Q1: Three starting QBs (Vick/Roethlisberger/Cutler) will be out of action this week. Which offensive player on either PHI, PIT or CHI will be negatively impacted the most? Is there a separate player that stands to benefit above all others?
Most Negatively Impacted
Heath Miller (TE – PIT): Miller is the most likely to get negatively impacted. He didn’t get a single pass thrown his way after Ben Roethlisberger went down in week 10. Byron Leftwich is a lot less elusive than Roethlisberger and it’s likely Miller will be staying in to block more often to help protect Leftwich. Fantasy owners have been very happy with Miller most of this season as he’s averaged nearly 9 points per game in standard scoring systems, but with Leftwich at QB, I’m expecting that to drop off, possibly dramatically. - Russ Bliss (Fantasy Football Starters)
Brandon MarshallMike Wallace (WR – PIT) & Brandon Marshall (WR – CHI): The two offensive players who will be hurt most by this are Mike Wallace and Brandon Marshall. It’s close, but I think the tie would have to go to the former because Jay Cutler won’t be out for very long. Ben Roethlisberger will miss six weeks or so. Leftwich has a long delivery, which will prompt Todd Haley to call more runs and screens. – Walter Cherepinsky (Walter Football)
Brandon Marshall (WR – CHI): Marshall will be the player negatively impacted the most this week because of QB injuries. The Chicago-San Francisco game was probably going to be fairly low-scoring even if Cutler was playing. Now that Cutler is out, it’s likely that Marshall will be even more focused by the 49ers’ secondary and not see nearly as many targets from Jason Campbell as he usually does from Cutler. Plus, the 49ers are fifth in the NFL in passing yards allowed per game. - Zach Greubel (Win My Fantasy League)
Brandon Marshall (WR – CHI): As the starter for the Redskins in 2008, Jason Campbell attempted throws of 20+ yards on just 6.9% of his drop backs, which was the lowest rate in the league. Jay Cutler attempted throws of 20+ yards on 14.1% of his drop backs this year, which is the fifth highest rate in the league. About 28.2% of Brandon Marshall’s targets this year have been over 15 yards, so the downgrade from Cutler to Campbell really limits Marshall’s upside and big play ability. – Brett Talley (The Fantasy Fix)