Hakeem Nicks listed as doubtful a few weeks ago (1 Viewer)

[zed2283]

Luckily in my dynasty I can just roll with AJ Green and Julio

 

[The Jerk]

Redraft could be a buy if you are 3-1 with sufficient team strength. Shouldn't take as much to get him now. He could be a difference maker following the Week 11 bye.

 

[RushHour]

I hate owning this guy so much.

 

[steveski]

Damn. I was planning on grabbing Hixon after the waivers cleared even if no news about Nicks was released. Now I may have to waste my good waiver priority on him.

 

[southeastjerome]

Everyone is always wondering/asking who this year's Victor Cruz is. If Nicks is indeed out for an extended period of time, Hixon could end up being this year's Cruz.

 

[solorca]

Redraft could be a buy if you are 3-1 with sufficient team strength. Shouldn't take as much to get him now. He could be a difference maker following the Week 11 bye.

I'm sitting at 4-0 with sufficient depth, so I think I'm going to just sit on him. I've only started him in week one anyway (he was on my bench in the week he blew up), so I've been surviving without him. I may get burned if this ends up being an IR situation, but I think he'll be more valuable to my team's playoff run than the player I could get in a trade.I have the benefit of having Marshall, Nicks, Stevie Johnson, and Hartline, along with Demarco Murray, Lynch, and Mcfadden, and only have to start 2/2 and a flex though. If a team was in a rougher situation, or is currently at 2-2 or worse, I think it's worth it to start shopping him...but I wouldn't give him away.

 

[scrumptrulescent]

Everyone is always wondering/asking who this year's Victor Cruz is. If Nicks is indeed out for an extended period of time, Hixon could end up being this year's Cruz.

If Nicks doesn't play, couldn't Barden do just as well as Hixon?

 

[steveski]

Everyone is always wondering/asking who this year's Victor Cruz is. If Nicks is indeed out for an extended period of time, Hixon could end up being this year's Cruz.

If Nicks doesn't play, couldn't Barden do just as well as Hixon?

By the looks of Sunday, Hixon is the WR3 on the giants and Barden is the WR4. Barden only did well 2 weeks ago because Nicks AND Hixon were out. If it's just a short term thing, Hixon is the guy to own. If it's IR, then Barden might be worth a stash if you have a deep enough bench to see if he emerges.

 

[Buck Bradcanon]

Everyone is always wondering/asking who this year's Victor Cruz is. If Nicks is indeed out for an extended period of time, Hixon could end up being this year's Cruz.

If Nicks doesn't play, couldn't Barden do just as well as Hixon?

By the looks of Sunday, Hixon is the WR3 on the giants and Barden is the WR4. Barden only did well 2 weeks ago because Nicks AND Hixon were out. If it's just a short term thing, Hixon is the guy to own. If it's IR, then Barden might be worth a stash if you have a deep enough bench to see if he emerges.

This. I think its Hixon and its really not close. Full disclosure I own Nicks and Barden, but not Hixon.

 

[matttyl]

Anyone know how it would work if he were to be put on the IR now, with the new rules? When would he be able to return?

 

[kutta]

Redraft he's obviously a sell but as a dynasty owner I'm not concerned at all. My team is WR heavy so I don't need him but I'd much rather he sat out a few weeks and came back healthy.

I don't think he's obviously a sell. I think he's obviously a buy.

 

[ponchsox]

I'm really hoping we hear some news soon about his knee and how long they expect him to be out.

 

[Dought Man]

Relax guys...

 

[SameSongNDance]

I'm holding unless I can get a low-end WR1 type of guy.

 

[fruity pebbles]

According to ESPN.com, Coughlin said Nicks is moving better, but he didn't want to speculate if the wideout would return to practice on Thursday. Barden complained of headaches and was evaluated on Tuesday, according to The Star-Ledger.

 

[MAC_32]

Follow FBG's own Jene Bramel on twitter, I think his breakdown is spot on

 

[DevilintheDetail]

I'm getting a bad feeling about this. Nicks just can't stay healthy. The knee injury coming out of nowhere is particularly concerning.

 

[SameSongNDance]

I'm getting a bad feeling about this. Nicks just can't stay healthy. The knee injury coming out of nowhere is particularly concerning.

The injury didn't really come out of nowhere though. This type of injury, where the player injures his opposite leg because of compensation, isn't a rare occurrence.By the way, the fact that he even has a chance to practice Thursday is good news.I can't believe it but I actually handcuffed Hixon in the two leagues I own him in, first time handcuffing a WR.Hixon was targeted 11 times last week (was on the field for 97% of offensive snaps compared to Barden's 63% and now Barden has a concussion) and gets matched up with a Haden-less CLE secondary this Sunday. IMO he's in WR2 territory for this week.

