Due to childhood trauma, I have the superpower of blunt, hyper criticism. These are my harsh observations:
The logo looks tattoo parlor-ish mixed with a little hipster steampunk. If that’s your jam, go for it. Personally, I like it.
Not in love with sugar skulls. Sounds like an all girls roller derby team.
Torcedar is difficult to say and spell. (My phone wants to auto-correct it). I would be steadfast against using anything that gets auto checked/corrected. With all that said, and although I’ve never heard of it, the cigar aficionado’s absolutely have so I like that aspect. Of the two names I like this one best.
Suggestion: The older I get, the less I am inclined to jump through any hoops to buy something. If you can manage to have an option that doesn’t require a sign up/password more people would buy. EVERYONE is tired of that. I know the pushback is the customer still needs to give their information, but that’s expected by the customer. I would still ask that they sign up, just give people the option to do that on their own time/down the line.
Just my two cents with love.