What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Girls Soccer and Concussions (1 Viewer)

Don't Toews Me

Footballguy
"New study shows that girls soccer has higher per capita rate of concussions than any other sport"

When you think of prep sports concussions, you almost certainly think of football first. Yet a new study shows that football barely has the second-highest per capita rate of concussions and traumatic brain injuries among all health setbacks in a specific high school sports. The top number? Girls soccer, by a significant amount.

The findings from the study “Sport- and Gender-specific Trends in the Epidemiology of Concussions Suffered by High School Athletes”found that roughly 27 percent of all injuries suffered by girls soccer players are traumatic brain injuries (TBI). That’s a staggering percentage, particularly for a sport that also features a high incidence rate of knee injuries and other concerns.

The study, led by Dr. Wellington Hsu, professor of orthopaedics at Northwestern University’s Feinberg School of Medicine, was presented at the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons (AAOS) annual conference.

From the study: To our knowledge, this is the first study to report that concussions now account for a higher proportion of injuries in girls soccer than boys football. The concussion rate for girls soccer is also increasing rapidly, and is now nearly tied with boys football and 3-fold higher than boys soccer.

To put that 27 percent in perspective, football injuries feature a 24 percent correlation between brain injuries and overall injuries. That percentage is almost identical to the one for girls basketball and the one for boys soccer, with each of those sports approximately one percentage point behind the prior sport on the list.

Equally notable was the fact that concussions are apparently on the rise across all sports, with many rates essentially doubling following the introduction of TBI laws.

While much of that is clearly due to increased awareness, there’s little question that concussions within the sport of girls soccer are on the rise, which may finally adjust perceptions about what constitutes a dangerous sport.
Via Dr. Erin Reynolds (a neuropsychologist): https://twitter.com/DrErinReynolds/status/1014546107177848833

Erin Reynolds PsyD‏ @DrErinReynolds Jul 4

If you know me, you've heard me say take #football away tomorrow and my #concussion practice is still booming. It's time for more talk about treatment and less talk about the #NFL.
Mike Hopper, MS, ATC‏ @mnhopper1s Jul 4

So absolutely correct! Football accounts for ~110 of our athletes. Nobody seems to want to talk about the risks that the other 650 athletes at our school take in sport participation each day! #AT4ALL addresses all of them too! Concussions are not a football problem!
Erin Reynolds PsyD‏ @DrErinReynolds Jul 4

It drives me crazy - football is a small percentage of overall concussions (for 4 months out of the year in high school) but takes up all of our collective attention!
Mike Hopper, MS, ATC‏ @mnhopper1s Jul 4

Yep. 4 years I've been at my school, and we've had nearly as many concussions in volleyball as we have had in football. I believe golf is our only sport we haven't dealt with a concussion in the sport or through outside injury.

 
I'm not sure why you felt the need to describe a 16-month-old study as "new", but whatever.

Anyway, concussions in girls sports are a legitimate concern. Luckily, many states and schools have already implemented protocols which will significantly reduce the risks for girls (i.e., eliminating headers, reducing contact drills, increasing awareness, increasing medical attention, etc.).

Unfortunately, many of these protocols are not available for football players, which is why football is nearly as dangerous now as it was 5 years ago.

 
I played in a coed adult soccer league a few years ago. One girl on the opposing team one week was playing incredibly recklessly and aggressively. Eventually she went for a 50/50 ball that she had no business trying for an launched the top of her head directly into my chin. Knocked herself out cold and got a really bad concussion.

I don't really have a point other than women are crazy.

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top