BigRed
Footballguy
Been easy to whiff on a lot of players in this weird year but injuries, obvious unpredictables (eg Saints sucking) etc notwithstanding, some of my notable hit/misses offhand:
HITS:
V Young overrated, esp running-wise (didn't anyone else learn from the K Stewart SNAFU)
Benson overrated
T Jones (overrated almost every year he's been in the league)
Brady and Moss to tear it up (didn't expect it to be this ridiculous tho)
Edwards to do well
TJ Housh - he's better than circus clown CJ
Wayne - I felt this was the year he finally surpassed Harrison (OK thought that last year too but it was for the first time)
Alexander - wasn't about to touch this overrated old fart
MISSES:
Favre - expected another pathetic year
E Manning - yeah last week sucked but overall he's done pretty well and way better than most expected (since he lost Barber, OL, etc)
Garrard - not flashy but has done better than I ever expected w/those lame WRs/TEs
Westbrook - figured him on IR by now or at least rushing for less
MB3 - I expected the low touches; I didn't expect this much production from them
R Brown - was doing great on a lame team, I've considered him overrated from Day 1
fn LJ - despite the weak team I expected a LOT more than he's mostly given
Debatable:
Jordan - loved him as cheap RB4, been mixed results
Campbell - not a believer
Jacobs - did not feel he could be "the man" all year
HITS:
V Young overrated, esp running-wise (didn't anyone else learn from the K Stewart SNAFU)
Benson overrated
T Jones (overrated almost every year he's been in the league)
Brady and Moss to tear it up (didn't expect it to be this ridiculous tho)
Edwards to do well
TJ Housh - he's better than circus clown CJ
Wayne - I felt this was the year he finally surpassed Harrison (OK thought that last year too but it was for the first time)
Alexander - wasn't about to touch this overrated old fart
MISSES:
Favre - expected another pathetic year
E Manning - yeah last week sucked but overall he's done pretty well and way better than most expected (since he lost Barber, OL, etc)
Garrard - not flashy but has done better than I ever expected w/those lame WRs/TEs
Westbrook - figured him on IR by now or at least rushing for less
MB3 - I expected the low touches; I didn't expect this much production from them
R Brown - was doing great on a lame team, I've considered him overrated from Day 1
fn LJ - despite the weak team I expected a LOT more than he's mostly given
Debatable:
Jordan - loved him as cheap RB4, been mixed results
Campbell - not a believer
Jacobs - did not feel he could be "the man" all year
Last edited by a moderator:
