What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Eagles vs Bears - NFC Wild Card - Henceforth Known as the Double Doink Game (1 Viewer)

I'm willing to believe that the refs got confused and used bad wording there... what I'm waiting for after the game is the refs' official ruling on the play. If they say that wasn't a catch then that flies in the face of the new rule changes. Also, why did teh refs move everyone up the field?
Probably explained it to Doug as unclearly as he did over the pa

 
Apparently youtube TV is stuck in Spanish for the game (verified on Twitter that everyone is having this issue).  Their recomendation is to download the NBC sports app and watch the game there. Great business model.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Smallwood giving up on that catch turning it into an INT was the worst Philly play of the 1st half. 

 
Like... I hope that's not the official position by the refs. You can't call it not a catch because it wasn't possessed after the catch/whistle blew. Dude just made a joke about that. That's the most obvious rule change in the offseason by the Competition Committee.

 
Feels like we are going to lose to a few trick plays like that since we can’t get offense going. Mitch isn’t impressive so far. 

 
The official rulebook disagrees. 
I don't have access to that casebook referenced in that tweet but if they do in fact have a specific case picked out for that scenario it makes little sense to do it there and not in so many others.

There is no inherent difference between an incomplete pass being changed to a fumble with no clear recovery on a sack than an incomplete pass being changed to a fumble with no clear recovery on the WR's end.  So why do they allow one but not the other?

 
See, Bears need to have Trubisky game manage this thing. Run quick outs, trick plays, runs... don't require Mitch to do complex things because he can't so far. Get a WR pass going or something.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
See, Bears need to have Trubisky game manage this thing. Run quick outs, trick plays, runs... don't require Mitch to do complex things because he can't so far. Get a WR pass g9oing or something.
If they get out of this round they are toast, Mitch could be good down the road but not ready. 

 
What's the Eagles only hope? 
Grind the Bears down and avoid 3rd and Long. Bears are moving the ball pretty well, they just had a couple of bad mistakes. Let's be real: if the Iggles scored a TD here, does anyone think the Bears and Trubisky can drive down the field and get a TD?

 
Last edited by a moderator:
@MikePereira: Instant replay was correct in staying with incomplete pass. In order to go from incomplete to catch and fumble is if there is a clear recovery by either team or if the ball goes out of bounds. Case book plays 15.114 and 15.115.


It does happen.  Most commonly on plays where a QB gets hit as he throws and it is ruled incomplete, but is determined to be a fumble on replay.  In those scenarios  (when the ball is often just left sitting on the field) it is considered a sack and the play is dead where the QB lost the ball.  They don't just arbitrarily rule it incomplete even though replay determined it was a fumble.

Same thing with a player lunging into the endzone.  If replay determined he actually fumbled the ball before breaking the plane but no one picked it up (or the recovery wasn't clear) they don't just arbitrarily leave it as a TD even when replay shows it clearly wasn't.  Instead they go back and spot the ball where the runner fumbled it.

This was the same.


I'm willing to believe that the refs got confused and used bad wording there... what I'm waiting for after the game is the refs' official ruling on the play. If they say that wasn't a catch then that flies in the face of the new rule changes. Also, why did the refs move everyone up the field?

EDIT: Wait ARE THEY SAYING WIPE OUT A CATCH BECAUSE THERE WAS NO CLEAR RECOVERY AFTER THEY THEMSELVES BLEW THE WHISTLE DEAD? WTF?

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top