GovTrack.us, an award-winning, non-partisan source of information on our legislators, has compiled a number of statistics related to bill sponsorship in the House and Senate. These statistics go back to 1997, and include such things as the number of bills sponsored, the number of sponsored bills that go to committee, and the number of sponsored bills that are passed into law. For the remainder of this analysis, I will be focusing solely on current senate Democrats who have completed at least one full term (I'm including Joseph Lieberman here, but not Bernie Sanders). There are 3938 such Senators in all. (The reason I'm excluding Republicans, FWIW, is that it's much easier to have one's bills become law when one's party controls the chamber, as the Republicans have for most of the past ten years. Therefore, it isn't fair to any Democrat to compare their numbers to a Republican).
Hillary Clinton has
introduced bills to the Senate at a blistering pace. She has sponsored 337 bills in her Senate tenure so far, or an average of 288.9 per term. This is the highest number of any of her Democratic cohorts:
- Clinton - 288.9 bills sponsored per term (337 in 1.17 terms)
- Feinstein - 288.8 bills sponsored per term (528 in 1.83 terms)
- Schumer - 218.2 bills sponsored per term (400 in 1.83 terms)
- Bingaman - 196.9 bills sponsored per term (361 in 1.83 terms)
- Boxer - 180.0 bills sponsored per term (330 in 1.83 terms)
AVERAGE - 122.1 bills sponsored per term
- Nelson/NE - 52.3 bills sponsored per term (61 in 1.17 terms)
- Byrd - 28.4 bills sponsored per term (52 in 1.83 terms)
Unfortunately, very little of this legislation has moved. Of Hillary's 337 bills, only 46 have made it to the Committee stage, giving her a 13.6% batting average; the typical Democrat has a 17.4% batting average. In other words, Hillary Clinton has been relatively ineffective at getting her sponsored bills to Committee; she ranks 24 of the 39 Democrats in this department.
- Byrd - 44.2% of bills sponsored went to committee (23 of 52)
- Biden - 42.7% of bills sponsored went to committee (93 of 218)
- Reid - 38.2% of bills sponsored went to committee (104 of 287)
- Akaka - 28.9% of bills sponsored went to committee (71 of 246)
- Kennedy - 25.8% of bills sponsored went to committee (83 of 322)
AVERAGE - 17.4% of bills sponsored went to committee
- Clinton - 13.6% of bills sponsored went to committee (46 of 337)
- Lincoln - 9.0% of bills sponsored went to committee (15 of 167)
- Nelson/NE - 6.6% of bills sponsored went to committee (4 of 61)
- Carper - 2.7% of bills sponsored went to committee (1 of 113)
Similarly, Hillary ranks poorly at converting bills that come out of Committee into law; only 2 of her 46 post-committee bills did so. This ranks 29th out of 3938 Democrats.
- Brown - 36.4% of bills sponsored out of committee became law (4 of 11)
- Carper - 33.3% of bills sponsored out of committee became law (1 of 3)
- Johnson - 30.0% of bills sponsored out of committee became law (6 of 20)
- Wyden - 25.0% of bills sponsored out of committee became law (8 of 32)
- Reed - 20.0% of bills sponsored out of committee became law (5 of 25)
AVERAGE - 9.8% of bills sponsored out of committee became law
- Clinton - 4.3% of bills sponsored out of committee became law (2 of 46
- Nelson/NE - 0.0% of bills sponsored out of committee became law (0 of 4)
- Kohl - 0.0% of bills sponsored out of committee became law (0 of 12)
- Nelson/FL - 0.0% of bills sponsored out of committee became law (0 of 26)
Combining these two things, we see that only 2 out of 337 bills she has sponsored have become law, or 0.6%. This is one of the worst numbers among the Democrats:
- Wyden - 4.8% of bills sponsored became law (8 of 165)
- Johnson - 4.3% of bills sponsored became law (6 of 138)
- Akaka - 4.1% of bills sponsored became law (10 of 246)
- Brown - 3.7% of bills sponsored became law (4 of 109)
- Reed - 3.0% of bills sponsored became law (5 of 146)
AVERAGE - 1.7% of bills sponsored became law
- Clinton - 0.6% of bills sponsored became law (2 of 337)
- Nelson/NE - 0.0% of bills sponsored became law (0 of 61)
- Kohl - 0.0% of bills sponsored became law (0 of 130)
- Nelson/FL - 0.0% of bills sponsored became law (0 of 133)
As a result, although Hillary has introduced bills at a faster pace than any of her colleagues, she has passed a below-average number of successful bills (e.g. bills that became law) -- just 2 over 7 years, or 1.7 per term.
- Feinstein - 6.0 bills became law per term (11 in 1.83 terms)
- Akaka - 5.5 bills became law per term (10 in 1.83 terms)
- Bingaman - 4.9 bills became law per term (9 in 1.83 terms)
- Dodd - 4.4 bills became law per term (8 in 1.83 terms)
- Kennedy - 4.4 bills became law per term (8 in 1.83 terms)
- Schumer - 4.4 bills became law per term (8 in 1.83 terms)
- Wyden - 4.4 bills became law per term (8 in 1.83 terms)
AVERAGE - 2.1 bills become law per term
- Clinton - 1.7 bills become law per term (2 in 1.17 terms)
- Nelson/FL - 0.0 bills become law per term (0 in 1.17 terms)
- Nelson/NE - 0.0 bills become law per term (0 in 1.17 terms)
- Kohl - 0.0 bills become law per term (0 in 1.83 terms)