What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

*FBG Ultimate Survivor* League 5 Thread (1 Viewer)

RenegadeGM

Footballguy
League 5 LEAGUE FULL

League link

Monday, August 22nd at 9:30 PM Eastern - Best Ball / All-play

PPR Scoring, with 0.5 PPR for RB

1 QB, 2 RB, 3 WR, 1 TE, 1 flex (RB/WR/TE), 1 PK, 1 Def

Draft Order (with dice roll)

1. Disco Stu - 966

2. joffer - 887

3. Tick - 816

4. BusMan - 680

5. Gamma1210 - 580

6. Will Grant - 483

7. frae - 452

8. Jene Bramel - 332

9. RenegadeGM - 328

10. LionsFan78 - 181

11. alonegunman - 73

12. Frostillicus - 28

Participants in bold were automatic entries due to past finishes.

Draft is about to start!

 
And roughly four hours later, we're done.

Glad to see Frosty finally made it aboard, but it is too bad BusMan disappeared.

I'll post what I think of my squad tomorrow... feel free anyone else.

 
Crazy schedule lately and not much time to prep…and it showed. Went in with a flexible strategy, but planned to stay away from week 5 players (at least until I locked down my starters)...but couldn’t pull it off. Got off to a decent start, but my round 3 Brady pick spun me in a direction that I never quite recovered from. LionsFan and Frosty also sniped me a few times when I had a guy queued up.

Brady, Tom NEP QB 7 3.11

Cutler, Jay CHI QB 8 10.02

After taking Brady early I immediately decided to roll with 2 QBs. Almost took Ryan with my 7.11 pick, but decided to grab another WR. No bye week issues and NE seems to be firing on all cylinders.

Mendenhall, Rashard PIT RB 11 1.11

McFadden, Darren OAK RB 8 2.02

Bush, Michael OAK RB 8 11.11

Helu, Roy WAS RB 5 15.11

Snelling, Jason ATL RB 8 16.02

Rodgers, Jacquizz ATL RB 8 17.11

Ridley, Stevan NEP RB 7 18.02

Goodson, Mike CAR RB 9 19.11

Like Mendy and McFadden as starters and snagged Bush if McFadden’s orbital bone issue lingers, but ended up neglecting depth here as I scrambled to get WRs and TEs. Decided to wait on RB (after getting sniped a few times) and load up on upside guys if a starter goes down. Not a big Helu believer, but who knows what Shanny will do. No room for error here and need Mendy and McFadden/Bush to perform to have any shot.

Marshall, Brandon MIA WR 5 5.11

Manningham, Mario NYG WR 7 4.02

Moss, Santana WAS WR 5 7.11

Green, A.J. CIN WR 7 8.02

Knox, Johnny CHI WR 8 12.02

Mason, Derrick NYJ WR 8 13.11

Bess, Davone MIA WR 5 14.02

Williams, Damian TEN WR 6 21.11

Very weak here since 3 WRs start each week and I have three players with week 5 byes. Got some WRs that are great for PPR scoring (and could be sneaky), but the lack of firepower here will likely haunt me.

Davis, Vernon SFO TE 7 6.02

Lewis, Marcedes JAC TE 9 9.11

Happy with my TEs and similar to my QBs, decided to go with two after locking down a couple top 10 guys. Lewis could even be a flex play foe me if needed. No bye week issues.

Bironas, Rob TEN PK 6 20.02

Longwell, Ryan MIN PK 9 23.11

Waited here and got below average kickers. No bye week issues, but that is rally the only positive thing to say.

Seahawks, Seattle SEA D 6 22.02

Redskins, Washington WAS D 5 24.02

Like my kickers, waited until the end and got below average results…and got stuck with a week 5 bye after all the non-bye week teams were snapped up.

Overall probably a middle of the road team that will need some big breaks and misfortune of others to move on. Look forward to the other writeups, always interesting for the 12 of us and the other leagues drafting over the next few days.

 
Sorry about last night, guys. My internet at home went down (and is still down) and like a fool I didn't copy Clayton's cell number so I couldn't inform him. Hope that didn't screw you guys up too much.

 
Well at 7 I hoped one of the non week 5 RB's would get to me. I could have taken CJ or Rice with his bye. I took Rice and then started avoiding week 5 guys. Anyway, here is how it finished up...

QB

Mike Vick

Mark Sanchez

Vince Young

Well in a 5 week league I decided that Vick's long term health wasn't as much as a concern and took him in rd 2. Young however is insurance in case.

RB

Ray Rice

Fred Jackson

Jonathan Stewart

Daniel Thomas

Shane Vereen

Rashaad Jennings

Isaac Redman

I think Rice will be great for 4 weeks, hopefully one of Jackson Stewart or Thomas can have a good week to match Ray.

WR

Mike Williams

Brandon Lloyd

Kenny Britt

Mike Sims Walker

Jacoby Jones

This is a small group but since I took 3 WR's early I decided to fill the other areas and hope that Tampa Mike, Lloyd, and Britt will be solid enough. Sims-Walker could have a couple good weeks too.

TE

Kellen Winslow

Dustin Keller

Kevin Boss

I waited on TE and decided to get 3 and hope that each week one of them shows up.

DEF

Detroit Lions

Tampa Bay Bucs

Miami Dolphins

I like Detroit this year, but again wanted some options.

K

Nate Kaeding

Billy Cundiff

Shaun Suisham

Kickers are fickle and getting points from them is tough to predict so again going with 3 and hoping to catch one with a good week each time.

If Vick is healthy and I can get RB production from Jackson, Stewart, or Thomas I could be ok. It was fun and interesting.

 
I feel like a survivor for finishing the draft awake... . :eek:
I dozed off several times. Noticed I took two defenses with week 5 byes. Meant to fix that by taking a third D, but apparently I took a fourth QB instead? :doh:My team is probably terrible. It looks ok to me, but I'm not well informed these days. I know my WRs and QB were awesome back in my day. Draft prep happened during the draft. Meant to stop by the Hawks Nest first but ran out of time. :sadbanana:QBP ManningC McCoyT JacksonC HenneRBA FosterF JonesB Green-EllisJ HarrisonB TateR WilliamsWRM WallaceR WayneA BoldinP BurressS SmithJ SimpsonJ MorganD HixonTEZ MillerB WatsonKM BryantJ BrownDRavensCowboys:shrug:
 
Sorry about last night, guys. My internet at home went down (and is still down) and like a fool I didn't copy Clayton's cell number so I couldn't inform him. Hope that didn't screw you guys up too much.
As a FGBs Survivor vet I knew there had to be an explanation. The autodraft got you lots of WRs!
 
Actually like my team out of the 5th spot. It was a spot I really didn't want since I knew the top RBs without a week 5 bye would be gone. I decided to switch it up since I figured that FBGs love to hoard WRs and I didn't want to miss out and I've been seeing RBs drop in the other leagues.

Brees, Drew NOS 11 4.08

Flacco, Joe BAL 5 11.05

My idea of waiting on QBs went out the window when I saw Brees there in the 4th. I know I took him one spot before Dodds said I was allowed to but compared to the other top QBs I loved the value. I almost didn't draft a backup, but Flacco can put up 300/3 in his offense so in best ball I really like this combo for where I got them. I wasn't going to waste a pick on a 3rd QB with no upside.

