What's new
Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums

This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Hakeem Nicks listed as doubtful a few weeks ago (1 Viewer)

Currently have Torrey Smith starting over him. Neither of them have ideal matchups though.

What kind of decisions are the rest of you dealing with?
Nicks or Maclin as my WR3.Unless I hear bad news im starting Nicks, I think both are in for big days but I cant see myself starting either over Roddy White or Stevie Johnson.
I can't see how anyone would be confident that Nicks is in for "a big day."We don't know how healthy he is and the Niners are yielding the second-fewest pass yards per game in the NFL.
Because after owning him for every year that hes been in the league he has built up my confidence in him.My thinking is Niners D is no joke, but their secondary are no world beaters. I figure they havent been focusing on Nicks, so he will be able to exploit some situations provided Eli can survive the pass rush, which I think will happen.

I think its gonna be a close game and whoever turns the ball over less wins, and this week I have that being NYG.

 
Currently have Torrey Smith starting over him. Neither of them have ideal matchups though.

What kind of decisions are the rest of you dealing with?
Nicks or Maclin as my WR3.Unless I hear bad news im starting Nicks, I think both are in for big days but I cant see myself starting either over Roddy White or Stevie Johnson.
I can't see how anyone would be confident that Nicks is in for "a big day."We don't know how healthy he is and the Niners are yielding the second-fewest pass yards per game in the NFL.
Because after owning him for every year that hes been in the league he has built up my confidence in him.My thinking is Niners D is no joke, but their secondary are no world beaters. I figure they havent been focusing on Nicks, so he will be able to exploit some situations provided Eli can survive the pass rush, which I think will happen.

I think its gonna be a close game and whoever turns the ball over less wins, and this week I have that being NYG.
This is my first year owning him in any leagues, so I'm interested in your thoughts since you're a longtime owner. Does he typically perform well coming off an injury? I know that I was disappointed in week 1 after expecting him to perform (followed by benching him when he blew up the next week)...
 
I have Calvin Johnson, Nicks, Andre Roberts currently in my lineup but I'm thinking about swapping Roberts for Torry Smith.

 
I have Calvin Johnson, Nicks, Andre Roberts currently in my lineup but I'm thinking about swapping Roberts for Torry Smith.
Nice. I was thinking about pastrami for lunch today but ended up going with a French dip. It was solid but not spectacular.
 
I have Calvin Johnson, Nicks, Andre Roberts currently in my lineup but I'm thinking about swapping Roberts for Torry Smith.
Nice. I was thinking about pastrami for lunch today but ended up going with a French dip. It was solid but not spectacular.
Another example of a new member running around using our board as their personal jack off sock. Did you get off with this post?
No, but keep going. I'm almost there.
 
Have to make a drop to take him off IR in the league I have him in. I also have Hixon, so that takes the late start out of play. Currently have Crabtree in as my starter so it's not like I'm going with a reach here. I'll agonize on this overnight and check prior to gametime about how he's looking pre-game prior to making a final decision. I REALLY want to start him, but...................

 
I have Calvin Johnson, Nicks, Andre Roberts currently in my lineup but I'm thinking about swapping Roberts for Torry Smith.
Nice. I was thinking about pastrami for lunch today but ended up going with a French dip. It was solid but not spectacular.
Another example of a new member running around using our board as their personal jack off sock. Did you get off with this post?
No, but keep going. I'm almost there.
Do you pull this stuff away from a keyboard?
 
Currently have Torrey Smith starting over him. Neither of them have ideal matchups though.

What kind of decisions are the rest of you dealing with?
Nicks or Maclin as my WR3.Unless I hear bad news im starting Nicks, I think both are in for big days but I cant see myself starting either over Roddy White or Stevie Johnson.
I can't see how anyone would be confident that Nicks is in for "a big day."We don't know how healthy he is and the Niners are yielding the second-fewest pass yards per game in the NFL.
Because after owning him for every year that hes been in the league he has built up my confidence in him.My thinking is Niners D is no joke, but their secondary are no world beaters. I figure they havent been focusing on Nicks, so he will be able to exploit some situations provided Eli can survive the pass rush, which I think will happen.

I think its gonna be a close game and whoever turns the ball over less wins, and this week I have that being NYG.
This is my first year owning him in any leagues, so I'm interested in your thoughts since you're a longtime owner. Does he typically perform well coming off an injury? I know that I was disappointed in week 1 after expecting him to perform (followed by benching him when he blew up the next week)...
Hes had nagging injuries as long as I can remember and a few serious ones, but I cant think of a single time he hasnt performed well while injured or coming off an injury. Hes one of the toughest WR in the NFL, and plays hard every game.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
do not bench your studs.I dont know how many times it needs to be repeated.
Does this still apply to Andre Johnson?
uh, ya.you got him, you start him
That advice would have left you frustrated almost every week.
Different situations. Nicks = stud whenever he's active. Even when dinged up. A Johnson = assumed stud at beginning of year but isn't anymore.I wouldn't hesitate to scratch a healthy AJ. Iirc he's even playing less snaps by design this year to keep him fresh for later.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
do not bench your studs.I dont know how many times it needs to be repeated.
Does this still apply to Andre Johnson?
uh, ya.you got him, you start him
That advice would have left you frustrated almost every week.
Different situations. Nicks = stud whenever he's active. Even when dinged up. A Johnson = assumed stud at beginning of year but isn't anymore.I wouldn't hesitate to scratch a healthy AJ. Iirc he's even playing less snaps by design this year to keep him fresh for later.
Agreed. Not only does AJ look old, but he barely looks to be part of the game plan anymore.I can't see how anyone would view him as an auto-start anymore.
 
