The disconnect for the fan base is this. We look at the roster as constituted and feel they went backwards talentwise this offseason (so far . . . still months away from suiting up for games). BB could be sitting there thinking he has a great roster and lots of players will make a seismic leap and perform better than last year. This year in particular that difference of opinion on the roster between fans and Bill is much greater than prior years. If the team still had Tom, fans would say Bill's gonna Bill and he never does much early in free agency. I get it, they don't have Tom, nor do they have as talented a roster as they normally would at this point (while many other teams do).
Their available salary cap space is always a mercurial thing. They have limited cap space THIS year, but OTC has them with $100M available in 2023 and $184M in 2024. Teams like the Bucs and Saints are already over the projected cap for next year (even projecting the cap going up) and still have half their rosters to fill out in those future seasons. Yes, the Patriots BY CHOICE are up against the cap. They could do any number of things to create more cap space (but they have elected not to go there).
As far as the coaching staff goes, Brian Hoyer is the real QB coach and responsible for Mac's development. Many people are suggesting that losing McDaniels is a gigantic loss. That remains to be seen. The playbook has been the same for decades, and the OC in NE (by title or someone serving that role) is essentially someone that calls plays. Bill doesn't want someone to come in and change the system. I still think there's a chance O'Brien will come back as OC. How many coaches have been poached over the years? The list is pretty extensive. On the surface, it looks daunting. But pull away the curtain, and the puppet master has, and always will be, BB.
It's clear that they played over their heads the middle of last year, and the last month of the season their deficiencies were exposed. I don't think they will end up as the #13 team in the AFC, but they certainly are a long way from being in the top tier of contenders.
I don't disagree with most of this, but I am just not buying this narrative (it is not yours) that many of the players are gonna take a seismic jump...let's look at the positions:
QB-I love Mac and he should be one that takes that leap...that being said they have done absolutely nothing to help him out so far this offseason...add an injury or two to a Henry, Bourne or Meyer and their weapons could be beyond dreadful...not giving Mac more weapons is easily my #1 gripe because his development is by far the most important thing this year...if he develops, they have a future.
RB-Best unit on the team. just hope the D is good enough to be able to maximize their strengths.
WR-subpar group and while I like Meyer and Bourne it is pushing it to count on them to take a big leap...Agholor could be better, but I don't see it being much better...if they don't add another quality WR (or two) either in the draft or free agency it will be a joke.
TE-I really like Henry but Jonnu did not show me anything last year that says he can take a big leap forward...physical skills are there but he just doesn't seems to get it but with those skills there is still hope...I am not even sure Keene and Asiasi are real people at this point.
O-Line-I thought this group underachieved last season and they have now lost two starters in Karras and Mason...there is some room for growth with Mike O but Wynn appears to be pretty much average and unreliable...if Brown goes down it could get real dicey...without Dante I just don't have faith they can just figure this position out like they used to.
CB-losing Jackson really hurts...after him you have a solid/quality CB in Jones and just an average at best group...if Wade turns into something that would be a huge score...the JoJuan Williams pick really hurts this unit...I don't think the fact the Pats struck gold with Butler and Jackson can be counted on as a smart strategy that they will do it again...just don't see them being in a favorable position playing against legit QBs like Allen.
Safety-Even with McCourty aging they have two good ones in the steady Phillips and Duggar who has a chance to be a real good one.
LB-anyone who has a clue about this group is full of BS...it is a complete unknown outside of Judon...Bentley is serviceable, but Hightower (if he stays) is pretty much done...there are some intriguing youngsters like Uche, Jennings, Wilson, McMillan, McGrone and Perkins but they are all question marks and none were "blue chip" prospects coming into the NFL...this is the area I will be watching closest as it could be anything from a complete disaster to a real nice surprise that pushes the rebuild faster.
D-Line-sneaky not good position...Barmore is a stud but after that it is an average at best group that doesn't have much upside IMO...guys like Wise, Cowart, Guy, Anderson and Godchaux simply are what they are.
Coaching staff-big questions here for the Assistants...great opportunity for some guys to advance their coaching career...I thought there were some real un-Patriot moments last season with regard to penalties, subbing and overall discipline...this group needs to tighten up.
Overall, I just don't see a path to being anything other than solid as the best case scenario (especially with a loaded AFC)...just too much has to go right and if they get some injuries to the wrong guys (ex. Henry, Trent Brown, Bourne, Barmore, Judon, Jonathan Jones) I just don't think they have the depth to recover from that...that being said I am good with that if they have another good draft, develop the youngsters currently on the team and are in a position to use next year's cap space (as well as taking the hit on this year's cap) to move forward and not to bandage holes due to bad drafting which was the case last season.