Gore, Frank SFO RB 7 2.08

Hardesty, Montario CLE RB 5 18.08

Hillis, Peyton CLE RB 5 5.05

Jacobs, Brandon NYG RB 7 9.05

Lynch, Marshawn SEA RB 6 6.08

Stephens-Howling, LaRod ARI RB 6 21.05

As I expected, RBs dropped in this league. I actually regret grabbing Gore over Forte a little, but it is only .5 PPR for RBs and the Bears O-line scares me. I think Gore will have more TDs. Hillis dropped forever because of his week 5 bye. I'll take him and his handcuff for RB1 numbers for 4 weeks. Its all play not survivor so I wasn't as concerned about filling in the week 5 bye. Lynch, Jacobs, and LSH are good best ball RBs since I won't have to guess when Jacobs gets his random 102/2 game.

Berrian, Bernard MIN WR 9 24.08

Bowe, Dwayne KCC WR 6 3.05

Floyd, Malcom SDC WR 6 10.08

Johnson, Andre HOU WR 11 1.05

Little, Greg CLE WR 5 14.08

Maclin, Jeremy PHI WR 7 7.05

Murphy, Louis OAK WR 8 22.08

Royal, Eddie DEN WR 6 15.05

Love AJ and Bowe as my top 2. Other than that, I'm not thrilled with the rest. With 3WRs and a flex, I will be hoping for RB flex points a lot. I think Maclin and Little should be a solid WR3BC. Curious to see what others think here. I like Floyd and Royal as sleepers this season.

Celek, Brent PHI TE 7 13.05

Graham, Jimmy NOS TE 11 8.08

Kendricks, Lance STL TE 5 16.08

Didn't get a stud TE early so I needed three. I should be middle of the pack here and shouldn't have a decent floor each week with them. Had to grab FBG hype machine Kendricks earlier than I had planned because he had the most upside left at that point.

Hanson, Jason DET PK 9 19.05

Hartley, Garrett NOS PK 11 17.05

Only took two so I could take another WR. No week 5 bye and good offenses.

Bills, Buffalo BUF Def 7 23.05

Panthers, Carolina CAR Def 9 20.08

Steelers, Pittsburgh PIT Def 11 12.08

Got three with no week 5 bye. Steelers should score for me 4 of the 5 weeks.

This is my first draft of this format and I actually really like my team. First three picks went as planned and then I had to adjust once I took Brees. Filled in most spots well except for my depth at WR. Not a lot of week 5 byes and Hillis is the only big contributor.

 
QB

Cassel, Matt KCC QB 6 8.11

Fitzpatrick, Ryan BUF QB 7 11.02

Garrard, David JAC QB 9 19.02

if i didn't get one of the big 5, plan was to wait pretty long. certainly nothing spectacular, but i'm ok with this trio for the first 5 weeks. I'm a big Fitspatrick fan. Garrard should be safe for the first 5 weeks even if he ####s the bed.

RB

Addai, Joseph IND RB 11 6.11

Brown, Ronnie PHI RB 7 16.11

Peterson, Adrian MIN RB 9 1.02

Ringer, Javon TEN RB 6 15.02

Thomas, Pierre NOS RB 11 10.11

Turner, Michael ATL RB 8 2.11

definitely my strongest position. no week 5 byes. i think Turner is underrated right now. Ringer looks better and better every day. Pierre in the 10th is a steal. Not really worried about Addai for the first 5 weeks. If Carter makes an impact, it will be later.

WR

Armstrong, Anthony WAS WR 5 23.02

Avant, Jason PHI WR 7 18.11

Branch, Deion NEP WR 7 13.02

Colston, Marques NOS WR 11 5.02

Jackson, DeSean PHI WR 7 3.02

Moore, Lance NOS WR 11 7.02

Ward, Hines PIT WR 11 9.02

Less than thrilling. hoping Desean comes out of the gates firing. could be a serviceable group though. Two Saints, two Eagles. Branch is criminally underrated right now. that was probably my best pick of this bunch. Colston was probably a reach given the state of his knee.

TE

Finley, Jermichael GBP TE 8 4.11

Moeaki, Tony KCC TE 6 14.11

Tamme, Jacob IND TE 11 22.11

Like this group a lot. Tamme has nice upside given Dallas Clark's injury history. Finley's just a stud.

PK

Carpenter, Dan MIA PK 5 24.11

Gostkowski, Stephen NEP PK 7 17.02

Prater, Matt DEN PK 6 20.11

strong

DT

Chiefs, Kansas City KCC Def 6 21.02

Eagles, Philadelphia PHI Def 7 12.11

meh

Overall: I like this team better this morning than i did last night. Little to no impact of the week 5 bye. Solid B-

 
Bradford, Sam STL QB - 5 10.03

Orton, Kyle DEN QB - 6 12.03

Tebow, Tim DEN QB - 6 14.03

Johnson, Chris TEN RB - 6 1.10

Jones-Drew, Maurice JAC RB (P) - 9 2.03

Bush, Reggie MIA RB - 5 8.03

Brown, Donald IND RB - 11 15.10

Murray, DeMarco DAL RB ® (P) - 5 19.10

Washington, Leon SEA RB - 6 24.03

Welker, Wes NEP WR - 7 3.10

Austin, Miles DAL WR (Q) - 5 4.03

Ochocinco, Chad NEP WR - 7 6.03

Garcon, Pierre IND WR - 11 7.10

Evans, Lee BAL WR - 5 11.10

Breaston, Steve KCC WR - 6 13.10

Decker, Eric DEN WR - 6 17.10

Brown, Antonio PIT WR - 11 23.10

Gibson, Brandon STL WR - 5 21.10

Clark, Dallas IND TE (P) - 11 5.10

Pettigrew, Brandon DET TE (Q) - 9 9.10

Henery, Alex PHI PK ® - 7 18.03

Gould, Robbie CHI PK - 8 20.03

Chargers, San Diego SDC Def - 6 16.03

Colts, Indianapolis IND Def - 11 22.03

Like it, don't love it. QB - Disappointed at what I came away with here. Missed a few targets along the way, so I addressed other positions instead of following the run. Waited until everyone had 1 or 2 QB's before taking Bradford, who was absolutely the last one left I valued at all. Not digging the week 5 bye though. If for some crazy reason one of Orton/Tebow ain't starting in Denver during week 5, I'm toast. RB - I'm screwed if Chris Johnson (holdout) or MJD (injury concerns) let me down. Neither have bye weeks, and very little backfield competition, so if they can just hang tight for 5 weeks I like my chances. I liked getting Reggie Bush where I did, he intrigues me. The rest are merely fliers. I could see a few surprise games out of Donald Brown, but my expectations are low. WR - Definitely the strength of my team. Good "starting" core of Austin, Welker, Ocho, good depth with a few decent best-ball picks (Garcon, Evans, Breaston) that should provide me with some good scores out of the position. Didn't plan on targetting both NE WR's, just sort of happened that way. No other WR presented me the same upside as Ocho where I took him, so i went with it. TE - Originally planned on targetting three TE's, but landing both Dallas Clark and Brandon Pettigrew, with neither having a bye week, made me content at 2. If Clark can just stay healthy for 5 weeks, that's all I ask. PK/TD - In the past I've settled for whatever was leftover at the end of the draft. This year I decided to step up and take them earlier, giving me better options with no bye-week issues, while hoping to scoop my RB/WR targets later anyway, which I did. Indy/SD's schedule mixes up pretty well (MIN, CLE, KC, MIA, KC/DEN) and I wanted 2 good kickers with no bye weeks.

