SSOG said:
Well this begs the question, how much is LT worth if the Chargers' run blocking is currently so putrid that the upshot of LT being fully healthy and quick/explosive is that big losses can be turned into short gains?
Actually, it raises the question. Also if a back can turn big losses into short gains, then he can just as easily turn short gains into big gains. Unless you think that the only running plays San Diego are ever going to run will naturally result in big losses if not for some herculean effort by the primary back.
I think davearm's concern about whether the Chargers' run-blocking will continue to suck, while overstated, is a legitimate one.In 2006, the line played really well --
especially the left side of the line with LT McNeil, LG Deilman, and C Hardwick. But RG Goff had a great season as well -- the only relative weakness was RT Shane Olivea, and he was fine as a run-blocker. (His trouble was pass-blocking.)
In 2007, the line was really inconsistent even though it returned all five starters. It started the year terribly, but eventually improved. Jeromey Clary started the last part of the season at RT when Olivea was hurt, and proved to be an upgrade. So the job was his to keep as the Chargers released Olivea the following offseason.
In 2008 the line was inconsistent again, but McNeil and Hardwick were playing through injuries. Goff got old and his play really fell off. So at least there was an excuse/explanation.
It's 2009. Coming into the season, the line had four of the same five starters that it had when it played well at the end of 2007, and everyone was healthy. The new starter at RG, even though he was an unproven rookie (third-round draft pick Luis Vasquez), was sure to be an upgrade over the 2008 version of Goff. So it looked like everything was cool.
But they came out really flat against the Raiders. It was like the beginning of 2007 again. Then C Hardwick and RG Vasquez got hurt, and the Chargers had to scramble to fill their spots. (The top backup guard was also the backup center; so to fill the RG spot they turned to an inexperienced tackle who'd never played guard before.)
Predictably, the OL has struggled over the past two games. But what's really weird -- and disappointing -- is that the left side of the line manned by Pro Bowlers McNeil and Dielman has struggled as much as the right side. Getting Vasquez back at RG this week should help since Dombrowski was clearly over his head. But (a) it's not a good sign when you're counting on a rookie to provide a big improvement in the OL play; and (b) even if Vasquez plays really well, that won't fix whatever's wrong with McNeil and Dielman.
I don't think the line will stay sucky all season. I'm hoping it will be like 2007 when they eventually played much better after a terrible start. But it's hard to say. It's quite possible that they'll just continue to suck this year. That possibility should reduce fantasy owners' enthusiasm for Tomlinson at least somewhat.