The thing that most people don't realize (because it is unlike most other sports) is that the Conn Smythe Award is given to a player based on his body of work over the entire playoffs, not just a game or series. At this point I would consider +700 to be a nice value play with Niemi. Toews is still 6 points ahead of the next Blackhawk in scoring. If he continues to be silent, I would vote for Niemi. If he puts in a point per game over the next 2-4 games, I believe Toews wins. 2 of Niemi's major KPI's are GAA and Save %, both are solid, but not spectacular. The award is decided by journalists....writers for USA today, Yahoo Sports, Denver Post, etc...imo journalists tend to be "what have you done for me lately". If Toews scores 0-1 points in the Stanley Cup finals series, I have a hard time believing that he would get a majority of the 400ish votes. Right or wrong, I would favor Niemi in that scenario, unless he (or the Hawks) falters again and we have another 10-9 game or whatever game 1 ended up at. To your other point, I don't believe that the field has any value at this point.