Don't have that fuzzy feeling this year. Lots of risks...a few guys I barely missed that would've changed my entire draft. I've never felt great walking out of these things and have managed to fare quite well...we'll see if it's the same this year. Good group of drafters, good luck fellas.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
First of all, thanks to Clayton for running the draft and solving the various issues that arose during the draft. It was, despite being very lengthy, a fun draft with a good group. I feel for BusMan having his connection drop... I know he's a tough hombre in these competitions and was here due to past success.

Anyway, not sure what to think so far of this team... made one stupid and unintentional mistake when I looked at the wrong bye week at TE (see below) but other than that kinda shifted on the fly as best I could.



Schaub, Matt HOU 11 7.09

Manning, Eli NYG 7 8.04

Smith, Alex SFO 7 20.04

My original QB plan was to try to take a guy near the end of the first tier... changed strategy a bit on the fly for a few reasons and ended up taking a few guys from tier two. I do think getting a solid QB you can rely on is important, but at least they are only getting 4 points per TD. After passing on that top tier, I decided to take two back-to-back and did OK with Schaub and E. Manning. Neither has a bye, so hopefully one will be good enough each week. Towards the end of the draft I was going to take a guy like Hasselbeck, but missed on him in Round 18, so I took Alex Smith in Round 20. Not overly optimistic about him, but he does play a full five weeks (unless he is benched, which is always possible) and a few of them are decent matchups. Not the best QBs in the league, but probaby not the worst.



Jackson, Steven STL 5 3.09

Ingram, Mark NOS 11 4.04

Grant, Ryan GBP 8 5.09

Woodhead, Danny NEP 7 11.09

Barber, Marion CHI 8 16.04

Jackson wasn't a target, but I was hoping to take Best and he went the pick before. Unfortunately, with a Week 5 bye, I immediately knew I had to get a solid third option to cover that week, which meant picking RBs the next two rounds, too. Ingram was my next pick, and then I reached a bit for Grant because the non-Week 5 pool at RB was just about dry. GB at least starts off with a decent schedule, so hopefully Ingram/Grant can cover Week 5... and with Jackson's schedule not great, I will need them anyway. I missed an opportunity to insure Ingram with Thomas around the 10th, so I scrambled for Woodhead after. I'm not expecting much from Barber, but he's worth a shot as late as the 16th, especially with no bye week. I would have liked to have another RB, but due to my screw up below, I had to waste a roster spot... (see TE)

White, Roddy ATL 8 1.09

Jackson, Vincent SDC 6 2.04

Amendola, Danny STL WR 5 9.09

Williams, Mike SEA WR 6 10.04

Nelson, Jordy GBP WR 8 12.04

Washington, Nate TEN WR 6 13.09

Hill, Jason JAC WR 9 15.09

Went WR/WR right out of the chute and then crapped the bed a little a the position. Amendola should at least catch a ton of passes, and I know he has a Week 5 bye, but by Round 9 you have to start taking some of these guys, and I don't have any other byes that week here. Regretted taking BMW over M. Floyd in Round 10. Nelson and Washington are, hopefully, best-ball type guys that produce a few big games a year. Finally, Jason Hill is at least starting and should do something each week... hoping Gabbert doesn't start Week 1. I like my first two WRs, but could have used a better #3 and eight in total.

Witten, Jason DAL 5 6.04

Davis, Fred WAS 5 14.04

Heap, Todd ARI 6 18.04

OK, so here's where I screwed up... I'm OK with the Witten pick despite the bye week. There was just nothing else that was screaming at me on the board when I took him. I thought about backing him up earlier many times, but there was always something else I seemed to need that round. So then, it is getting desperate, and I look down see F. Davis is on a bye Week 6, and take him, as I'm not confident in Cooley's knee. Then I realize a round or two later the source I looked had a typo and Davis was off Week 5 as well, not Week 6! Not a huge deal, but now it meant I had to burn another pick on a TE just to get one playing Week 5, and there was pretty much nothing left. So I reluctantly took Heap, when I much rather would have took another flyer on a RB or WR. Oh well. I have three TEs now. Maybe it'll somehow turn out to benefit me... but I doubt it.

Feely, Jay ARI 6 21.09

Akers, David SFO 7 22.04

Succop, Ryan KCC 6 24.04

Three uninspiring kickers, but at least all three should kick for five weeks. Not exactly stellar offenses here, though.

49ers, San Francisco Def 7 17.09

Raiders, Oakland Def 8 19.09

Texans, Houston Def 11 23.09

Make no mistake, these are three pretty bad defenses. Will three bad options a week yield one good score? We'll see.

Overall:

Not overly excited about my team, and not overly down on it at the same time. To me it seems very.... average. And to advance in this format, you have to have playmakers capable of exploding to give you those nice best ball scores each week. Not sure if this team has it. I don't think I'll finish at the bottom, but I'll need a few breaks to finish at the top.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Aaron Rodgers 1.08

Matt Flynn 24.05

Knew I'd be put to this decision at 1.08. Nearly took Hakeem Nicks instead, but decided I liked Rodgers nearly as much and didn't want to feel obligated to reach for a top tier quarterback in rounds 2-3 if they went quickly. As it turns out, I could've gotten Brady at good value in the third or Brees/Manning in the fourth. I had planned on taking Mark Sanchez at QB2, but frae sniped me in the 11th. After that, I decided I'd rather have another WR option rostered than a guy like McNabb, Garrard, etc.

Jahvid Best 3.08

LeGarrette Blount 4.05

Mike Tolbert 7.08

CJ Spiller 9.08

Darren Sproles 12.05

Thomas Jones 17.08

Pretty happy with this group, though I want the Tolbert v AJ Green decision in the 7th back now. Good mix of options, with no bye week conflicts, that should give me two average or better scores every week.

Greg Jennings 2.05

Dez Bryant 5.08

Robert Meachem 8.05

James Jones 11.08

Devin Hester 13.08

Jordan Shipley 15.08

Emmanuel Sanders 18.05

Early Doucet 20.05

Josh Cribbs 21.08

My strategy in best ball lineups is to get two top fifteen receivers, then improve depth at RB and TE. There are lots and lots and lots of single game upside receivers. Get two anchors (hopefully) and a good mix of guys behind should bring you at least one (and usually two) nice scores every week. The WR3BC approach almost always does as well or better than those who stick to fewer, more highly ranked options. I would've liked to have Green as a more stable "WR3" since I'll be without Bryant in Week 5, and should've known better than to let him slide that one more round.

Owen Daniels 6.05

Aaron Hernandez 10.05

I think Daniels is a top five TE this year and players capable of monster weeks like Hernandez are gold in this format as depth.

Adam Vinatieri 19.08

Mike Nugent 23.08

Meh. Was still taking WRs when the first group of kickers went off the board.

New York Giants 14.05

New Orleans Saints 16.05

Cincinnati Bengals 22.05

Very much like the NYG/NOS combination. Good mix of schedules, aggressive defenses. I like a 3rd DST in this format and the Bengals were the best complementary option at the time.

This group should have a chance to advance, but it's a risky group (single QB, committee approach at WR). One 2-9 week is very hard to overcome. We'll see. Should be fun to watch.

 
I have no week 5 byes, so I won't list any bye weeks.

Rivers / McNabb

I took Rivers too early, but I was already thinking about being near a turn and watching positions evaporate. I really like Rivers this season, particularly for the first five games when Gates should be healthy to go with VJ, Floyd, Mathews, and the very good supporting WRs. McNabb should be good for the first five weeks, and I felt strong enough to go with just two here when it got late in the draft, going with a 4th TE instead of a 3rd QB.

Charles / Wells / Benson / McGahee / Hunter / Gerhart

Charles is great in PPR, Wells's value hasn't caught up with his situation, and Benson pretty much sucks given how bad that team is going to be, but he'll play the first five games. McGahee's there for TD vultures, and Hunter/Gerhart are just in case Gore or Peterson gets hurt. I think I'm good here with those top three, but I could have used another decent platoon guy when I was chasing TEs and taking PK/D too early in the teen rounds.

Holmes / Collie / MThomas / RWilliams / Burleson / Driver / Heyward-Bey

I like Driver and DHB in this format - both will have a big game here and there. Collie's one of the guys I moved up my list based on the 5-week format (like Gates and RBush). Thomas couldn't be more boring, but I think Garrard's better than people give him credit for and will do fine for Thomas. Roy Williams was very good to me last season both in this competition and in the $30k contest - he's a punchline, but he's better than people think. He's back with Martz with Cutler at QB. I reached for both Williams and Burleson, but I'm fine with that - I think they're still bargains in these rounds given where they should be taken. I'm a little light here with only 7 WRs, but that's fine with me.

Cook / HMiller / Shiancoe / Beckum

I missed out on a lot of TE targets and kept feeling that the value wasn't there, but it went on too long. Since these guys are weak, I took four of them. Hopefully they'll spread out some TDs over 5 weeks.

Novak / Barth

I used Herman's rankings to target Novak.

Tennessee / Arizona / Jacksonville

Three crappy teams, but all play other crappy teams pretty often in the first five games. Between the three of them, I get games against: Carolina, Washington, Seattle, Jacksonville, Denver, Cleveland, Tennessee, Carolina, and Cincinnati. I could see some defenses totally dominating these offenses early with their new QBs, new coaches, or generaly feebleness. Maybe not Cleveland and Jacksonville, but I'm happy here.

Overall, I like this team. I think the four TEs shore up the weakest part of my team. I know that I won't score highly on value calculations vs. ADP, but I hit some guys I targeted as undervalued - if I value them 4 rounds ahead of their ADP and take them 2 rounds ahead of their ADP, I don't mind.

I like Jene's team a LOT.

 
Crazy schedule lately and not much time to prep…and it showed. Went in with a flexible strategy, but planned to stay away from week 5 players (at least until I locked down my starters)...but couldn’t pull it off. Got off to a decent start, but my round 3 Brady pick spun me in a direction that I never quite recovered from. LionsFan and Frosty also sniped me a few times when I had a guy queued up. Brady, Tom NEP QB 7 3.11Cutler, Jay CHI QB 8 10.02After taking Brady early I immediately decided to roll with 2 QBs. Almost took Ryan with my 7.11 pick, but decided to grab another WR. No bye week issues and NE seems to be firing on all cylinders. Mendenhall, Rashard PIT RB 11 1.11McFadden, Darren OAK RB 8 2.02Bush, Michael OAK RB 8 11.11Helu, Roy WAS RB 5 15.11Snelling, Jason ATL RB 8 16.02Rodgers, Jacquizz ATL RB 8 17.11Ridley, Stevan NEP RB 7 18.02Goodson, Mike CAR RB 9 19.11Like Mendy and McFadden as starters and snagged Bush if McFadden’s orbital bone issue lingers, but ended up neglecting depth here as I scrambled to get WRs and TEs. Decided to wait on RB (after getting sniped a few times) and load up on upside guys if a starter goes down. Not a big Helu believer, but who knows what Shanny will do. No room for error here and need Mendy and McFadden/Bush to perform to have any shot. Marshall, Brandon MIA WR 5 5.11Manningham, Mario NYG WR 7 4.02Moss, Santana WAS WR 5 7.11Green, A.J. CIN WR 7 8.02Knox, Johnny CHI WR 8 12.02Mason, Derrick NYJ WR 8 13.11Bess, Davone MIA WR 5 14.02Williams, Damian TEN WR 6 21.11Very weak here since 3 WRs start each week and I have three players with week 5 byes. Got some WRs that are great for PPR scoring (and could be sneaky), but the lack of firepower here will likely haunt me. Davis, Vernon SFO TE 7 6.02Lewis, Marcedes JAC TE 9 9.11Happy with my TEs and similar to my QBs, decided to go with two after locking down a couple top 10 guys. Lewis could even be a flex play foe me if needed. No bye week issues. Bironas, Rob TEN PK 6 20.02Longwell, Ryan MIN PK 9 23.11Waited here and got below average kickers. No bye week issues, but that is rally the only positive thing to say. Seahawks, Seattle SEA D 6 22.02Redskins, Washington WAS D 5 24.02Like my kickers, waited until the end and got below average results…and got stuck with a week 5 bye after all the non-bye week teams were snapped up.Overall probably a middle of the road team that will need some big breaks and misfortune of others to move on. Look forward to the other writeups, always interesting for the 12 of us and the other leagues drafting over the next few days.
I liked your strategy at QB, you should have a good score there most weeks. By not looking at RBs from rd 3-11 you really hurt your depth. DMac and Mendy will be your scores every week assuming they are healthy but I don't see you pulling a flex from here. With your 1 and 3 WR out week 5 along with Bess you will have trouble putting up a full lineup. You will need a good cushion going into week 5. I like Marshall and Manningham, but Moss and Green are going to be hit and miss. Bess should be a WR3 a lot of weeks though. Love the TEs in this format and agree they will be a flex for you. Kickers are fine but again you will be in trouble week 5 at DEF plus I don't like either much. I think you need some of your RB picks to do well to be able to move on. Not a bottom team but I worry about week 5 and if you have enough firepower to have a big lead going into it.
 