 

[tdhartis]

Follow FBG's own Jene Bramel on twitter, I think his breakdown is spot on

For those that don't care to venture:Jene Bramel @JeneBramelNicks Scenario 1 (more likely): Bone bruise annoyance, not significant. Could limit him for 1-2 wks. Silver lining: Rest also calms foot. Nicks Scenario 2 (less likely): Prolonged swelling evidence of meniscus/cartilage inj, rest doesn't help, surgery necessary, out 2-6 wks.

 

[ponchsox]

If he's even being considered a question mark to practice Thursday that leads to believe this is more of a day to day thing rather than week to week. Lets hope.

 

[Bo Skiboski]

Nicks owners: "I think he'll be fine."

Everyone else: "Scares me a bit."

 

[cvnpoka]

I'm getting a bad feeling about this. Nicks just can't stay healthy. The knee injury coming out of nowhere is particularly concerning.

The injury didn't really come out of nowhere though. This type of injury, where the player injures his opposite leg because of compensation, isn't a rare occurrence.

pretty sure he injured his knee bc he fell on it. had nothing to do with overcompensation.

The injury originated when he went down hard on an incomplete pass in the fourth quarter of the Giants' Week 2 win over Tampa. His ankle was stepped on in the process.

http://espn.go.com/nfl/story/_/id/8436264/new-york-giants-wide-receiver-hakeem-nicks-doubtful-philadelphia-eagles

 

[SameSongNDance]

I'm getting a bad feeling about this. Nicks just can't stay healthy. The knee injury coming out of nowhere is particularly concerning.

The injury didn't really come out of nowhere though. This type of injury, where the player injures his opposite leg because of compensation, isn't a rare occurrence.

pretty sure he injured his knee bc he fell on it. had nothing to do with overcompensation.

The injury originated when he went down hard on an incomplete pass in the fourth quarter of the Giants' Week 2 win over Tampa. His ankle was stepped on in the process.

http://espn.go.com/nfl/story/_/id/8436264/new-york-giants-wide-receiver-hakeem-nicks-doubtful-philadelphia-eagles

A lot of speculation is that the injury is more so due to overcompensation. http://www.nydailynews.com/blogs/giants/2012/09/ny-giants-hakeem-nicks-ruled-out-for-eagles-game

http://www.nypost.com/p/sports/giants/nicks_bruises_LassaViJDMhoVSmXeTkIBJ

I hope you're right but overcompensation seems like a distinct possibility.

 

[kutta]

Nicks owners: "I think he'll be fine."Everyone else: "Scares me a bit."

I'm a Nicks owner and I'm scared a lot.

 

[solorca]

Nicks owners: "I think he'll be fine."Everyone else: "Scares me a bit."

Most fantasy owners I know typically think the worst about their players injuries. It's the non-owners who are the voice of reason, more often than not.I'm a Nicks owner and have said that I think this will be a lingering injury that could cost him the season...but a lot of that is probably just me being a pessimist.

 

[Bo Skiboski]

Nicks owners: "I think he'll be fine."Everyone else: "Scares me a bit."

I'm a Nicks owner and I'm scared a lot.

I'm curious if you're trying desperately to deal him then.

 

[ponchsox]

Nicks owners: "I think he'll be fine."Everyone else: "Scares me a bit."

Most fantasy owners I know typically think the worst about their players injuries. It's the non-owners who are the voice of reason, more often than not.I'm a Nicks owner and have said that I think this will be a lingering injury that could cost him the season...but a lot of that is probably just me being a pessimist.

Have you picked up Hixon?

 

[kutta]

Nicks owners: "I think he'll be fine."Everyone else: "Scares me a bit."

I'm a Nicks owner and I'm scared a lot.

I'm curious if you're trying desperately to deal him then.

No way. I won't get any value out of him. I own Nicks in three leagues. I have picked up Hixon and Barden wherever possible.I'll ride out the storm and hope Hicks comes back healthy in a few weeks. But if I traded him now I'd get nothing for him.

 

[solorca]

Nicks owners: "I think he'll be fine."Everyone else: "Scares me a bit."

Most fantasy owners I know typically think the worst about their players injuries. It's the non-owners who are the voice of reason, more often than not.I'm a Nicks owner and have said that I think this will be a lingering injury that could cost him the season...but a lot of that is probably just me being a pessimist.

Have you picked up Hixon?

I did, but honestly it had more to do with blocking my opponent (who is currently starting Golden Tate and Stephen Hill because of injuries/bye week) from picking him up and starting him against me this week.If Nicks is shut down for the season at some point, Hixon will probably stay on my team as an occasional injury/bye week play.

