Help Please! Rodgers or Wilson - I Need to Respond to Other Owner (1 Viewer)

[Helmet Head]

12 Team 1 Point PPR Redraft League

An owner has offered me my choice of either Aaron Rodgers or Russell Wilson in a trade.  Which of those two would you take and which one do you think will have a more productive rest of the season?

My current two QBs are Eli and Semien (we're only allowed a maximum of 2 QBs).  He's asking for DeMarco Murray.

I need a QB and he needs a RB.

My other RBs are:  CJ Anderson, Christine Michael, Isaiah Crowell, Spencer Ware, Devontae Booker.

Is giving up D. Murray worth getting either Rodgers or Wilson. 

I know he has others looking at his QBs in trade talks, so if you can let me know your thoughts sooner than later. 

Thanks!

HH

 

[Threedo]

i would not trade Murray he is having a killer year, try to give him Crowell.

 

[Helmet Head]

i would not trade Murray he is having a killer year, try to give him Crowell.

Believe me, I agree.  I have tried and tried, but he only wants Murray.

I should mention the following QBs are on the waiver wire:  Tyrod Taylor, Alex Smith, Ryan Tannehill, Brian Hoyer, and Brock Osweiler, 

Any thoughts about me dropping Semien and picking up one of these QBs?

Thanks,

HH

 

[Helmet Head]

Anyone else?

I hate to be "that guy" asking for immediate responses; however, I know this owner is actively discussing trade talk with a few others owners.  I hope to let him know sooner than later.

Any thoughts/help is appreciated.

Thanks,

HH

 

[Alkarius]

If you had to pick one, Rodgers is the better trade over Wilson. But I agree that you should not give up DeMarco Murray

 

[DesertCrawler]

I agree Rodgers is the guy. Murray is too rich though I think

 

[Helmet Head]

Thanks for the responses and I agree that it may be too much to give up Murray.

With that, what about any of those I mentioned that are on the waiver wire.  Stay put or target one of them?

Thanks again!

 

[Helmet Head]

Any others?  Would app excite some additional feedback. 

Thanks,

 

[walbridge20]

I would pull the trigger and swap Simieon for Tyrod because of his running and therefore upside. In a 2 QB league you need at least one stud or you are toast. Rodgers will be fine-and by fine I mean he will have more games like he had against the Lions than he will like against the Vikings. Yes Murray is lighting the league on fire right now, but if I told you the Titans would have a top 2 RB in the league at the end of the season-even right now-you'd ask for some of what I was smoking. I'll make it real simple for you: the Titans are bad. There is almost no way he can keep up this pace. Sure, he will be good-but those TDs are going to dry up and it wouldn't surprise me if it was sooner than later

 

[Helmet Head]

I would pull the trigger and swap Simieon for Tyrod because of his running and therefore upside. In a 2 QB league you need at least one stud or you are toast. Rodgers will be fine-and by fine I mean he will have more games like he had against the Lions than he will like against the Vikings. Yes Murray is lighting the league on fire right now, but if I told you the Titans would have a top 2 RB in the league at the end of the season-even right now-you'd ask for some of what I was smoking. I'll make it real simple for you: the Titans are bad. There is almost no way he can keep up this pace. Sure, he will be good-but those TDs are going to dry up and it wouldn't surprise me if it was sooner than later

Thanks for taking the time to write that.  Great info.

 

[DoseOfDopeness]

Rodgers but don't trade Murray

https://forums.footballguys.com/forum/topic/749648-trade-help-please-whir-update/