I have Nicks in 3 leagues.

1. 16 teams, start Q/2R/2W/1T/1K/1D/1F, 0.5 PPR. I am debating between Denarius Moore and Nicks in my flex spot. Leaning towards Moore.

2. 10 teams, start 2Q/2R/2W/1T/1K/1D/1F, no PPR. I plan to start either Cobb or S. Rice in my flex spot over Nicks.

3. 8 teams, start 1Q/1R/1W/1T/1K/1D/3F, no PPR. I plan to start Murray, Martin, BJGE, and Ridley over Nicks and Desean Jackson.

 
What is everyone doing with late start this week and rumors he is gonna play with a very tough match up? I would have desperation options only if he doesn't play as most of my other guys play early games?

5 for 55 in NFC championship so maybe itnis better to keep him on bench

 
Last edited by a moderator:
'loose circuits said:
What is everyone doing with late start this week and rumors he is gonna play with a very tough match up? I would have desperation options only if he doesn't play as most of my other guys play early games?5 for 55 in NFC championship so maybe itnis better to keep him on bench
It's between Nicks and Stevie Johnson for me. Right now I have Johnson in. They both play in late afternoon games.
 
I don't buy the "don't bench your studs" argument. Nicks has been gimpy all year, and could be used as a decoy. He STILL isn't right.

 
'loose circuits said:
What is everyone doing with late start this week and rumors he is gonna play with a very tough match up? I would have desperation options only if he doesn't play as most of my other guys play early games?5 for 55 in NFC championship so maybe itnis better to keep him on bench
It's between Nicks and Stevie Johnson for me. Right now I have Johnson in. They both play in late afternoon games.
Same choice for me, and I'm going insane trying to decide the right one. I was leaning toward Nicks, until I saw this quote today...
(Rotoworld)Bills GM Buddy Nix expects Stevie Johnson to have a big game against the Cardinals on Sunday.Analysis: "Steve has had the best two weeks of practice that I've seen him have since I've been around him," said Nix. "I expect him to have a breakout game." Johnson will be squaring off with one of the better cover corners in the league in Arizona's Patrick Peterson, but Johnson thinks he can win. "He can be beat, anybody can be beat," Johnson said. He comes in as the No. 23 receiver in Rotoworld's Week 6 rankings.
 
He made the trip, thats all I need to know, starting him right now in WR slot and Bradshaw in the flex. If he ends up not being able to start ill be stuck with Manningham but im pretty confident he plays.

 
How can I possibly start this guy in a locked roster league with no other late game options? I would not be at all surprised if he plays and blows up, just like he did in the one good week he had.

 
How can I possibly start this guy in a locked roster league with no other late game options? I would not be at all surprised if he plays and blows up, just like he did in the one good week he had.
Yeah, I'm having a hard time being able to start him as well. I don't have any backup options in the late games due to injuries and bye weeks so it's either him at 4 or Mike Williams at 1. I'm probably going to go with Williams unless I hear something before the 1 oclock games start.
 
How can I possibly start this guy in a locked roster league with no other late game options? I would not be at all surprised if he plays and blows up, just like he did in the one good week he had.
Yeah, I'm having a hard time being able to start him as well. I don't have any backup options in the late games due to injuries and bye weeks so it's either him at 4 or Mike Williams at 1. I'm probably going to go with Williams unless I hear something before the 1 oclock games start.
I guess the hope for you is that Williams has a great game and you don't have to sweat it. For me, it's Hartline or Bryant. I'm sure I'll make the wrong decision, but I have Hartline in right now. Nicks may be maddening all season...one of those guys that I miss the good games and he stinks it up when I use him. Just feel like I need to see something out of him today before I plug him in.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Giants aren't starting Nicks if he's not ready.

Beat writers say he's running hard. Making great cuts. No repercussions from it thru the weeks' practices.

Whether you start him or not is your call.

Me, as Ive mentioned... I never bench my studs

 
Giants aren't starting Nicks if he's not ready. Beat writers say he's running hard. Making great cuts. No repercussions from it thru the weeks' practices.Whether you start him or not is your call.Me, as Ive mentioned... I never bench my studs
Do you by chance have a link? I'd like to read the reports. TIA.
 
