Is this Keeper league trade fair ? (1 Viewer)

[Outkast]

OK so real quick in a 10 team Keeper League this trade was proposed & accepted 2 weeks ago:

A trades Kellen Winslow, Cle TE to B

B trades Owen Daniels, Hou TE to A

B trades Derrick Mason, Bal WR to A

So not too bad right?

==================================

& this trade has just been accepted this week:

A trades Braylon Edwards, Cle WR to B

B trades Patrick Crayton, Dal WR to A

B trades Chris Henry, Ten RB to A

To me this is unfair & complete BS

=========================================

The kicker is B is the COMMISH & only he can VETO any trades

What do you think? Fair or Unfair?

 

[Steve in Minneapolis]

It is hard to say without knowing a lot more about keeper rules and rosters...but although the trade may appear to be lopsided, I don't see it as obvious collusion.

Don't dog on your commish just b/c he got a good deal on the trade.

 

[OddibeMcD]

I can predict every response you get...

Who cares if it is fair??? You don't veto trades merely on your perception of fairness.

OR

If Braylon blows out an ACL next week and you didn't let the trade through, what are you going to say then? The other owner should be screwed because people in the league don't want to see a trade that doesn't help them?

OR

This is not blatant collusion. Only veto trades when it is blatant collusion. This is not blatant collusion.

 

[proninja]

Someone please move this to the non-Patriots forum

 

[PatsWillWin]

Someone please move this to the non-Patriots forum

 

[Jack Burton]

Both those trades are one sided in the favor of team A for sure but... do you have evidence that collusion is involved?

Does the owner of team B make a lot of bad trades?

 

[Utter Chaos]

Both those trades are one sided in the favor of team A for sure but... do you have evidence that collusion is involved? Does the owner of team B make a lot of bad trades?

How can they be in favor of team A when it's team B that's getting Winslow and Edwards?I agree it looks like more information is needed before determining if they are fair or not. One thing to consider is that how much longer will Derek Anderson be the QB for Cleveland. Maybe Edwards and Winslow would not be as good with Brady Quinn in there. While they appear to be one sided now who knows what Chris Henry will do in the future. He is certainley capable of being a stud WR.

 

[faulkfan]

I love those trades!

 

[-OZ-]

Both those trades are one sided in the favor of team A for sure but... do you have evidence that collusion is involved?

Does the owner of team B make a lot of bad trades?

How can they be in favor of team A when it's team B that's getting Winslow and Edwards?I agree it looks like more information is needed before determining if they are fair or not. One thing to consider is that how much longer will Derek Anderson be the QB for Cleveland. Maybe Edwards and Winslow would not be as good with Brady Quinn in there. While they appear to be one sided now who knows what Chris Henry will do in the future. He is certainley capable of being a stud WR.

Maybe Fisher should change him to WR? "Fair?" - no

That is what you asked, not if you should try to overturn.