Well at 7 I hoped one of the non week 5 RB's would get to me. I could have taken CJ or Rice with his bye. I took Rice and then started avoiding week 5 guys. Anyway, here is how it finished up...QBMike VickMark SanchezVince YoungWell in a 5 week league I decided that Vick's long term health wasn't as much as a concern and took him in rd 2. Young however is insurance in case.RBRay RiceFred JacksonJonathan StewartDaniel ThomasShane VereenRashaad JenningsIsaac RedmanI think Rice will be great for 4 weeks, hopefully one of Jackson Stewart or Thomas can have a good week to match Ray.WRMike WilliamsBrandon LloydKenny BrittMike Sims WalkerJacoby JonesThis is a small group but since I took 3 WR's early I decided to fill the other areas and hope that Tampa Mike, Lloyd, and Britt will be solid enough. Sims-Walker could have a couple good weeks too.TEKellen WinslowDustin KellerKevin BossI waited on TE and decided to get 3 and hope that each week one of them shows up.DEFDetroit LionsTampa Bay BucsMiami DolphinsI like Detroit this year, but again wanted some options.KNate KaedingBilly CundiffShaun SuishamKickers are fickle and getting points from them is tough to predict so again going with 3 and hoping to catch one with a good week each time.If Vick is healthy and I can get RB production from Jackson, Stewart, or Thomas I could be ok. It was fun and interesting.
I think the main downfall is the depth at WR. It is only a 5 week season and if you don't think Vick can stay healthy you shouldn't have taken him. The pick of Young should have been a WR. Love the RBs you put together, but again I think one of them should have become a WR. If Britt gets suspended, you are down to MSW and Jones to put up a WR3 score. I was hoping Keller would make it to me, I like the TE combo a lot and wouldn't be surprised if you pull a flex score or two from them. Overall it is a high risk high reward team. If Britt doesn't get suspended and you can get 3 decent WR scores a week you have a shot to advance. Too much risk for me though.
 
I feel like a survivor for finishing the draft awake... . :eek:
I dozed off several times. Noticed I took two defenses with week 5 byes. Meant to fix that by taking a third D, but apparently I took a fourth QB instead? :doh:My team is probably terrible. It looks ok to me, but I'm not well informed these days. I know my WRs and QB were awesome back in my day. Draft prep happened during the draft. Meant to stop by the Hawks Nest first but ran out of time. :sadbanana:QBP ManningC McCoyT JacksonC HenneRBA FosterF JonesB Green-EllisJ HarrisonB TateR WilliamsWRM WallaceR WayneA BoldinP BurressS SmithJ SimpsonJ MorganD HixonTEZ MillerB WatsonKM BryantJ BrownDRavensCowboys:shrug:
If Peyton starts week 1 you might be ok. Don't think you needed 4 QBs though. RBs/WRs look pretty good, I like the depth at WR. Not a BJGE fan this season though. I would have grabbed a TE earlier, I think you will be behind at TE each week with Miller/Watson. If Peyton plays your RBs and WRs could carry you.
 
I think the main downfall is the depth at WR. It is only a 5 week season and if you don't think Vick can stay healthy you shouldn't have taken him. The pick of Young should have been a WR. Love the RBs you put together, but again I think one of them should have become a WR. If Britt gets suspended, you are down to MSW and Jones to put up a WR3 score. I was hoping Keller would make it to me, I like the TE combo a lot and wouldn't be surprised if you pull a flex score or two from them. Overall it is a high risk high reward team. If Britt doesn't get suspended and you can get 3 decent WR scores a week you have a shot to advance. Too much risk for me though.
I agree that WR is too thin. This is the first time I have done best ball and the only time I have ever had locked roster moves. I didn't take Young until rd 21 or 22 so there wasn't a lot left at WR there. Maybe I should have only gone with 2 TE's. There is certainly some risk with being so short at WR and having to start 3, but I am banking on the first 3 I took to be worth it. Thanks for the thoughts.
 
QB

Cassel, Matt KCC QB 6 8.11

Fitzpatrick, Ryan BUF QB 7 11.02

Garrard, David JAC QB 9 19.02

if i didn't get one of the big 5, plan was to wait pretty long. certainly nothing spectacular, but i'm ok with this trio for the first 5 weeks. I'm a big Fitspatrick fan. Garrard should be safe for the first 5 weeks even if he ####s the bed.

RB

Addai, Joseph IND RB 11 6.11

Brown, Ronnie PHI RB 7 16.11

Peterson, Adrian MIN RB 9 1.02

Ringer, Javon TEN RB 6 15.02

Thomas, Pierre NOS RB 11 10.11

Turner, Michael ATL RB 8 2.11

definitely my strongest position. no week 5 byes. i think Turner is underrated right now. Ringer looks better and better every day. Pierre in the 10th is a steal. Not really worried about Addai for the first 5 weeks. If Carter makes an impact, it will be later.

WR

Armstrong, Anthony WAS WR 5 23.02

Avant, Jason PHI WR 7 18.11

Branch, Deion NEP WR 7 13.02

Colston, Marques NOS WR 11 5.02

Jackson, DeSean PHI WR 7 3.02

Moore, Lance NOS WR 11 7.02

Ward, Hines PIT WR 11 9.02

Less than thrilling. hoping Desean comes out of the gates firing. could be a serviceable group though. Two Saints, two Eagles. Branch is criminally underrated right now. that was probably my best pick of this bunch. Colston was probably a reach given the state of his knee.

TE

Finley, Jermichael GBP TE 8 4.11

Moeaki, Tony KCC TE 6 14.11

Tamme, Jacob IND TE 11 22.11

Like this group a lot. Tamme has nice upside given Dallas Clark's injury history. Finley's just a stud.

PK

Carpenter, Dan MIA PK 5 24.11

Gostkowski, Stephen NEP PK 7 17.02

Prater, Matt DEN PK 6 20.11

strong

DT

Chiefs, Kansas City KCC Def 6 21.02

Eagles, Philadelphia PHI Def 7 12.11

meh

Overall: I like this team better this morning than i did last night. Little to no impact of the week 5 bye. Solid B-
Mostly agree with your assessment. I like the committee approach at QB for these type of drafts in general, but I like to have one that is capable of a 300/3 week or two, and yours probably aren't. If you had Stafford, Cutler, or Flacco in place of Cassel I would like it a lot better. Fitz and Garrard are good for the rest of the committee. Very strong at RB, your flex will come from there most of the time. I'm more pessimistic on your WRs, mostly because of the double Saints/Eagles. If one of those teams has a poor week you will be in trouble at WR, and I don't think you have the depth to cover it. Like your TEs, Ks, and DEFs. Overall middle of the pack with some upside if your WRs are consistent and a QB steps up.

 
Mostly agree with your assessment. I like the committee approach at QB for these type of drafts in general, but I like to have one that is capable of a 300/3 week or two, and yours probably aren't..
I think Fitzpatrick has that capability, he had two 300/4 games last year
 
'joffer said:
Mostly agree with your assessment. I like the committee approach at QB for these type of drafts in general, but I like to have one that is capable of a 300/3 week or two, and yours probably aren't..
I think Fitzpatrick has that capability, he had two 300/4 games last year
True, I think the loss of Evans will hurt more than people think and I am just down on the Bills in general.
 