 

[noneother]

Moved him for Britt and Martelus Bennett (backing up gates) had to do something.....

Hankerson and Gordon as my #4/5

Bryant and Maclin at 1/2

Nicks as troubled me for three years.. Couldn't stomach it.. At least with Britt, I can have déjà vu all over again.. But different.

 

[UFGator0587]

Moved him for Britt and Martelus Bennett (backing up gates) had to do something.....Hankerson and Gordon as my #4/5Bryant and Maclin at 1/2Nicks as troubled me for three years.. Couldn't stomach it.. At least with Britt, I can have déjà vu all over again.. But different.

Trading a risky player for a not-as-good risky player and a solid TE? No thanks.

 

[ponchsox]

Hakeem Nicks (foot, knee) has been ruled out for Week 5 versus the Browns.

Coach Tom Coughlin pointed to a combination of knee and foot soreness, although the Giants insist there's been no setback with his surgically repaired foot. Doctors are hoping the extra rest will do him good. At this point, we're more concerned that the knee injury could end up being a cartilage or mensicus issue. With Nicks out and Ramses Barden (concussion) in doubt, Domenik Hixon is a must-add plug-and-play WR3 option against a Browns secondary allowing the second-most fantasy points to opposing receivers.

If Hixon is still available, RUN and get him.

 

[babydemon90]

Where does Hixon rate going forward though? Compared to other WR's like Hartline, Britt, etc... that also have the capacity to be special...

 

[ponchsox]

Where does Hixon rate going forward though? Compared to other WR's like Hartline, Britt, etc... that also have the capacity to be special...

When Nicks is out, I like Hixon better. How long will Nicks be out? That is the million dollar question.

 

[DevilintheDetail]

Where does Hixon rate going forward though? Compared to other WR's like Hartline, Britt, etc... that also have the capacity to be special...

I'd much rather have Hixon than Britt. Britt could be an injury scratch all season and the offense is not good. I'd rather have Hartline than Hixon. Hartline is the clear #1 target on his team and Hixon will probably eventually have to deal with Nicks coming back.

 

[ponchsox]

Where does Hixon rate going forward though? Compared to other WR's like Hartline, Britt, etc... that also have the capacity to be special...

I'd much rather have Hixon than Britt. Britt could be an injury scratch all season and the offense is not good. I'd rather have Hartline than Hixon. Hartline is the clear #1 target on his team and Hixon will probably eventually have to deal with Nicks coming back.

It also depends on the league. In ppr I like Hartline but non-ppr Hixon will have more TD chances.

 

[DevilintheDetail]

Where does Hixon rate going forward though? Compared to other WR's like Hartline, Britt, etc... that also have the capacity to be special...

I'd much rather have Hixon than Britt. Britt could be an injury scratch all season and the offense is not good. I'd rather have Hartline than Hixon. Hartline is the clear #1 target on his team and Hixon will probably eventually have to deal with Nicks coming back.

It also depends on the league. In ppr I like Hartline but non-ppr Hixon will have more TD chances.

I have no idea why Hixon would have more TD chances. Hartline has gotten lots of red zone looks so far.

 

[ponchsox]

Where does Hixon rate going forward though? Compared to other WR's like Hartline, Britt, etc... that also have the capacity to be special...

I'd much rather have Hixon than Britt. Britt could be an injury scratch all season and the offense is not good. I'd rather have Hartline than Hixon. Hartline is the clear #1 target on his team and Hixon will probably eventually have to deal with Nicks coming back.

It also depends on the league. In ppr I like Hartline but non-ppr Hixon will have more TD chances.

I have no idea why Hixon would have more TD chances. Hartline has gotten lots of red zone looks so far.

Hmmmmmm, maybe a much better QB in a passing offense?

 

[DevilintheDetail]

Where does Hixon rate going forward though? Compared to other WR's like Hartline, Britt, etc... that also have the capacity to be special...

I'd much rather have Hixon than Britt. Britt could be an injury scratch all season and the offense is not good. I'd rather have Hartline than Hixon. Hartline is the clear #1 target on his team and Hixon will probably eventually have to deal with Nicks coming back.

It also depends on the league. In ppr I like Hartline but non-ppr Hixon will have more TD chances.

I have no idea why Hixon would have more TD chances. Hartline has gotten lots of red zone looks so far.

Hmmmmmm, maybe a much better QB in a passing offense?

I think the fact that the Giants also have Cruz and Bennett taking red zone looks would balance those factors out.

 

[ponchsox]

Where does Hixon rate going forward though? Compared to other WR's like Hartline, Britt, etc... that also have the capacity to be special...

