Four Baseball Poles (1 Viewer)

[Lehigh98]

Because I'm having trouble waiting around for the next round.

 

[boubucarow]

Yankees 70%

Phillies 80%

Rangers - Phillies in the hope of Lee vs Halladay

Lee

 

[Jaysus]

What, no Joe Blanton?

 

[Lehigh98]

What, no Joe Blanton?

That's to pick your starter, not the opposing team's.

 

[dennis.moore]

Game 7 - Jack Morris or John Smoltz

 

[Mr. Know-It-All]

On the road I might go with Cliff Lee, but in general Roy Halladay.

 

[Eephus]

Game 7 - Jack Morris or John Smoltz

Mickey Lolich or Bob Gibson

 

[whoknew]

I'm surprised people would rather have Lee than Halladay.

Seems strange.

 

[Lehigh98]

I'm surprised people would rather have Lee than Halladay.Seems strange.

Maybe because Halladay has had one start against the Reds and Lee has 7 starts with 6 wins including 2 elimination games and 2 in the World Series. I think Halladay has the potential but so far Lee has been more proven in the postseason including the LCS and WS levels Halladay hasn't had a chance in yet.

 

[whoknew]

I'm surprised people would rather have Lee than Halladay.Seems strange.

Maybe because Halladay has had one start against the Reds and Lee has 7 starts with 6 wins including 2 elimination games and 2 in the World Series. I think Halladay has the potential but so far Lee has been more proven in the postseason including the LCS and WS levels Halladay hasn't had a chance in yet.

But Halladay is better.

 

[harryhood]

I'm surprised people would rather have Lee than Halladay.Seems strange.

Maybe because Halladay has had one start against the Reds and Lee has 7 starts with 6 wins including 2 elimination games and 2 in the World Series. I think Halladay has the potential but so far Lee has been more proven in the postseason including the LCS and WS levels Halladay hasn't had a chance in yet.

But Halladay is better.

This. I don't drop the guy down a notch because his team could never make the post season.

 

[Captain Hook]

I'm surprised people would rather have Lee than Halladay.

Seems strange.

Maybe because Halladay has had one start against the Reds and Lee has 7 starts with 6 wins including 2 elimination games and 2 in the World Series. I think Halladay has the potential but so far Lee has been more proven in the postseason including the LCS and WS levels Halladay hasn't had a chance in yet.

But Halladay is better.

This. I don't drop the guy down a notch because his team could never make the post season.

Maybe not....BUT the experience counts for something AND if the Rangers beat the Yankees it will mean:1) Hamilton is back to hitting well; and

2) The team confidence will be sky high

Besides who would be more motivated > Cliff Lee facing the Phillies in the World Series after they dumped him

 

[Michael Brown]

Yankees 60%

Phillies 70%

Yanks/Phillies

Halladay