Bradford, Sam STL QB - 5 10.03Orton, Kyle DEN QB - 6 12.03Tebow, Tim DEN QB - 6 14.03Johnson, Chris TEN RB - 6 1.10Jones-Drew, Maurice JAC RB (P) - 9 2.03Bush, Reggie MIA RB - 5 8.03Brown, Donald IND RB - 11 15.10Murray, DeMarco DAL RB ® (P) - 5 19.10Washington, Leon SEA RB - 6 24.03Welker, Wes NEP WR - 7 3.10Austin, Miles DAL WR (Q) - 5 4.03Ochocinco, Chad NEP WR - 7 6.03Garcon, Pierre IND WR - 11 7.10Evans, Lee BAL WR - 5 11.10Breaston, Steve KCC WR - 6 13.10Decker, Eric DEN WR - 6 17.10Brown, Antonio PIT WR - 11 23.10Gibson, Brandon STL WR - 5 21.10Clark, Dallas IND TE (P) - 11 5.10Pettigrew, Brandon DET TE (Q) - 9 9.10Henery, Alex PHI PK ® - 7 18.03Gould, Robbie CHI PK - 8 20.03Chargers, San Diego SDC Def - 6 16.03Colts, Indianapolis IND Def - 11 22.03
You have some upside at QB, don't like that you burned a 14th on Tebow, there were still solid players on the board at that point. If you believe in Orton you have to think he makes it through 5 weeks. I am one who thinks CJ2k will be on the field week 1 so you got huge value there. MJD may be back to his normal self, but I think you should have taken a WR there and waited on RB until the 3rd. Bush is surging up boards, I would like him better if it was a full PPR for RBs. I don't know if the other 3 will score for you at all, I like Murray the best of those. I think you should have taken a 4th RB before the 15th. Love the direction you went with WRs, solid PPR guys in Welker and Austin followed by best ball picks in Evans, Brown, and Gibson. You will probably be getting your flex from this group and I love the depth you have. As long as Clark stays healthy you will be fine but you could have waited longer on a TE2 and got a better RB in that round. 2Ks and 2 DEFs with no byes is fine. Overall, I think a top 6 team pushing for the top 4. RB depth worries me if one of the top 2 have a bad week, and your QBs are good but not great. Your WRs will need to carry you some weeks.
 
First of all, thanks to Clayton for running the draft and solving the various issues that arose during the draft. It was, despite being very lengthy, a fun draft with a good group. I feel for BusMan having his connection drop... I know he's a tough hombre in these competitions and was here due to past success.

Anyway, not sure what to think so far of this team... made one stupid and unintentional mistake when I looked at the wrong bye week at TE (see below) but other than that kinda shifted on the fly as best I could.



Schaub, Matt HOU 11 7.09

Manning, Eli NYG 7 8.04

Smith, Alex SFO 7 20.04

My original QB plan was to try to take a guy near the end of the first tier... changed strategy a bit on the fly for a few reasons and ended up taking a few guys from tier two. I do think getting a solid QB you can rely on is important, but at least they are only getting 4 points per TD. After passing on that top tier, I decided to take two back-to-back and did OK with Schaub and E. Manning. Neither has a bye, so hopefully one will be good enough each week. Towards the end of the draft I was going to take a guy like Hasselbeck, but missed on him in Round 18, so I took Alex Smith in Round 20. Not overly optimistic about him, but he does play a full five weeks (unless he is benched, which is always possible) and a few of them are decent matchups. Not the best QBs in the league, but probaby not the worst.



Jackson, Steven STL 5 3.09

Ingram, Mark NOS 11 4.04

Grant, Ryan GBP 8 5.09

Woodhead, Danny NEP 7 11.09

Barber, Marion CHI 8 16.04

Jackson wasn't a target, but I was hoping to take Best and he went the pick before. Unfortunately, with a Week 5 bye, I immediately knew I had to get a solid third option to cover that week, which meant picking RBs the next two rounds, too. Ingram was my next pick, and then I reached a bit for Grant because the non-Week 5 pool at RB was just about dry. GB at least starts off with a decent schedule, so hopefully Ingram/Grant can cover Week 5... and with Jackson's schedule not great, I will need them anyway. I missed an opportunity to insure Ingram with Thomas around the 10th, so I scrambled for Woodhead after. I'm not expecting much from Barber, but he's worth a shot as late as the 16th, especially with no bye week. I would have liked to have another RB, but due to my screw up below, I had to waste a roster spot... (see TE)

White, Roddy ATL 8 1.09

Jackson, Vincent SDC 6 2.04

Amendola, Danny STL WR 5 9.09

Williams, Mike SEA WR 6 10.04

Nelson, Jordy GBP WR 8 12.04

Washington, Nate TEN WR 6 13.09

Hill, Jason JAC WR 9 15.09

Went WR/WR right out of the chute and then crapped the bed a little a the position. Amendola should at least catch a ton of passes, and I know he has a Week 5 bye, but by Round 9 you have to start taking some of these guys, and I don't have any other byes that week here. Regretted taking BMW over M. Floyd in Round 10. Nelson and Washington are, hopefully, best-ball type guys that produce a few big games a year. Finally, Jason Hill is at least starting and should do something each week... hoping Gabbert doesn't start Week 1. I like my first two WRs, but could have used a better #3 and eight in total.

Witten, Jason DAL 5 6.04

Davis, Fred WAS 5 14.04

Heap, Todd ARI 6 18.04

OK, so here's where I screwed up... I'm OK with the Witten pick despite the bye week. There was just nothing else that was screaming at me on the board when I took him. I thought about backing him up earlier many times, but there was always something else I seemed to need that round. So then, it is getting desperate, and I look down see F. Davis is on a bye Week 6, and take him, as I'm not confident in Cooley's knee. Then I realize a round or two later the source I looked had a typo and Davis was off Week 5 as well, not Week 6! Not a huge deal, but now it meant I had to burn another pick on a TE just to get one playing Week 5, and there was pretty much nothing left. So I reluctantly took Heap, when I much rather would have took another flyer on a RB or WR. Oh well. I have three TEs now. Maybe it'll somehow turn out to benefit me... but I doubt it.

Feely, Jay ARI 6 21.09

Akers, David SFO 7 22.04

Succop, Ryan KCC 6 24.04

Three uninspiring kickers, but at least all three should kick for five weeks. Not exactly stellar offenses here, though.

49ers, San Francisco Def 7 17.09

Raiders, Oakland Def 8 19.09

Texans, Houston Def 11 23.09

Make no mistake, these are three pretty bad defenses. Will three bad options a week yield one good score? We'll see.

Overall:

Not overly excited about my team, and not overly down on it at the same time. To me it seems very.... average. And to advance in this format, you have to have playmakers capable of exploding to give you those nice best ball scores each week. Not sure if this team has it. I don't think I'll finish at the bottom, but I'll need a few breaks to finish at the top.
I probably like your QBs more than most. Schaub has top 3 weekly potential, and you know what you are getting with Eli. Smith was a wasted pick. I would be shocked if he scored for you. Starting WR/WR hurt you I think. SJax and Ingram are fine, but I am not big on Grant this year. Week 5 is going to be tough. Similar to R.Bush, I like Woodhead in a full PPR much better. Barber is a good pick and might surprise, hope he gets his 2 TD game in week 5. Can't argue with your top 2 WRs, and Amendola will hold down the fort in PPR. Worried about depth and where your flex play will come from. Hill and Washington are good in best ball so I like those picks late. TE is great the first 4 weeks but again week 5 is an issue. Ks and DEFs are probably in the bottom half of the league. I think this team holds its own the first four weeks but losing SJax, Amendola, and the two TEs in week 5 makes me feel like it will be tough to advance. As Jene said, one 2-9 week is tough to overcome.
 
Aaron Rodgers 1.08Matt Flynn 24.05Knew I'd be put to this decision at 1.08. Nearly took Hakeem Nicks instead, but decided I liked Rodgers nearly as much and didn't want to feel obligated to reach for a top tier quarterback in rounds 2-3 if they went quickly. As it turns out, I could've gotten Brady at good value in the third or Brees/Manning in the fourth. I had planned on taking Mark Sanchez at QB2, but frae sniped me in the 11th. After that, I decided I'd rather have another WR option rostered than a guy like McNabb, Garrard, etc.Jahvid Best 3.08LeGarrette Blount 4.05Mike Tolbert 7.08CJ Spiller 9.08Darren Sproles 12.05Thomas Jones 17.08Pretty happy with this group, though I want the Tolbert v AJ Green decision in the 7th back now. Good mix of options, with no bye week conflicts, that should give me two average or better scores every week.Greg Jennings 2.05Dez Bryant 5.08Robert Meachem 8.05James Jones 11.08Devin Hester 13.08Jordan Shipley 15.08Emmanuel Sanders 18.05Early Doucet 20.05Josh Cribbs 21.08My strategy in best ball lineups is to get two top fifteen receivers, then improve depth at RB and TE. There are lots and lots and lots of single game upside receivers. Get two anchors (hopefully) and a good mix of guys behind should bring you at least one (and usually two) nice scores every week. The WR3BC approach almost always does as well or better than those who stick to fewer, more highly ranked options. I would've liked to have Green as a more stable "WR3" since I'll be without Bryant in Week 5, and should've known better than to let him slide that one more round.Owen Daniels 6.05Aaron Hernandez 10.05I think Daniels is a top five TE this year and players capable of monster weeks like Hernandez are gold in this format as depth. Adam Vinatieri 19.08Mike Nugent 23.08Meh. Was still taking WRs when the first group of kickers went off the board.New York Giants 14.05New Orleans Saints 16.05Cincinnati Bengals 22.05Very much like the NYG/NOS combination. Good mix of schedules, aggressive defenses. I like a 3rd DST in this format and the Bengals were the best complementary option at the time.This group should have a chance to advance, but it's a risky group (single QB, committee approach at WR). One 2-9 week is very hard to overcome. We'll see. Should be fun to watch.
Jene, I have to say that while you were drafting this team I hated it. Looking at the whole team, it looks a lot better than I thought it would, although not my style. Even Rodgers is not immune to having one bad week out of 5. I think you needed a McNabb or Garrard here as a hedge. You're RBs really came together and worked out well based on where you picked them. All of you're 3-6 RBs should get touches every week and should be enough to protect you if Best or Blount has a bad week. Not bad on the WRs, although some players I am not high on. I like the WR3BC approach with Meachem, Jones, Hester and Shipley. Really not a fun of Doucet or Cribbs. With Dez off week 5 you will need two scores from your backups which might be tough. Overall, I knew this was your strategy but you might be hurting for WE scores some weeks. Love the TE combo in this format. Ks and DEFs are fine. It is a very high risk high reward team which I see either at the top or bottom after 5 weeks mostly based on how well the Rodgers/Jennings combo works out.
 
I have no week 5 byes, so I won't list any bye weeks.Rivers / McNabbI took Rivers too early, but I was already thinking about being near a turn and watching positions evaporate. I really like Rivers this season, particularly for the first five games when Gates should be healthy to go with VJ, Floyd, Mathews, and the very good supporting WRs. McNabb should be good for the first five weeks, and I felt strong enough to go with just two here when it got late in the draft, going with a 4th TE instead of a 3rd QB.Charles / Wells / Benson / McGahee / Hunter / GerhartCharles is great in PPR, Wells's value hasn't caught up with his situation, and Benson pretty much sucks given how bad that team is going to be, but he'll play the first five games. McGahee's there for TD vultures, and Hunter/Gerhart are just in case Gore or Peterson gets hurt. I think I'm good here with those top three, but I could have used another decent platoon guy when I was chasing TEs and taking PK/D too early in the teen rounds.Holmes / Collie / MThomas / RWilliams / Burleson / Driver / Heyward-BeyI like Driver and DHB in this format - both will have a big game here and there. Collie's one of the guys I moved up my list based on the 5-week format (like Gates and RBush). Thomas couldn't be more boring, but I think Garrard's better than people give him credit for and will do fine for Thomas. Roy Williams was very good to me last season both in this competition and in the $30k contest - he's a punchline, but he's better than people think. He's back with Martz with Cutler at QB. I reached for both Williams and Burleson, but I'm fine with that - I think they're still bargains in these rounds given where they should be taken. I'm a little light here with only 7 WRs, but that's fine with me.Cook / HMiller / Shiancoe / BeckumI missed out on a lot of TE targets and kept feeling that the value wasn't there, but it went on too long. Since these guys are weak, I took four of them. Hopefully they'll spread out some TDs over 5 weeks.Novak / BarthI used Herman's rankings to target Novak.Tennessee / Arizona / JacksonvilleThree crappy teams, but all play other crappy teams pretty often in the first five games. Between the three of them, I get games against: Carolina, Washington, Seattle, Jacksonville, Denver, Cleveland, Tennessee, Carolina, and Cincinnati. I could see some defenses totally dominating these offenses early with their new QBs, new coaches, or generaly feebleness. Maybe not Cleveland and Jacksonville, but I'm happy here.Overall, I like this team. I think the four TEs shore up the weakest part of my team. I know that I won't score highly on value calculations vs. ADP, but I hit some guys I targeted as undervalued - if I value them 4 rounds ahead of their ADP and take them 2 rounds ahead of their ADP, I don't mind.I like Jene's team a LOT.
First, it is nice not having to worry about week 5 byes. Was that part of the plan and did you often skip higher ranked players with a week 5 bye? Rivers will be fine as usual, but I think you reached a little on McNabb. I am not a Benson fan but he will get carries, but the rest of the RBs are solid. McGahee will get at least a few scores in the first 5 weeks and that might be enough for a flex play. I like Holmes and especially with the 5 week season, but you might be hurting for points at WR3, and ROY might end up being a wasted pick as your WR4. Driver and DHB might have a good week or two, but when Thomas puts up a few 4/50 weeks in the Jags offense, I think you will be wishing you grabbed one more solid starter instead of ROY. AT first I didn't like the 4 mid level TE approach but it might work. TEs don't get bonuses in this league and you just need someone who will get catches. All 4 should get looks each game and just need to hope for some TDs to follow. Don't like the DEF choices but whatever. Rivers/Charles will be enough to keep you in it some weeks but I don't know if there is enough upside at WR/TE to make it top 4. I see a 5-7th finish for this team.
 
Gamma1210

Brees, Drew NOS 11 4.08

Flacco, Joe BAL 5 11.05

Brees dropping was great, so you're good here. Flacco's a good backup with some long Lee Evans TDs. I think you did well with both these picks.

Gore, Frank SFO RB 7 2.08

Hardesty, Montario CLE RB 5 18.08

Hillis, Peyton CLE RB 5 5.05

Jacobs, Brandon NYG RB 7 9.05

Lynch, Marshawn SEA RB 6 6.08

Stephens-Howling, LaRod ARI RB 6 21.05

This crew is very light on PPR points, which can hurt. Gore was a good pick that late (I was hoping he'd fall to me). I don't like the Hardesty pick, but it's the 18th round, so that's fine. Hillis is a tough one for me to sort out this year, but if he's anything like last year, that was a big value. Lynch... it's hard to say. On the bright side, the Oakland crew should improve the run blocking a lot. On the dark side, they have no QB. I can't see why people wouldn't stack the line against them. All the teams with new QBs are likely to struggle early IMO. So, I don't love Lynch. Jacobs could be good since you don't have to predict his good games.

Berrian, Bernard MIN WR 9 24.08

Bowe, Dwayne KCC WR 6 3.05

Floyd, Malcom SDC WR 6 10.08

Johnson, Andre HOU WR 11 1.05

Little, Greg CLE WR 5 14.08

Maclin, Jeremy PHI WR 7 7.05

Murphy, Louis OAK WR 8 22.08

Royal, Eddie DEN WR 6 15.05

AJ and Bowe are great, though Bowe drops a bit in PPR. I'm not sure what else you have here, though. Maclin if he's healthy is a great value there and makes your top 3 solid, but if he's not healthy, I don't like this crew much. Floyd should get a couple of TDs, but I don't see Little doing much early on, and Murphy and Berrian aren't that likely to see the field much. Royal's hard to figure out, and I tend to think he was a decent value where you got him, but I think you needed something more here.

Celek, Brent PHI TE 7 13.05

Graham, Jimmy NOS TE 11 8.08

Kendricks, Lance STL TE 5 16.08

I hate that you got Kendricks when I needed him. I'm not a big fan of this group, though. Graham seems vastly overrated in redrafts to me this season - it seems like NO always has the next big thing at TE, and it never works out that way.

Hanson, Jason DET PK 9 19.05

Hartley, Garrett NOS PK 11 17.05

Smart picks here. Good offenses with continuity from last season.

Bills, Buffalo BUF Def 7 23.05

Panthers, Carolina CAR Def 9 20.08

Steelers, Pittsburgh PIT Def 11 12.08

I think you've got the Steelers here and nothing else, but I like 3 defenses in this format - I once won this thing because of a very mediocre Seahawks defense going absolutely bonkers one week - they were my third defense that year.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
First, it is nice not having to worry about week 5 byes. Was that part of the plan and did you often skip higher ranked players with a week 5 bye?
I used the weekly weights in the Draft Dominator, and set all weeks beyond 5 to 0. It dropped all the week 5 bye guys down by roughly 20% of their relative VFD. I then manually adjusted them back up a bit by tweaking their projections because I felt that in a best-ball format, missing a guy for a game isn't as big of a blow as it is in a standard league. However, since nobody else seemed to deduct as much as the DD did, the guys were gone by the time I would have picked them.
 
First, it is nice not having to worry about week 5 byes. Was that part of the plan and did you often skip higher ranked players with a week 5 bye?
I used the weekly weights in the Draft Dominator, and set all weeks beyond 5 to 0. It dropped all the week 5 bye guys down by roughly 20% of their relative VFD. I then manually adjusted them back up a bit by tweaking their projections because I felt that in a best-ball format, missing a guy for a game isn't as big of a blow as it is in a standard league. However, since nobody else seemed to deduct as much as the DD did, the guys were gone by the time I would have picked them.
Yup.Gamma, I think your team is strong. Better than average depth throughout and a good mix of top tier talent on top. Avoid a string of injuries and I think you've got an excellent chance to advance.
 
First, it is nice not having to worry about week 5 byes. Was that part of the plan and did you often skip higher ranked players with a week 5 bye?
I used the weekly weights in the Draft Dominator, and set all weeks beyond 5 to 0. It dropped all the week 5 bye guys down by roughly 20% of their relative VFD. I then manually adjusted them back up a bit by tweaking their projections because I felt that in a best-ball format, missing a guy for a game isn't as big of a blow as it is in a standard league. However, since nobody else seemed to deduct as much as the DD did, the guys were gone by the time I would have picked them.
I followed a similar plan. Considered taking guys with a week 5 bye a couple times, but ultimately stayed away from it as well. Was less thrilled about drawing #6 overall... but I think I did OK given the feeling of always getting my #2 guy. QBSJason CampbellMatthew StaffordJosh FreemanI like to draft 3 QBS in a survivor league and always try to land 2 fairly high. I was happy with this crew - Freeman and Stafford have some big game potential and Campbell is a sleeper pick given that I landed him in the 15th round. He could toss a couple TDS one week and give me a couple extra points. DeAngelo WilliamsAhmad BradshawJustin ForsettBernard ScottJames StarksBilal PowellLess thrilled about the RB corps, which is definitely a weak spot for me. Ahmad Bradshaw is solid in a PPR league, and DWilliams should post solid numbers as well. Forsett is undervalued this year, and the PPR bonus, even if it's only .5, gives him a little boost. The other three guys are swing for the fence type of picks. Don't expect them to be in the starting lineup. If this team fails, it will be because I neglected the RB position. Kevin WalterCalvin JohnsonEarl BennettHarry DouglasSteve JohnsonDexter McClusterAndre RobertsDenarius MooreVERY happy to land Megatron, although at #6 overall, I guess that's who I expected to get so it wasn't a value pick. I'm hoping he and Stafford hook up right out of the gate and carry my team for the first couple of weeks. Steve Johnson was a pretty average pick at that point in the draft, and the WRs moved off the board at a pretty good clip after that. I like Roberts this season, and think he has some breakout potential. Moore is a rook but in the 9th, it wasn't a bad choice. The rest of these picks were more boom or bust type of guys with McCluser being the wild card with the recent announcement that he will get a few carries each game. Greg OlsenRob GronkowskiI was tempted to take 3 TEs, but was happy to land both Olsen and Gronk where I did - I think both are undervalued a bit this season, especially Olsen. Neil RackersJosh ScobeeNew England PatriotsDenver BroncosAtlanta FalconsThis isn't a heavy defensive scoring league, but I was still pretty happy with the three defenses that I landed. I probably could have left Denver off the mix and gone with another RB, but defenses can jump up and surprise you in a survivor format and I really like to have 3 of them on my roster if possible. In conclusion, I feel like I drafted the 'all underrated' team, and will spend the first week or two second guessing some of these choices, especially if some of these don't pan out. I don't HATE this team, but it's definitely not my best survivor entry. It has the feel of team that's set to finish in the middle of the pack. My only hope is the lack of week 5 issues gives me just enough to squeak into 4th.
 
great week 5 couldn't save that wretched team. WRs were awful. When Colston is your WR2, you're in trouble

 
I didn't draft well at all, and then had injuries drive the final nails into the coffin. A few decent picks later on like Jordy Nelson and Nate Washington couldn't save me.

Good luck to those who advanced!

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top