Is this trade as good as it looks? (1 Viewer)

[Irish3]

My squad below in a 16-team league with 1 PPR scoring. Starting lineup requirements:
1 QB
1 RB
2 WRs
1 TE
2 Flex (RB, WR or TE)
1 K
1 DEF

My team
QBs- Fields and Levis
RBs- Jonathan Taylor, Jaylen Warren and Zeke
WRs- Evans, McLaurin, Hopkins, Lockett, Boyd and Michael Wilson
TEs- Kmet, Hunter Henry and Otton
K- Tucker and Myers
Def- Seahawks and Titans

Trade-
I give up Jonathan Taylor, Lockett and Hunter Henry
I get Kyler Murray, Tony Pollard, and James Cook

Thoughts? Do you make that trade? In my eyes, I don't need Henry, Pollard is as good as Taylor, and I can replace Lockett with Cook and basically get Murray for Henry, who has major upside at QB, especially with Fields still not ready. I feel this is such a good deal I should've hit accept immediately, no?

 

[Irish3]

Appreciate anyone throwing in their 2 cents. Thx

 

[Gally]

I like the trade but I am a Kyler believer (as far as FF is concerned)

 

[Irish3]

I like the trade but I am a Kyler believer (as far as FF is concerned)

Agreed, anytime he's played, he seems to kill it. And he's usually matchup proof because of his running ability. I know I already have Fields, but who knows what he'll be like when he eventually returns because of the thumb issue. Plus he has his bye week during the playoffs.

 

[Irish3]

Any others would be greatly appreciated.

 

[Irish3]

Looking to pull the trigger on this deal today. Any last thoughts?

 

[1320kid]

I’d do this. Good luck!

 

[Tackierfern]

Yeah I think this is worth it. I'd do it as well.

 

[Irish3]

I just grabbed Russell Wilson off the WW as someone dropped him for a defense. So I have Fields and Wilson at QB, instead of Levis.

However, I still think getting Murray could be an upgrade over Wilson and maybe even Fields, especially if Fields never comes back right this season. I also think the duo of Pollard and Cook are better than Taylor and Lockett. Could be wrong though. Either way, getting Murray for basically Henry is crazy.

 

[Gally]

I just grabbed Russell Wilson off the WW as someone dropped him for a defense. So I have Fields and Wilson at QB, instead of Levis.

I would rather have kept Levis. We know what Wilson is and he is not a league winner anymore. Levis has the higher upside and I would rather have that as my 2nd QB

 

[Irish3]

I just grabbed Russell Wilson off the WW as someone dropped him for a defense. So I have Fields and Wilson at QB, instead of Levis.

I would rather have kept Levis. We know what Wilson is and he is not a league winner anymore. Levis has the higher upside and I would rather have that as my 2nd QB

Thx for the feedback. No one grabbed Levis to this point, so there's always a possibility to scoop him back up.

 

[skbatmen]

I’d make the trade in a quick minute.

 

[Irish3]

I’d make the trade in a quick minute.

That's how I felt at first. Then I started debating how rough Pollard has been, along with Cook. I'd kick myself if Taylor was a stud and Pollard and cook continued to suck.

Thx for chiming in.