J.Garcia or D.Garrard who has the better season (1 Viewer)

[Thumper]

Rotoworld listed Garrard as the 15th best qb option in the league. While I like Garrard's ability to run. He has almost no weapons to throw the ball to. I just don't get that high of a ranking.

Garcia has weapons that are somewhat better,but he is not a threat at all to run. He should be an upgrade over the qb play in Tampa last year. (2,643 171 11td's 16 int's)

This is for the 3rd spot on my team. Who do you think has more potential?

 

[Jason Wood]

Garrard is the more mobile QB at this stage of their respective careers, but saying Garcia is no threat to run the ball ignores his considerable NFL resume.

Rushing Yards per Game: 18.9 (Garcia) vs. 22.0 (Garrard)
Rushing TDs per Game: 0.24 (Garcia) vs. 0.21 (Garrard)
Yards per Rush: 4.72 (Garcia) vs. 5.54 (Garrard)

 

[moderated]

Garrard is the more mobile QB at this stage of their respective careers, but saying Garcia is no threat to run the ball ignores his considerable NFL resume.

Rushing Yards per Game: 18.9 (Garcia) vs. 22.0 (Garrard)
Rushing TDs per Game: 0.24 (Garcia) vs. 0.21 (Garrard)
Yards per Rush: 4.72 (Garcia) vs. 5.54 (Garrard)

Are you using games where Garrard only came in for a series or two? With such a small sample calculating games in where he just came in while Leftwich was out a series will make his PPG stats misleading.