This thread is as good as any to ask I guess (I hope). Why do so many people go out of their way to express how much they "hate" the Eagles? It was even a joke in the Big Lebowski. I wouldn't list them as one of my favorite acts but have always enjoyed them and they left a lot of really good music behind. The whole phenomenon seems so odd and it's almost like its some "music cred" thing to hate on that band.
R.I.P Glenn. Thanks for the music.
I think it has something to do with the fact that their music sometimes sounds simple, like anyone could do it. The stupider/less musically educated the listener, the more likely this conclusion. When in fact harmonizing as well as Henley and Frey did is incredibly rare, Henley is a ridiculously talented (and underrated) drummer, much of the guitar and bass playing was quite complex, and their songwriting was masterclass-level.
Don't think it has anything to do with it's simplicity, but a lot to do with sterility. Even when they go for something swinging, it's stiff as a board. Plus anybody in the tank for Gram Parsons, Hillman, Clark, Clarence White, etc is likely going to find the Eagles way over-overpolished. Beyond that, I just don't like the songs. The Lebowski thing was just a rallying point for everybody who felt similarly having that sentiment pop up so randomly and hilariously.