Fantasy Football - Footballguys Forums
This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
Is Matt Schaub attainable? (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter jestertj
- Start date
Texasmouth
Footballguy
Probably wont happen. Vick is too injury prone for Atlanta to let him go in my opinion.
Bears_Man2
Footballguy
Don't think they'll deal him. I think it'd take a 1st rounder for them to consider anything.
Texasmouth
Footballguy
No way Schaub should command a 1st rounder if Culpepper could be had for a 2nd rounder........
Either way, I don't think it will be easy to get him out of Atlanta. I would bet the second he can leave, he will. It must be hard watching a guy play that you know you are better than......
Either way, I don't think it will be easy to get him out of Atlanta. I would bet the second he can leave, he will. It must be hard watching a guy play that you know you are better than......
diesel7982
Footballguy
Lets see:Younger? check
MUCH MUCH cheaper? check
Not coming off a devestating knee injury? check
The third reason combined with the second is why Schaub is worth more than Pepper.
diesel7982
Footballguy
If you really need that answered...So that's why Patrick Ramsey's worth a 1st rounder?
redman
Footballguy
LOL @ "need it answered." What's needed is improvement on your analysis. A player's worth is measured by more than the health of his knee and his age. I happen to like Shaub as a prospect, but that's all he is. Unlike Ramsey, he's not had the games to really demonstrate his abilities, and even Ramsey's considered raw at this point despite playing for twice as many years and roughly 10 times as many snaps and starts.If you really need that answered...So that's why Patrick Ramsey's worth a 1st rounder?
A trade of high draft picks for him at this point would seem silly in light of the market value for others out there who have an actual track record to look at. While Shaub may end up better, this looks a lot like the Scott Mitchell trade from Miami to Detroit prospectively.
EBF
Footballguy
I'm going to side with Diesel here. Ramsey has already failed once as an NFL starter, whereas Schaub has looked great every step of the way. If I were an NFL GM then I'd definitely deal a first rounder for him.LOL @ "need it answered." What's needed is improvement on your analysis. A player's worth is measured by more than the health of his knee and his age. I happen to like Shaub as a prospect, but that's all he is. Unlike Ramsey, he's not had the games to really demonstrate his abilities, and even Ramsey's considered raw at this point despite playing for twice as many years and roughly 10 times as many snaps and starts.If you really need that answered...So that's why Patrick Ramsey's worth a 1st rounder?
A trade of high draft picks for him at this point would seem silly in light of the market value for others out there who have an actual track record to look at. While Shaub may end up better, this looks a lot like the Scott Mitchell trade from Miami to Detroit prospectively.
diesel7982
Footballguy
Is Ramsey going to start for Washington? NoIs Ramsey going to backup Brunell? NoLOL @ "need it answered." What's needed is improvement on your analysis. A player's worth is measured by more than the health of his knee and his age. I happen to like Shaub as a prospect, but that's all he is. Unlike Ramsey, he's not had the games to really demonstrate his abilities, and even Ramsey's considered raw at this point despite playing for twice as many years and roughly 10 times as many snaps and starts.If you really need that answered...So that's why Patrick Ramsey's worth a 1st rounder?
A trade of high draft picks for him at this point would seem silly in light of the market value for others out there who have an actual track record to look at. While Shaub may end up better, this looks a lot like the Scott Mitchell trade from Miami to Detroit prospectively.
Washington has no leverage to demand a 1st round pick for Ramsey, who has failed as a starter twice in this league.
Schaub is a crucial backup for ATL who has succeeded in his opportunities to be a #1 guy. He is younger, and looks to be more talented than Ramsey.
If you cant see why Schaub would demand a higher pick, I dont know what to say...
Texasmouth
Footballguy
I am not going to trash Schaub since I think he is a great prospect but to compare his limited action to what Culpepper has done is a little silly.
Schaub career 66/134 for 825 yards and 5TD/4INT
Schaub career 66/134 for 825 yards and 5TD/4INT
the simplest point is that once a team says they won't be keeping player X, his value goes down. There might be some superstar exception but....Ramsey will be given to some team. Schaub will have to be pried away.Is Ramsey going to start for Washington? NoIs Ramsey going to backup Brunell? NoLOL @ "need it answered." What's needed is improvement on your analysis. A player's worth is measured by more than the health of his knee and his age. I happen to like Shaub as a prospect, but that's all he is. Unlike Ramsey, he's not had the games to really demonstrate his abilities, and even Ramsey's considered raw at this point despite playing for twice as many years and roughly 10 times as many snaps and starts.If you really need that answered...So that's why Patrick Ramsey's worth a 1st rounder?
A trade of high draft picks for him at this point would seem silly in light of the market value for others out there who have an actual track record to look at. While Shaub may end up better, this looks a lot like the Scott Mitchell trade from Miami to Detroit prospectively.
Washington has no leverage to demand a 1st round pick for Ramsey, who has failed as a starter twice in this league.
Schaub is a crucial backup for ATL who has succeeded in his opportunities to be a #1 guy. He is younger, and looks to be more talented than Ramsey.
If you cant see why Schaub would demand a higher pick, I dont know what to say...
