Is Plaxico Burress the Jets #1 Fantasy WR this year? (1 Viewer)

[DevilintheDetail]

So far, Plaxico looks like a bigger weapon and at least as important a part of the offense as Santonio Holmes. Will he continue to post better fantasy stats, especially given his prominence in the red zone?

 

[DeaLerZ]

Plaxico will most likely if he stays healthy get more TD's than Santonio Holmes because he is a big redzone target, somewhere in the 8-10 TD range, but will only end up in the 50-60 rec range... however Holmes will be much more consistent, and will have around 80 rec.....but more in the 6-8 TD range..... really just depends on your leagues scoring on which player is more valuable

I tend to think Consistency is far more valuable and would definitely take Holmes

 

[DevilintheDetail]

Plaxico will most likely if he stays healthy get more TD's than Santonio Holmes because he is a big redzone target, somewhere in the 8-10 TD range, but will only end up in the 50-60 rec range... however Holmes will be much more consistent, and will have around 80 rec.....but more in the 6-8 TD range..... really just depends on your leagues scoring on which player is more valuable

I tend to think Consistency is far more valuable and would definitely take Holmes

So far, despite being new to the offense, Burress has been more consistent than Holmes (TDs in 2/3 games rather than 1/3, # of receptions in a tighter variance range). Why do you expect Holmes to be more consistent?