What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Great sports towns with absolutely no shared history (1 Viewer)

SaintsInDome2006 said:
QuizGuy66 said:
SaintsInDome2006 said:
San Diego vs Anybody/Everybody.

Besides the Padres vs Atlanta, Chicago, New York, Detroit - SD has never won a championship in any major pro sport.
Forgot the AFC Championship game vs the Bengals eh?And the Super Bowl where the 49ers smoked 'em.

And the fact that LA stole the Clippers (who San Diego stole from Buffalo).

(Okay stealing the Clippers from the San Diego may be a bit strong).

-QG
Pfft, fail on my part.

This is a pretty tough question, I guess almost every town has had a team make it to the championship level in some sport.
Not Cleveland (since 1964, pre super bowl)

 
zamboni said:
Walking Boot said:
Milwaukee and Nashville
The Milwaukee Admirals of the AHL are the top minor league affiliate of the Nashville Predators.
The Nashville Sounds were also the Triple A affiliate of the Brewers from 2005-2014...seeing Braun and Fielder both come through here.

 
DC and Boston have almost no history/rivalry despite being on the same coast and each having teams in all four major sports. The football and baseball teams play in different conferences and haven't met in the playoffs to my knowledge, which includes a combined 13 Super Bowl appearances. The basketball teams are in the same conference but somehow have never been good at the same time (DC 1977-79 and 2013-present, Boston pretty much every other season) and have met in only three playoff series, none in the last 30 years. The hockey teams are both perennial playoff teams in the same conference but somehow have also only met three times in their history, only once in the last 15+ years.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
DC and Boston have almost no history/rivalry despite being on the same coast and each having teams in all four major sports. The football and baseball teams play in different conferences and haven't met in the playoffs to my knowledge, which includes a combined 13 Super Bowl appearances. The basketball teams are in the same conference but somehow have never been good at the same time (DC 1977-79 and 2013-present, Boston pretty much every other season) and have met in only three playoff series, none in the last 30 years. The hockey teams are both perennial playoff teams in the same conference but somehow have also only met three times in their history, only once in the last 15+ years.
Grew up in Boston (76-88), spend most of adulthood in DC (88-present except 2001-2004 in Boston). This is probably accurate. The only curve is you might consider DC an Orioles town until 2005 when the Nationals moved south from Montreal. Not sure if there was any interaction between the Sox and the 2 Senators franchises that became the Twins and the Rangers.

 
DC and Boston have almost no history/rivalry despite being on the same coast and each having teams in all four major sports. The football and baseball teams play in different conferences and haven't met in the playoffs to my knowledge, which includes a combined 13 Super Bowl appearances. The basketball teams are in the same conference but somehow have never been good at the same time (DC 1977-79 and 2013-present, Boston pretty much every other season) and have met in only three playoff series, none in the last 30 years. The hockey teams are both perennial playoff teams in the same conference but somehow have also only met three times in their history, only once in the last 15+ years.
:shrug: In 1975 the Bullets beat the Celtics in the Eastern Conference Finals. Plus you got the whole Boston Redskins thing.
 
DC and Boston have almost no history/rivalry despite being on the same coast and each having teams in all four major sports. The football and baseball teams play in different conferences and haven't met in the playoffs to my knowledge, which includes a combined 13 Super Bowl appearances. The basketball teams are in the same conference but somehow have never been good at the same time (DC 1977-79 and 2013-present, Boston pretty much every other season) and have met in only three playoff series, none in the last 30 years. The hockey teams are both perennial playoff teams in the same conference but somehow have also only met three times in their history, only once in the last 15+ years.
Grew up in Boston (76-88), spend most of adulthood in DC (88-present except 2001-2004 in Boston). This is probably accurate. The only curve is you might consider DC an Orioles town until 2005 when the Nationals moved south from Montreal. Not sure if there was any interaction between the Sox and the 2 Senators franchises that became the Twins and the Rangers.
The old Senators and Red Sox had some great battles for 6th place. Joe Cronin had some great years in Washington but his sale to the Red Sox in 1934 sent the Senators into a tailspin that they never recovered from.

Ted Williams managed the new Senators.

