assigned for each roster spot min....after week 8 any open roster spots dont count against the cap
After Berry went down it is easy to see I had a revolving door at DT...grabbed Sapp he got hurt, then grabbed Bernard to finish out the season.
Developmental Rookie Squad(3yr max stay)
$395 Frye, Charlie CLE QB
$ 56McCown, Luke TBB QB
$ 2Fargas, Justin OAK RB has to be activated or cut
$336 Smith, Musa BAL RB has to be activated or cut
$ 2 Woods, Rashaun SF WR
$ 2 Lyman, Chase NOS WR
$ 61 Gould, Robbie CHI PK
$211 Kaeding, Nate SDC PK
$116 Brown, Mark NYJ LB
$ 18 Hill, Leroy SEA LB
$ 2 Considine, Sean PHI S
$ 3 Harris, Chris CHI S
DRAFT Picks(picks are slotted a salary value)
Year 2006 Round 3.14
Year 2006 Round 4.14
Year 2006 Round 5.11
Year 2006 Round 5.14
Year 2006 Round 6.14
Year 2006 Round 7.14
Year 2006 Round 8.5
Year 2006 Round 8.11
Year 2006 Round 8.14
CAP HITS(cut a player it cost ya % over the course of the assigned contract)
Bo Schobel 4/$260
Glenn Earl 3/$612
Charlie Adams 3/$1
(The cap hit next yr decreases for the top 2 and adams falls off etc)
this team was 15-1 after the reg. season
(and the highest scoring team too)
and lost its final 2 games
Pierce Injury hurt BAD caused me to activate Crowder who put up a 1pt effort(if memory serves me), had a bye in the playoffs and in week 2 lost to the eventual champ who put up his Highest score of the yr and I put up my lowest
, lost the conolation bowl to finish in 4th but drafting is seeded by reg season after the two super bowl contestants We are in rules discussion now and there is a chance we may get rid of the contract aspect in 2 yrs...we feel the salarys(which escalate yrly and are performance based on top of a base) will create enough turnover...I am pretty much in cap hell after this yr...think i have one more good run from this squad...not sure if i need to tinker or basically leave the core alone...I know I need some DBs but they are the most plentifull thing avail on the WW and there will be some avail in RFA...We also have FRANCHISE TAGS and TRANSITIONAL TAGS(I will not be using any this yr).
RED=RFA$$$$/Contract Yrs Left
$1219/2 Brees, Drew SDC QB
$1376/3 Hasselbeck, Matt SEA QB
RFA Wallace, Seneca SEA QB
$1801/4 Johnson, Rudi CIN RB
$1795/3 Jordan, Lamont OAK RB
$1713/3 Lewis, Jamal BAL RB
$ 765/2 Morris, Maurice SEA RB
$ 723/1 Taylor, Chester BAL RB
$1689/4 Smith, Steve CAR WR
$1626/5 Williams, Roy DET WR
$1193/1 Smith, Rod DEN WR
RFA Vines, Scott DET WR
RFA Boerigter, Marc KCC WR
RFA Gardner, Rod GBP WR
$ 929/2 Smith, L.J. PHI TE
RFA Becht, Anthony TBB TE
RFA Clark, Desmond CHI TE
$ 92/1 Brown, Kris HOU PK
RFA Akers, David PHI PK
$1112/1 Strahan, Michael NYG DE
$898/2 Berry, Bert ARI DE
RFA Walker, Gary HOU DE
RFA Bernard, Robert SEA DT
RFA Sapp, Warren OAK DT
RFA Redding, Cory DET DE
$1703/5 Vilma, Jonathan NYJ LB
$1518/4 Pierce, Antonio NYG LB
$ 908/2 Gold, Ian DEN LB
$ 650/3 Crowder, Channing MIA LB
$ 640/3 Henderson, E.J. MIN LB
$ 276/1 Bruschi, Tedy NEP LB
RFA Vrabel, Mike NEP LB
$1378/5 Williams, Roy DAL S
$ 513/1 Dawkins, Brian PHI S
RFA Bly, Dre' DET CB
RFA Mathis, Rashean JAC CB
RFA Woolfolk, Andre TEN CB
RFA Carpenter, Keion ATL S
RFA Clark, Ryan WAS S
CAP OVERVIEW
Total Salary: $24871
Salary Cap: $30000
Cap Room Available: $5128
I will have to fill some roster spots and that will strain the cap...we carry a 40 man roster during the season...1 cap yr must be assigned for each roster spot min....after week 8 any open roster spots dont count against the cap
After Berry went down it is easy to see I had a revolving door at DT...grabbed Sapp he got hurt, then grabbed Bernard to finish out the season.
Developmental Rookie Squad(3yr max stay)
$395 Frye, Charlie CLE QB
$ 56McCown, Luke TBB QB
$ 2Fargas, Justin OAK RB has to be activated or cut
$336 Smith, Musa BAL RB has to be activated or cut
$ 2 Woods, Rashaun SF WR
$ 2 Lyman, Chase NOS WR
$ 61 Gould, Robbie CHI PK
$211 Kaeding, Nate SDC PK
$116 Brown, Mark NYJ LB
$ 18 Hill, Leroy SEA LB
$ 2 Considine, Sean PHI S
$ 3 Harris, Chris CHI S
DRAFT Picks(picks are slotted a salary value)
Year 2006 Round 3.14
Year 2006 Round 4.14
Year 2006 Round 5.11
Year 2006 Round 5.14
Year 2006 Round 6.14
Year 2006 Round 7.14
Year 2006 Round 8.5
Year 2006 Round 8.11
Year 2006 Round 8.14
CAP HITS(cut a player it cost ya % over the course of the assigned contract)
Bo Schobel 4/$260
Glenn Earl 3/$612
Charlie Adams 3/$1
(The cap hit next yr decreases for the top 2 and adams falls off etc)
Last edited by a moderator:
