Dynasty Wr #13 ranking (1 Viewer)

[Biabreakable]

This tiebreaker poll will determine who is Wr #13.

The poll that led to this tiebreaker vote: http://forums.footballguys.com/forum/index...howtopic=296071

Once a winner has been decided then I will move on with poll #14.

Results - After one week of polling on this including the original poll (what a close race the entire time) it looks to me that Lee Evans is the prefered choice here.

I could do as OZ has suggested and make Housh/Harrison #14 and 15 but Harrison had more votes than Housh in the original poll while Housh has more in this one. So I am not clear which one of these 2 may be prefered. I also do not know which one the people who voted for Evans may vote for or if they would vote for someone else. Although I do think it is very likely that these 2 will be the next Wrs to win there is a outside chance that there will be more support for another Wr over them.

So I am going to give this decision to Evans at 13 and then reopen voting for 14 rather than assuming I know the answers of how people will vote.

I am not in a hurry with these polls. I would rather try for as accurate reflection of what people think as possible. And there is also the issue of uncertainty about if Marvin or Housh are #14 to consider. So that is the reasoning behind how I am collecting this information. Although I recognise that it is very likely either Marvin or Housh will win the #14 slot I am not sure which one will. I will create poll 14 now to find out.

 

[Road Warriors]

This tiebreaker poll will determine who is Wr #13.

The poll that led to this tiebreaker vote: http://forums.footballguys.com/forum/index...howtopic=296071

Once a winner has been decided then I will move on with poll #14.

I'll take the youth over short term production. Quality WR2 with upside if the Bills improve their offense.

 

[s_ezy]

i will take 2 more top ten years from Harrison over the "potential" of TJ or Evans

i do like Housh and then evans after Harrison, but even in dyansty the goal is to win NOW

Housh and Harrison have the advantage over Evans simply due to the QBs that throw to them

between Harrison and Housh it is close, but i will take the guy with the proven track record the last 8 years

 

[Tick]

Current WR leaders:

Reggie Wayne 0 0 0 | 77 1213 9 | 175 71

Chad Johnson 6 24 0 | 80 1285 7 | 173 68

Marvin Harrison 0 0 0 | 82 1180 9 | 172 67

Terrell Owens 0 0 0 | 77 1040 11 | 170 65

Torry Holt 0 0 0 | 80 1044 10 | 164 60

Donald Driver 6 22 0 | 79 1166 7 | 161 56

Javon Walker 6 120 1 | 62 1007 7 | 161 56

Darrell Jackson 0 0 0 | 63 956 10 | 156 51

Steve Smith 6 45 1 | 76 1081 6 | 155 50

Plaxico Burress 0 0 0 | 60 907 9 | 145 40

Lee Evans 0 0 0 | 70 1082 6 | 144 39

Laveranues Coles 2 14 0 | 87 1065 6 | 144 39

T.J. Houshmandzadeh 3 6 0 | 77 943 8 | 143 38

 

[wannabee]

I like Housh here. he is very underrated.

 

[Biabreakable]

^^

 

[Ron_Mexico]

As explosive as Harrison can be,

I'll take the youth of Housh and Evans

in a dynasty format.

 

[-OZ-]

It might be worthwhile to just go with Evans/Housh at 13a / 13b and Marvin at 15.

 

[Biabreakable]

It might be worthwhile to just go with Evans/Housh at 13a / 13b and Marvin at 15.

It might. I will take that into consideration.

 

[Tick]

As explosive as Harrison can be,I'll take the youth of Housh and Evansin a dynasty format.

That's a sucky haiku.

 

[Prince Myshkin]

So what you guys are telling me is that if somebody offered you Lee Evans for Marvin Harrison straight up in a dynasty league you would take it???

I think youth is WAY overvalued by most dynasty owners and in these polls. Trying to project a guys value next year is tough....projecting it 3-5 years down the road is a shot in the dark.

 

[Biabreakable]

So what you guys are telling me is that if somebody offered you Lee Evans for Marvin Harrison straight up in a dynasty league you would take it???

I think youth is WAY overvalued by most dynasty owners and in these polls. Trying to project a guys value next year is tough....projecting it 3-5 years down the road is a shot in the dark.

So what is your method?http://forums.footballguys.com/forum/index...=296123&hl=

 

[-OZ-]

So what you guys are telling me is that if somebody offered you Lee Evans for Marvin Harrison straight up in a dynasty league you would take it???I think youth is WAY overvalued by most dynasty owners and in these polls. Trying to project a guys value next year is tough....projecting it 3-5 years down the road is a shot in the dark.

I'll tell you that as a Lee Evans owner in 3 leagues, I wouldn't consider trading him for Marvin in 2 of them. In the 3rd, I might because I need the extra 2 points this week. In the others, the future is as important as this year.Youth might be overrated, I'd say unproven youth certainly is. Evans has shown himself to be a top tier WR in the NFL already.

 

[wannabee]

Marvin will be 35 before the start of the first game next season. Yes, he is playing well, but the end could be nearer than we realize.

 

[chris1969]

It might be worthwhile to just go with Evans/Housh at 13a / 13b and Marvin at 15.

thats about the way I'd rate it.