 
DC and Boston have almost no history/rivalry despite being on the same coast and each having teams in all four major sports. The football and baseball teams play in different conferences and haven't met in the playoffs to my knowledge, which includes a combined 13 Super Bowl appearances. The basketball teams are in the same conference but somehow have never been good at the same time (DC 1977-79 and 2013-present, Boston pretty much every other season) and have met in only three playoff series, none in the last 30 years. The hockey teams are both perennial playoff teams in the same conference but somehow have also only met three times in their history, only once in the last 15+ years.
:shrug: In 1975 the Bullets beat the Celtics in the Eastern Conference Finals. Plus you got the whole Boston Redskins thing.
Also Ted Williams managing the old Senators for a bit. But that's really all there is, and it's all ancient history. The only thing that's happened in the last 40 years is the two first-round Cup series and a couple early NBA playoff series 30+ years ago, which I think is odd considering the geography and the fact that they both have teams in all four sports. Mostly a product of all the Washington teams sucking over that stretch, to be sure, but still unusual.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
DC and Boston have almost no history/rivalry despite being on the same coast and each having teams in all four major sports. The football and baseball teams play in different conferences and haven't met in the playoffs to my knowledge, which includes a combined 13 Super Bowl appearances. The basketball teams are in the same conference but somehow have never been good at the same time (DC 1977-79 and 2013-present, Boston pretty much every other season) and have met in only three playoff series, none in the last 30 years. The hockey teams are both perennial playoff teams in the same conference but somehow have also only met three times in their history, only once in the last 15+ years.
:shrug: In 1975 the Bullets beat the Celtics in the Eastern Conference Finals. Plus you got the whole Boston Redskins thing.
Also Ted Williams managing the old Senators for a bit. But that's really all there is, and it's all ancient history. The only thing that's happened in the last 40 years is the two first-round Cup series, which I think is odd considering the geography and the fact that they both have teams in all four sports. Mostly a product of all the Washington teams sucking over that stretch, to be sure, but still unusual.
I think you're right...When the 'skins were great in the Joe Gibbs era, the Patriots weren't very good. Now when the Pats have been good over the last decade, the skin's have been scraping the bottom of the barrel.

 
Cleveland's hockey team merged into the Minnesota North Stars in the 70s.

The best answer is probably Cleveland with some other city. Cleveland and L.A.?

 
Cleveland's hockey team merged into the Minnesota North Stars in the 70s.

The best answer is probably Cleveland with some other city. Cleveland and L.A.?
The Browns and Rams played each other for the NFL Championship 3 times in the '50s. The Browns won 2, the Rams won 1.

 
Green Bay and Toronto.
As good a start as any.

You almost have to start with cities that don't have 4 major sports teams. Or those that haven't had them long. Or win championships.

So Nashville, lacking major league baseball and basketball, paired with say Memphis, might work.

Or start with cities with great college teams but not pro. Ann arbor, south Bend, Tuscaloosa; with pro cities.

even if they're close by.

South Bend and Chicago?

Ann arbor and Detroit?

Tuscaloosa and Atlanta/Nashville?

 
Green Bay and Toronto.
As good a start as any.

You almost have to start with cities that don't have 4 major sports teams. Or those that haven't had them long. Or win championships.

So Nashville, lacking major league baseball and basketball, paired with say Memphis, might work.

Or start with cities with great college teams but not pro. Ann arbor, south Bend, Tuscaloosa; with pro cities.

even if they're close by.

South Bend and Chicago?

Ann arbor and Detroit?

Tuscaloosa and Atlanta/Nashville?
Too much proximity automatically means shared history.

Lots of ND alums in the Chicago area - it pretty much self disqualifies as it guarantees "shared" history.

Interestingly, though, I always noted how much I hate Notre Dame but as an Illinois alum realize we almost never play them (at least in the major sports) - one 2nd round game in the NCAA tournnament at the Hoosier Dome is about it.

A good offshoot might be major college programs in College Basketball and Football with no shared history. There's a few.

Anyway...

Ann Arbor and Detroit - too close - lots of UM and Michigan State alums to :stirspot: Doesn't track.

Tuscaloosa and Atlanta - total SEC Alabama/Georgia - tons of history.

Tuscaloosa and Nashville - Vandy is in Nashville and while awful almost all of the time there's history w/Alabama as both are SEC. And I'm sure there's enough Vols fans there as well.

-QG

 
DC and Boston have almost no history/rivalry despite being on the same coast and each having teams in all four major sports. The football and baseball teams play in different conferences and haven't met in the playoffs to my knowledge, which includes a combined 13 Super Bowl appearances. The basketball teams are in the same conference but somehow have never been good at the same time (DC 1977-79 and 2013-present, Boston pretty much every other season) and have met in only three playoff series, none in the last 30 years. The hockey teams are both perennial playoff teams in the same conference but somehow have also only met three times in their history, only once in the last 15+ years.
:shrug: In 1975 the Bullets beat the Celtics in the Eastern Conference Finals. Plus you got the whole Boston Redskins thing.
Also Ted Williams managing the old Senators for a bit. But that's really all there is, and it's all ancient history. The only thing that's happened in the last 40 years is the two first-round Cup series and a couple early NBA playoff series 30+ years ago, which I think is odd considering the geography and the fact that they both have teams in all four sports. Mostly a product of all the Washington teams sucking over that stretch, to be sure, but still unusual.
Since people seem to be including college into this analysis, I guess Georgetown/BC may need to be considered. BC did have some good teams every now and again. Though Georgetown's biggest rival was definitely Syracuse in the old Big East.

 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top