Giants aren't starting Nicks if he's not ready. Beat writers say he's running hard. Making great cuts. No repercussions from it thru the weeks' practices.Whether you start him or not is your call.Me, as Ive mentioned... I never bench my studs
Do you by chance have a link? I'd like to read the reports. TIA.
Sorry bro, just typed in 'hakeem nicks' into the search bar of twitter throughout the week and read various news reports.You dont need to register to twitter to do this (I dont have an account)
 
How can I possibly start this guy in a locked roster league with no other late game options? I would not be at all surprised if he plays and blows up, just like he did in the one good week he had.
Yeah, I'm having a hard time being able to start him as well. I don't have any backup options in the late games due to injuries and bye weeks so it's either him at 4 or Mike Williams at 1. I'm probably going to go with Williams unless I hear something before the 1 oclock games start.
:goodposting: It's hard to start him with no other late options in case he's a no go.
 
Giants aren't starting Nicks if he's not ready.

Beat writers say he's running hard. Making great cuts. No repercussions from it thru the weeks' practices.

Whether you start him or not is your call.

Me, as Ive mentioned... I never bench my studs
Do you by chance have a link? I'd like to read the reports. TIA.
I found this.I too read somewhere else as well that he was running very well this week.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
NFL insider Jay Glazer reported on FOX NFL Sunday that the Giants are "optimistic" Hakeem Nicks (knee, foot) will play at San Francisco in Week 6.

According to Glazer, Nicks just boarded the bus to go test out his knee at Candlestick Park. He's not out of the woods just yet, but all indications thus far have suggested he will be active for the mammoth NFC tilt. Nicks had five catches for 55 yards versus at San Francisco in the NFC Championship game last season.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Why? The pinned thread is for news updates only and we are using this one to debate whether or not to start him.

He's in my lineup...and I have no other options :bag:

 
How can I possibly start this guy in a locked roster league with no other late game options? I would not be at all surprised if he plays and blows up, just like he did in the one good week he had.
Yeah, I'm having a hard time being able to start him as well. I don't have any backup options in the late games due to injuries and bye weeks so it's either him at 4 or Mike Williams at 1. I'm probably going to go with Williams unless I hear something before the 1 oclock games start.
Man, hope you stuck with TB Mike Williams!!
 
How can I possibly start this guy in a locked roster league with no other late game options? I would not be at all surprised if he plays and blows up, just like he did in the one good week he had.
Yeah, I'm having a hard time being able to start him as well. I don't have any backup options in the late games due to injuries and bye weeks so it's either him at 4 or Mike Williams at 1. I'm probably going to go with Williams unless I hear something before the 1 oclock games start.
Man, hope you stuck with TB Mike Williams!!
I did! Thank god. I really would have been kicking myself right now if I didn't.
 
How can I possibly start this guy in a locked roster league with no other late game options? I would not be at all surprised if he plays and blows up, just like he did in the one good week he had.
Yeah, I'm having a hard time being able to start him as well. I don't have any backup options in the late games due to injuries and bye weeks so it's either him at 4 or Mike Williams at 1. I'm probably going to go with Williams unless I hear something before the 1 oclock games start.
Man, hope you stuck with TB Mike Williams!!
I did! Thank god. I really would have been kicking myself right now if I didn't.
Awesome - way to go. Glad it worked out. I sat Hartline and put Nicks in, so I still hope Hakeem has a good game. I'll post any Nicks injury update I see in THIS THREAD...keeping an eye on Twitter.
 
http://www.sbnation.com/nfl/2012/10/14/3502326/hakeem-nicks-injury-update-fantasy-status-giants-vs-49ers

Hakeem Nicks (knee) is a game-time decision, but he looks good and isn't favoring his foot or knee in warmups, according to Ralph Vacchiano.

Nicks' last game was a 199-yard explosion against the Bucs. He has 14 catches and 237 yards in his two games this season.

Fantasy Impact: Nicks is expected to play and owners should feel somewhat comfortable with trotting him out there. The Niners do have an unbelievably good front seven, but their safeties Dashon Goldson and Donte Whitner can be burned. Nicks will probably run more vertical routes with any concern for cutting on his balky knee.

Fantasy owners should put Nicks in their lineup, but check back to make sure he's a go. Rueben Randle would make for a useful spot-start should Nicks be a surprising inactive.

 
Hakeem Nicks, WR, NYGNews: After missing the past three games with knee and foot issues, Giants wide receiver Hakeem Nicks is active for the Week 6 showdown at San Francisco. Nicks was listed as questionable on the team's injury report after being limited in practice last week. He has not played since Sept. 16 when the the fourth-year wideout tallied 199 yards on 10 catches.Analysis: In seven games since the calendar flipped to the new year, Nicks has posted 47 receptions for 757 yards (108.1 yards per game) and six touchdowns. The 49ers are allowing an average of the fewest Fantasy points to opposing receivers this season (14.2), but Nicks is still considered a quality option in most formats for Week 6.
I'm going roll with Nicks :boxing:
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top