"I have not tried Mad Men. I am not a big fan of that time period but I do know people think the show is very high quality."
If you like Buffy and Babylon do NOT watch Mad Men. You will be lost within 15 minutes.
because it takes a genius to watch a bunch of rich dudes smoke, drink, and cheat on their wives?
I think both shows are great for their genres. IMO, Mad Men is not made for binge watching. I have tried. that is one thing that I usually warn people about when they start the show.
Buffy is the smartest and coolest show that most guys think they are too manly to try. easily in my top 5 favorite shows.