I'd much rather have Hixon than Britt. Britt could be an injury scratch all season and the offense is not good. I'd rather have Hartline than Hixon. Hartline is the clear #1 target on his team and Hixon will probably eventually have to deal with Nicks coming back.

It also depends on the league. In ppr I like Hartline but non-ppr Hixon will have more TD chances.

I have no idea why Hixon would have more TD chances. Hartline has gotten lots of red zone looks so far.

Hmmmmmm, maybe a much better QB in a passing offense?

I think the fact that the Giants also have Cruz and Bennett taking red zone looks would balance those factors out.

True, but great matchup against the Browns this week nonetheless.

 

[greggorymac]

Very scary that Nicks was officially ruled out for Week 5 so early in the week (on Thursday). What does that say about his availability for Week 6? Knee issue sounds severe... or am I just reading into this too much?

 

[coachbobbyfinstock]

Luckily in my dynasty I can just roll with AJ Green and Julio

Lame.

 

[ponchsox]

Very scary that Nicks was officially ruled out for Week 5 so early in the week (on Thursday). What does that say about his availability for Week 6? Knee issue sounds severe... or am I just reading into this too much?

I wouldn't count on him any time soon. If you are 4-0 or 3-1 you can afford to wait on him but if your team is struggling I would sell.

 

[DevilintheDetail]

Very scary that Nicks was officially ruled out for Week 5 so early in the week (on Thursday). What does that say about his availability for Week 6? Knee issue sounds severe... or am I just reading into this too much?

I wouldn't count on him any time soon. If you are 4-0 or 3-1 you can afford to wait on him but if your team is struggling I would sell.

Yeah, this is his third straight missed game and it doesn't sound like he was close at all to even practicing really. I think he'll probably miss the next couple of weeks. Unfortunately, his body just doesn't seem like it can stay healthy, as one injury leads to another.

 

[Soulfly3]

Although he's been ruled out for Week 5, Hakeem Nicks (knee, foot) jettisoned his stationary bike to participate in the Giants' jog-thru on Friday.Getting the mental reps is a good sign that the swelling is down in Nicks' knee, which should rule out a meniscus or cartilage injury. It now appears that he has a chance to return for Week 6 at San Francisco.

Calm.

 

[DevilintheDetail]

Although he's been ruled out for Week 5, Hakeem Nicks (knee, foot) jettisoned his stationary bike to participate in the Giants' jog-thru on Friday.Getting the mental reps is a good sign that the swelling is down in Nicks' knee, which should rule out a meniscus or cartilage injury. It now appears that he has a chance to return for Week 6 at San Francisco.

Calm.

The thing about Nicks is that it seems like he regularly re-aggravates injuries or that a new one pops up just as the old one dies down. If he manages to play week 6, will that just knock him out for a couple more games? It sure seems like that could easily happen.

 

[MAC_32]

Although he's been ruled out for Week 5, Hakeem Nicks (knee, foot) jettisoned his stationary bike to participate in the Giants' jog-thru on Friday.Getting the mental reps is a good sign that the swelling is down in Nicks' knee, which should rule out a meniscus or cartilage injury. It now appears that he has a chance to return for Week 6 at San Francisco.

Calm.

The thing about Nicks is that it seems like he regularly re-aggravates injuries or that a new one pops up just as the old one dies down. If he manages to play week 6, will that just knock him out for a couple more games? It sure seems like that could easily happen.

Next week's practices are important. If he practices next week and doesn't have any setbacks I'd feel good about his prospects week 6 and coming out of it healthy. He has over compensating injuries and the only way they'll improve is rest, good choice holding him out this week. If he has continued setbacks next week though there are more problems and he'll probably need to go under the knife. Just don't know if it's the 2 week variety, or 6.

 

[Buck Stop]

I wish we knew more. I love his talent, but the injuries are starting to occur way to often for my tastes. Was just offered Nicks for Torrey Smith and D. Moore in a PPR dynasty. I'm torn

 

[lbouchard]

I wish we knew more. I love his talent, but the injuries are starting to occur way to often for my tastes. Was just offered Nicks for Torrey Smith and D. Moore in a PPR dynasty. I'm torn

Don't want to turn this into AC thread, but I'd pass. I only have Smith one spot below Nicks.

 

[two_dollars]

Although he's been ruled out for Week 5, Hakeem Nicks (knee, foot) jettisoned his stationary bike to participate in the Giants' jog-thru on Friday.Getting the mental reps is a good sign that the swelling is down in Nicks' knee, which should rule out a meniscus or cartilage injury. It now appears that he has a chance to return for Week 6 at San Francisco.

Calm.

I think it deserves to be brought up again, someone mentioned it earlier, that the rest for his knee is also rest for his foot. That bodes well for future playing time as well.