Maybe Drinen or Stuart could answer, but I wonder how many RBs have become top-10 in their third season after getting at least 200 carries in their first two seasons and finishing both years outside of the top-20. I suspect the list is going to be very small. Heck, I wonder how many RBs have *EVER* become top-10 after finishing with at least 200 carries in their first two seasons and failing both times to crack the top-20.
I don't have any numbers to back this up (and I really hope someone shows up with the numbers, because I'm honestly curious), but my initial thought was that if Ronnie Brown was going to break out, he would have done it already.
OK, so I ran the numbers using the Historical Data Dominator. Here's what I found.....Since 1960, there have been only 40 RB's to have at least 200 carries in their first two seasons in the league, that includes R. Brown & C. Williams who are both entering their 3rd year.
-NONE of the RB's that had at least 200 carries in their first two seasons did NOT finished in the top 20 in fantasy scoring in either of those years EXCEPT for Ronnie Brown. The next closest was Cadillac, but he finished #19 his rookie year.
-Only 4 of these backs besides Brown & Williams have finished below 15th in each of their first two years. Here's how they finished in their 3rd year:
Sammie Smith - #68
Ricky Williams - #8
John Stephens - #25
Ronald Moore - #74
-As you can see, Ricky Williams is the only back to have cracked the top 10 after two sub 15 seasons (he was 27 & 18 his first two).
Some other analysis of the 3rd year of these other 38 RB's:
The average ranking in year 3 is
10.92 spots LOWER than their year 2 rankings.
The average year 3 point totals are
21% LOWER than the point totals in year 2.
It doesn't look good for any 3rd year back who has carried a significant load in their first two seasons. The numbers do not appear to be in favor of Ronnie Brown, but then again there is always a chance he is the second to really step it up in year 3.