If he had stayed healthy, I highly doubt he would have been a top-3 RB despite the pace he was on.
Prior to his injury, during the 1st 6 1/2 games, he had 129.1 FP's out of the 135.4 produced by Miami's RB's, or about 95% of the points. After the injury, Miami's RB's (the stellar quintet of Chatman, Booker, Gado, Cobbs, and Williams) went on to produce another 146.4 FP's over the last 9 1/2 games. Do you really think he would not have had another 109.9 points, the amount he needed to finish 3rd? That's only 75% of what his replacements put up. I think he would have reached that easily.
I think what you just posted kind of supports the argument against Ronnie's elite production being due to his talent and not being a result of Cameron's schemes and play-calling.Ronnie Brown had 129.1 FP's over 6.5 games = 19.8 FP/game
Other Miami RB's had 146.4 FP's over 9.5 games = 15.4 FP/game
Obviously by your comment, you don't think very highly of Chatman, Booker, Gado, Cobbs, and Williams (and there really is nothing spectacular about them). Yet, they were STILL able to put up a hefty 15.4 FP/game (against tougher opponents as well). 15.4 FP/game over a 16 game season would have totaled 246 fantasy points or good enough for
#3 OVERALL among fantasy RB's. Not bad for a group of scrubs.
So, either those are much more talented RB's than we think or maybe a lot of it had to do with the "system" and Cam Cameron. The fact that a committee of career backup RB's (except Ricky who played a handful of plays anyway) could come in and produce at that kind of level with minimal dropoff overall says something. I'm not saying that it was ALL Cameron, but I think many Brown supporters are ignoring the major factor he played in his production last year.
ETA--- (rankings in yds allowed/game)
Ronnie's opponents over 6.5 games -- Wash (4th), Dallas (6th), NYJ (29th), Oak (31st), Houston (19th), Clev (27th), and 1/2 vs. NE (10th). (and vs. Wash and Dallas, he had 32 and 33 yds rushing respectively and 0 TDs)
Other Miami RB's over 9.5 games -- 1/2 vs. NE (10th), NYG (8th), Buff (25th), Philly (7th), Pitt (3rd), NYJ (29th), Buff (25th), Balt (2nd), NE (10th), Cincy (21st)
Ronnie got to run against 4 horrible run defenses (the 4 games he did well in). When he ran against 2 top 10 defenses in yds allowed, he was miserable. On the other hand, his counterparts had to face 6 top 10 defenses (counting NE twice) over 9.5 games and still managed a fantastic FP/game.