If you were starting an NFL franchise today (1 Viewer)

[Clifton]

Well

This should be a horse race.

 

[Truman]

If I start a franchise today, and assume my QB plays until 35, Eli will play for twice as long as Brady.

He'll also cost a helluva lot less, and I'll be able to invest those extra dollars in building an offensive line to protect my QB and/or some pass rushers to go after everyone else's.

 

[Godsbrother]

I would take Brady but I think this poll is weird. Why include Eli and Garrard but not other top young QBs like Roethlisberger, Rivers, Romo and Palmer?

 

[Anarchy99]

If I start a franchise today, and assume my QB plays until 35, Eli will play for twice as long as Brady.He'll also cost a helluva lot less, and I'll be able to invest those extra dollars in building an offensive line to protect my QB and/or some pass rushers to go after everyone else's.

Brady is 30. Eli is 27. Manning is younger, but I don't see him playing twice as long. And their body of work extends beyond the past few weeks.

 

[Jous]

Brady is much better than Manning as of now and is only 3 years older... Brady is the easy choice.

I think the Garrard choice is a little random though, why include a borderline at best top 10 QB who isn't even that young?

 

[dgreen]

I would take Brady but I think this poll is weird. Why include Eli and Garrard but not other top young QBs like Roethlisberger, Rivers, Romo and Palmer?

Because he's just trying to be funny.

 

[SR388]

Brady is much better than Manning as of now and is only 3 years older... Brady is the easy choice. I think the Garrard choice is a little random though, why include a borderline at best top 10 QB who isn't even that young?

I actually gave him a little thought. He really showed me a lot this year. He is tough and mobile, something the other two aren't.As of today, even with the recent SB, the only sane choice is Brady.

 

[Anarchy99]

As of today, even with the recent SB, the only sane choice is Brady.

Overall though, Peyton is only 31.

 

[switz]

Well This should be a horse race.

What was your vote? Personally, I'd take the other Manning over any of those three. But he wasn't an option.

 

[SSOG]

Roethlisberger.